What's new

Ratings V Fulham

MOTM


  • Total voters
    249

Chris12

Well-Known Member
Mar 6, 2013
7,293
13,252
Just watched the game as I could only listen to it last night and we were nowhere near as bad as some are making out!

I expect Fulham to get out of trouble now that Jol has gone and it was always going to be tough at a place where it's a new managers first game.

The main pictures don't do Vlad's strike justice when you see it from behind Vlad it is so beautifully struck, wonderful technique!
how do you rewatch it?
 

finch101

Member
Jun 4, 2007
146
9
Lloris- 9: Made some top class reflex stops and another day Berbatov would of scored 1-2
Walker- 7 Great energy down the right, starting to hit some form
Dawson- 5 Battled well and you could see his leadership qualities out there, poor on the ball though, looking forward to Kaboul getting back to his best and Daws hitting the bench.
Chiriches-8 Looked solid, amazing tekkers for his goal.
Vertonghen 6- Struggled both defensively and in an attacking sense.
Capoue- 5- Looked cumbersome and out fought from small guys a few times, he will come good in the new year.
Sandro- 7- Good tell he was really trying to up the tempo in the midfield but it's not his natural game. Did well though
Paulinho- 6- Was okay, expected more from him so far though.
Lennon- 6.5 Dangerous on the right, ineffective on the left. Deserves his place in the side when on the right.
Lamela- 5 Poor first half, poor touches and passes. Second half he gave it away less, was disappointing though. Do feel many guys on here, due to willing him to do well, are seeing his performances through rose tinted glasses.
Defoe- 5 As always struggles on his own up top, that said he looked more dangerous up there than Soldado has in most games.

Holtby- 8 Tried to get the tempo up when he came on, great goal.
Chadli- Did he do anything? AVB clearly rates and trusts him.
Townsend- Tried to get on the ball, wish he would move the ball quicker, he doesn't need to run with/try and skin ppl every time he has the ball.

AVB-4: Starting Sandro and Capeou? Didn't need to do that, especially how slow and ponderous our build up has been to date. Thought Lamela should of come off earlier and personally would of put 2 up top at some stage. The long range worldies ARE MASSIVELY PAPERING OVER THE CRACKS.

CHANGE IN FORMATION NEEDED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

Alfieconnman

Ticket seller for the Dome of Doom
Aug 9, 2008
1,142
151
I always vote but rarely post on this thread. It is always interesting (amusing?) to see some of the variations in points awarded to individual players by posters which often clearly reflect their feelings about the player generally rather than an accurate assessment of their actual performance in the match. Daws has come in for particular negative attention recently. My feelings about him are ambivalent - he always gives heart and soul and never shirks a hard challenge but does suffer badly from his lack of pace. However, his situation is not helped by the frequent total absence of any support from Walker. I'm not anti-Walker and readily agree that he adds a strong attacking benefit but time and time again in the match last night Fulham were launching attacks down their left wing and Walker was nowhere to be seen. As a consequence Daws is left without much, if any, support on the RHS. This is not an excuse for his other frailties, merely an observation.
 

Blake Griffin

Well-Known Member
Oct 3, 2011
14,158
38,391
i see double standards defoe is in full flow, soldado puts in that performance and it's 7s all round.
 

Bus-Conductor

SC Supporter
Oct 19, 2004
39,837
50,713
i see double standards defoe is in full flow, soldado puts in that performance and it's 7s all round.

Really ?

v ManU

Soldado - This was the moment. Our tails were up, already winning, a slick move sees our chance famished 26m striker played in to score the goal that ignites his and our season. Oh dear. Maybe next week.

v City

Soldado - meh.

v Newc

Soldado - He's trying hard, nice dummy for Eriksen's chance, but I wouldn't mind seeing Adebayor have a go next game. On days like today he also needs to work their defenders a bit better when they have the ball.
 

markieboy

Well-Known Member
Aug 1, 2013
1,356
1,471
As a side note I really think Paulinho was just as culpable as Dawson for the balls up that led to their goal.
There are a few times every game when he just isn't strong enough or determined enough to make sure he gets/keeps the ball instead of going down easily looking for the referee to save him.
For him to really be a very good player at this level he needs to work on being a second or two quicker when the ball comes to him and do a bit of work with weights to beef up a bit.
He gets himself into really good positions in and around the box and once the goals start flowing for him,I really think he will go on to get plenty for us.
 

