PDA

View Full Version : Big Decisions for Harry Redknapp over Ledley King and Jonathan Woodgate


mawspurs
25-06-2010, 11:23 AM
Source: Football Fan House

Tottenham upset the odds to clinch their place in the Champions League last season. What was even more impressive was they did it despite suffering injuries to several key players along the way. Luka Modric, Vedran Corluka, Aaron Lennon and Jermain Defoe all had lengthy spells on the sidelines.

But two players spent longer on the treatment table than others, notably Ledley King and Jonathan Woodgate.

If the two centre-backs were fit they would probably be, not only the first choice pairing for Spurs, but also give John Terry and Rio Ferdinand a run for their money in the England squad.

There can be no doubt that King is a fantastic player when fully fit. He is strong, quick and dependable. Woodgate on the other hand compliments King in the sense he is a better passer of the ball and a calming influence at the back. Together they are an ideal pairing.

However, King's chronic knee problem and Woodgate's groin injury shows no signs of abating, so it could be unlikely we see the two in action together again.

King's knee injury is tolerated by Spurs. He undergoes intensive training in the swimming pool and is allowed extra rest in between matches so the club can get as many games out of him as possible each season.

Yet while he is carrying an injury, it makes him more susceptible to other problems, such as the groin injury he sustained against the USA at the World Cup.

Even the club's manager Harry Redknapp admitted he felt the 29-year-old's tournament was over as a result of the problem.

While Tottenham accommodate King's injury problems, Woodgate has been cast aside. The former Real Madrid defender is reportedly at a low ebb as medics are baffled by his groin problem.

Woodgate, 30, has undergone a hernia operation and further surgery to cure the problem. He did make a return to action in he 9-1 victory over Wigan on 22nd November, but that proved to be the last of his three appearances in the 2009/10 campaign.

Redknapp has sympathy for the defender's plight. He said in May: "He [Woodgate] texts me all the time - he has been very low, obviously.

"Can you imagine what his life has been like? He has treatment all day and he is doing recovery work. He is a great lad, a top bloke, but his problem is that nobody can get to the bottom of his injury. Woody has had a nightmare."

But while Redknapp has sympathy for his two crocked defenders, he also knows he needs to have players who can play week in, week out if they are to repeat their success of last season.

Michael Dawson, Younes Kaboul and Sebastien Bassong are all good players in their own right, but even Redknapp must realise he needs another strong defender in his squad.

He will also need to make a big decision about Woodgate, for while he may feel for the defender, the club cannot afford for him to miss another season.

It could therefore, be time for Redknapp to do the unwelcome task of releasing a player due to injury. He won't relish the task but Spurs have to move on without Woodgate.

tommyt
25-06-2010, 11:41 AM
Hope he recovers in time for second half of the season....excellent player

WhiteHeartLowe
25-06-2010, 11:44 AM
[quote=mawspurs;1860080]Source: Football Fan House


Yet while he is carrying an injury, it makes him more susceptible to other problems, such as the groin injury he sustained against the USA at the World Cup.

While Tottenham accommodate King's injury problems, Woodgate has been cast aside.

I think these two statements are complete BS. Having a cronic knee injury can not have had any bearing upon Ledley sustaining a strained groin muscle, any player could have sustained an injury like that at any time, also, Woodgate has hardly been 'cast aside', the club has done everything possible to get his problem sorted, sending him to specialists all over the world, and continue to do so.

StokeSpur
25-06-2010, 12:29 PM
[quote=mawspurs;1860080]Source: Football Fan House


Yet while he is carrying an injury, it makes him more susceptible to other problems, such as the groin injury he sustained against the USA at the World Cup.

While Tottenham accommodate King's injury problems, Woodgate has been cast aside.

I think these two statements are complete BS. Having a cronic knee injury can not have had any bearing upon Ledley sustaining a strained groin muscle, any player could have sustained an injury like that at any time, also, Woodgate has hardly been 'cast aside', the club has done everything possible to get his problem sorted, sending him to specialists all over the world, and continue to do so.

How can it be 'bs' ?? It says 'it makes him more susceptiple' to other problems, i would have thought it was obvious that if someone cant train fully they will pick up other niggling injurys easier than someone who is training and fully fit.

Todays game is very demanding on the body and pro footballers need to be at peak fitness all the time, if ledders didnt have a bad knee and could train properly his groin and other parts of the body would be stronger and there for be able to withstand more.

Isnt that obvious?

Re: woodgate. thats just stupid what he wrote and everyone knows it.

robbo_spur
25-06-2010, 01:02 PM
Harry Redknapp said on Talksport after Ledley's injury that his lack of training makes him more suscpetible to injuries unrelated to his knee.

felmonger
25-06-2010, 01:40 PM
Let us face facts.

1. Ledders and Woody are great players but both are injury prone and both are getting towards the end of their career.

2. The up-coming season is too important for Spurs to rely on either of them being available to play. And it is quite likely that Dawson, Bassong and Kaboul will get some sort of injury and/or be suspended during a long season.

If we do not want to pretend that Vedran or Tom are central defenders we must bring in at least one high class centre back. And if one of the kids, (the two Kyles and Dorian Dervite) are not going to make it into the first team squad this season then we probably should be looking to bring in a second seasoned centre back..

JoeT
25-06-2010, 05:27 PM
If the club is really serious about next season they will have to solve this dillemma with a purchase of a top-notch centre-back. Gary Cahill would be my candidate.

fatspur
25-06-2010, 06:41 PM
However, King's chronic knee problem and Woodgate's groin injury shows no signs of abating, so it could be unlikely we see the two in action together again.

definitely maybe then!

davidmatzdorf
25-06-2010, 06:42 PM
Woodgate was virtually injury free for 2-3 years before this groin problem happened. If they can solve that and he can play normally, then it won't be an issue and I wouldn't think he'd be anywhere near the end of his career - he could play at a high level for another 4-5 years.

If they can't fix it, it wouldn't surprise me if he retired - and obviously then we would need another high quality central defender.

But I'd be surprised if the club made any decisions or spent any money until the situation with Woodgate is clear.

JoeT
25-06-2010, 06:54 PM
I agree with you D.M. but it would be nice to know the situation as early as possible so that we could look for another high quality centre-back.

Ravabelly
25-06-2010, 09:24 PM
difficult one. If we go into the season still unclear over Woody's future and with King no worse than the end of last season/the WC, I would look to sign an experienced CB who accepts he won't necessarily play every game but is there to help the rest and perform whenever needed. Similar to a degree to when Naybet signed, and Davids but obviously in a different position. An ideal candidate would be Sol Campbell but that will never happen but a 33-36 year old CB, English or otherwise, would be ideal whilst there is serious doubt over how many games these two will play.

I don't think the need is immediate though. King can be managed, to play at least 75% of our games next season I would presume. Daws deserves to be first choice CB at the start of next season, Bassong hasn't let us down and, although the jury is out on Kaboul, in my opinion, he finished the season well for us when the pressure was on and I'd be happy to persevere.

KenilworthSpur
26-06-2010, 11:21 PM
King signing a new contract is a sign that Harry isn't ready to dump him just yet