I can remember people leveling exactly this kind of criticism at Klopp for signing Wijnaldum, Shaqiri and Robertson because they’d come from Newcastle, Stoke and a relegated Hull respectively.
Didn’t work out too badly, in hindsight.
what a bizarre argument
You’ve picked 3 random players that worked out well that have absolutely nothing to do with judging the specific player we are discussing on his own talents
Shall I now pick one of the thousands of footballers over the years that people had doubts about that turned out to be as poor as expected to counter?
Let’s stick to discussing whether Hojbjerg might be a good signing based on his own talents not because Wijnaldum turned out to be a good signing!