davidmatzdorf

Front Page Gadfly
Jun 7, 2004
18,106
45,030
Lloris 8.5 best goalkeeper in the league

Walker 7.5 excellent all-round game

Dawson 6 other than the crap pass that set up Fulham's goal, he played OK

Chiriches 8 we're going to have to put up with the occasional defensive aberration stemming from over-confidence, but he's a class act and looks increasingly comfortable in the Premiership

Vertonghen 6

Sandro 6 half of a double pivot that didn't do what it was supposed to do

Capoue 5.5 amazingly, got bustled off the ball by Fulham's midfielders

Paulinho 6 good performance let down by bad finishing

Lennon 6.5 almost back to his full-fitness form

Lamela 5.5 I'm not seeing what many others saw last night - most of the time, he still got knocked off the ball before he could do anything useful with it - Lamela sets off on all sorts of enterprising runs, but he almost never gets to deliver the ball

Defoe 6.5 played much better than people seem to think, including two genuinely creative passes in the first half - got into good positions, but the ball never really came in, at least not accurately


Holtby 7.5 great goal, good energy and running in an otherwise unstructured midfield lacking a DM

Chadli 6

Townsend 6
 

Legend10

Well-Known Member
Jul 8, 2006
10,847
5,277
i see double standards defoe is in full flow, soldado puts in that performance and it's 7s all round.

Very true, the comments about Defoe in this thread are very myopic.

He created 2 good chances, pulled a good save from Stekelenberg and got away 1 on 1 where he probably should have scored, the rest of his game was ok, not great not bad.

How many times this season could we summarise Soldado like that?

Personally I prefer Soldado but there's so little between what either of them are currently doing it's bizarre that one is slaughtered and one is in the main defended.
 

Spurs 1961

Well-Known Member
Aug 31, 2012
6,683
8,754
As a side note I really think Paulinho was just as culpable as Dawson for the balls up that led to their goal.
There are a few times every game when he just isn't strong enough or determined enough to make sure he gets/keeps the ball instead of going down easily looking for the referee to save him.
For him to really be a very good player at this level he needs to work on being a second or two quicker when the ball comes to him and do a bit of work with weights to beef up a bit.
He gets himself into really good positions in and around the box and once the goals start flowing for him,I really think he will go on to get plenty for us.
Paulinho is a key player for us since he is the only one who really links the team. But I think many people are correct, he needs a rest. Remember he not only plays every time for us but plays all the games for Brazil and travels thousands of miles with them as well.
 

jezz

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2013
5,651
8,654
Yeah and you can also see how many Fulham created too.
Yes its the EPL other teams are going to create chances thats how it works.
Im just glad were creating chances, all thats left is to start scoring them.
 

Bus-Conductor

SC Supporter
Oct 19, 2004
39,837
50,713
I think if I go through it all, it will just be going over very old ground, so don't see the point. All I can say is that if AVB wants us to play out from the back in a possession-based approach, then he needs to drum into the players the concept of 'pass and move', and if they are unwilling or unable to do this then he needs to ship them out and find some players that can.

I'll give one example to sum it up. First half Chiriches is bringing the ball out from the back. No options, so keeps coming. Lamela and Vertonghen are both within 15 yards of him, and both standing pinned to the touchline. All it takes to offer him a passing option is for Lamela to come inside, bringing his marker with him and then lay it off round the corner for Vertonghen to run onto the ball into the space vacated. Neither make a move. Ball gets pinged to feet in the tightest area imaginable and we lose the ball. Happened more than once down that side. All players are guilty though, there was one occasion where Dawson was bringing the ball out, was pleading for an option... there is a big space twenty yards up the pitch, all it takes is Lennon to make a run 10 yards inside to free himself and receive it in space. He stands on the spot.

No-one appreciates what they are meant to be doing and how we move up the pitch as a unit, with the ball. One of the worst examples is midway through the second half where all three of Sandro, Paulinho and Holtby come to get the ball off of Dawson. Absolutely amateur.

It simply has to get better.

EDIT: This tinkering with the team also has to stop. Lamela, Holtby, Chadli, Sigurdsson, Defoe, Kaboul and more all in and out over recent weeks. Players cant find form or the team develop an understanding if there are changes every week. Yes you might want to tweak the set-up for specific games, but not to the amount we are seeing. Decide a team and shape AVB and give it time to settle. No more scrabbling around using all possible combinations, time to make a choice.

Lloris - Three very good saves. A return to top form. Motm for me.

Walker - Good game.

Dawson - Oh dear. Responsible for the goal with a horrendously inept bit of play. That's just one mistake though, you can be most scathing about what should be his bread and butter at centre back... He gave Berbatov far too much time and space all game and was lucky nothing more came of it. Who gets carted off to the knackers yard first, him or Kaboul? We shall see.

Chiriches - Was guilty a few times of overplaying and giving the ball away in reasonably dangerous areas, an Ok performance though which was capped by the goal which got us back into the match.

Vertonghen - Average. Looks completely fucked off with life, which is concerning. Whilst Dawson is at fault for the goal, I have no idea why he was that far forward when the ball was being played out on the opposite side of the pitch. Having said all that, lets hope he isn't out for any significant amount of time.

Sandro - Ok. Not exactly bad, not exactly beastly either though.

Capoue - Ditto.

Lennon - A couple of bright moments that led to nothing, however Defoe did pinch a cross he fizzed in that Lamela was running onto in all fairness. Pretty Lennon-esque performance.

Paulinho - Gets himself up in support, but has been too wayward with his shooting this season and his passing isn't his strongest facet either. Is getting run into the ground, which isn't his fault. Needs to do better though.

Lamela - Is erratic but offers the few glimpses of real potential. Little give and go's, moving the ball quickly etc and getting away from a marker. I think he needs to play at No.10 position, simply so we can get him more involved in areas where he can have most impact.

Defoe - It wasn't his worst game ever, but we have seen it all before over 10 years and it isn't going to get any better. Wasted a couple of good opportunities too, which is what he is in the team to do. He also seems clueless about where to find space and what runs to make as a lone striker. Lets stop with this tinkering AVB, yeah?

Subs:

Holtby - Cracking goal, a good pass for Lennon down the line, an accurate cross onto Paulinho's head... Which will catch the eye of the majority... In between a lot of infuriating stuff. As I said last night, he is possibly our worst player for composure when we are chasing the game, I lost count of the amount of times he fizzed an overambitious pass towards a Spurs man or went all out for the hail mary pass. Enthusiasm needs to be channelled into something consistent, lets hope he can mature quickly because there is talent there.

Townsend - Didn't get into the game really, was handy to have him on to take the ball towards the corner flag late on I guess.

Chadli - Ummm...

I agree about the movement, it's something that needs working on, although I thought generally Lamela was better than some and has shown in other games a willingness to make himself available. (I'm sure in the last euro game he saw the ball about 60 times). His off ball movement was excellent in that game.

Defoe is one of the worst players in the league for this. His movement is so unimaginative and selfish, even for a a player of his type. Lennon's movement off the ball improved a little under AVB but is still pretty poor.

I think this is something that can be helped with coaching for sure, but a bit of intelligence goes a long way. Cleverer players just process what's happening better and react accordingly, and quicker.

I think AVB needs to address it, but I'm not sure how much smarter you can make some of the players we have.
 

mpickard2087

Patient Zero
Jun 13, 2008
21,889
32,561
I agree about the movement, it's something that needs working on, although I thought generally Lamela was better than some and has shown in other games a willingness to make himself available. (I'm sure in the last euro game he saw the ball about 60 times). His off ball movement was excellent in that game.

Defoe is one of the worst players in the league for this. His movement is so unimaginative and selfish, even for a a player of his type. Lennon's movement off the ball improved a little under AVB but is still pretty poor.

I think this is something that can be helped with coaching for sure, but a bit of intelligence goes a long way. Cleverer players just process what's happening better and react accordingly, and quicker.

I think AVB needs to address it, but I'm not sure how much smarter you can make some of the players we have.

Yeah I wasn't singling out Lamela especially, it was just one example at the forefront of my mind and one that was easily explainable. He looks the most intelligent with his play and movement so far, others just need to get used to how he plays and to get on the same wavelength.

I'd agree its a mix of coaching and the individual themselves. Right now we lack a bit of both in my opinion in key areas.
 

markieboy

Well-Known Member
Aug 1, 2013
1,356
1,471
Yes its the EPL other teams are going to create chances thats how it works.
Im just glad were creating chances, all thats left is to start scoring them.

I hope so but a rejuvenated Sunderland will also create plenty of chances if we play like this.
 
Top