What's new

New Stadium Details And Discussions

Lilbaz

Just call me Baz
Apr 1, 2005
41,363
74,893
I think the whole sliding pitch concept is very cool and I like the idea of a multi purpose stadium, provided the core function of the stadium as Spurs home is taken care of ( and it appears that it has been).

Wasn’t trying to come across as negative. I think the stadium looks amazing.

I was just pointing out that I think the NFL angle is a bit of a gamble as the cost of it dwarfs the revenues we are likely to expect short/medium term. Unless of course the whole franchise thing materialises and/or it provides an angle for some very rich US buyers.

Really doubt lewis/levy would be spending extra money on the stadium if they didn't think there would be a return.
 

spids

Well-Known Member
Jul 19, 2015
6,647
27,841
I was just pointing out that I think the NFL angle is a bit of a gamble as the cost of it dwarfs the revenues we are likely to expect short/medium term. Unless of course the whole franchise thing materialises and/or it provides an angle for some very rich US buyers.

I am sure that the sponsorship / partnership deals available to us with an NFL audience will be very lucrative. We were building the new stadium anyway, so only significant extra costs are for the retractable pitch. Even without NFL games, the retractable pitch will allow us to host concerts and other events without damaging the playing surface. We can have up to 16 non-football events a year I believe (may be wrong). I imagine this will also yield significant income compared to when we were at the old WHL.
 

SpartanSpur

Well-Known Member
Jan 27, 2011
12,552
43,063
I do understand this chaps, but at some stage IF the stadium just won’t be ready then the NFL game will also need to be relocated. Yes we do have the option of Wembley once more (God forbid) for football. Just because NFL has been announced now for October cannot absolutely guarantee it will be ready at the moment. What happens if it fails the safety certificates? It would be negligent to not allow for this ‘low percentage(?)’ possibility.

I'm sure I read yesterday the NFL saying they have Wembley or Twickenham pencilled in as contingencies if the stadium is not ready, for what it's worth. All seems promising on this front however and I don't think they would have announced this unless it was looking very probable that the stadium would be ready on time.

I certainly hope so as I want to buy tickets for this game and it being elsewhere would be a massive come-down!
 

Sandro30

Well-Known Member
Jul 7, 2011
2,855
12,322
Does anybody know the numbers of row's between the entrance into the south stand and the pitch? Trying to work out if I want to be above or below the entrances.

I have tried to count but either my eyes aren't good enough or the picture doesn't have enough pixels to make it easy enough!
 

davidmatzdorf

Front Page Gadfly
Jun 7, 2004
18,106
45,030
I think the whole sliding pitch concept is very cool and I like the idea of a multi purpose stadium, provided the core function of the stadium as Spurs home is taken care of ( and it appears that it has been).

Wasn’t trying to come across as negative. I think the stadium looks amazing.

I was just pointing out that I think the NFL angle is a bit of a gamble as the cost of it dwarfs the revenues we are likely to expect short/medium term. Unless of course the whole franchise thing materialises and/or it provides an angle for some very rich US buyers.

Really doubt lewis/levy would be spending extra money on the stadium if they didn't think there would be a return.

You're both right. It's a risk assessment, just like everything about the development ...everything about every development.

Having committed themselves to building a stadium, they decided to commit themselves to a major extra expenditure, in the hope of generating major additional revenue and capital value. I'm certain that they assessed the risks and benefits with great care, but that doesn't make the risks go away. It's possible to do everything right and still not get the result you wanted. That's a definition of risk and it's an unavoidable consequence of development.

You can manage risk, but you can't eradicate it.
 

thebenjamin

Well-Known Member
Jul 1, 2008
12,261
38,945
Sliding pitch really makes me nervous. Not just for delays at the outset, but if anything goes wrong later with the field not rolling out properly, or heaven forbid, there is a seam in the turf and a player tears a knee...

I think our WHL pitch was actually partly synthetic and sewn together in the same way the NWHL pitch will be, so I don't think that's going to be a problem. What I am a bit concerned about is that the football pitch is going to be suspended above the NFL pitch, and how's that's going to affect the feel of the pitch, the bounce of the ball etc. For example, Monaco's pitch, which is suspended above a car park, is apparently horrible to play on as the ball bounces unnaturally high due to it being hollow underneath the tray on which its suspended. I presume they've thought about this but not sure how you can really know until its done.
 

talkshowhost86

Mod-Moose
Staff
Oct 2, 2004
48,185
47,186
I think our WHL pitch was actually partly synthetic and sewn together in the same way the NWHL pitch will be, so I don't think that's going to be a problem. What I am a bit concerned about is that the football pitch is going to be suspended above the NFL pitch, and how's that's going to affect the feel of the pitch, the bounce of the ball etc. For example, Monaco's pitch, which is suspended above a car park, is apparently horrible to play on as the ball bounces unnaturally high due to it being hollow underneath the tray on which its suspended. I presume they've thought about this but not sure how you can really know until its done.

If it makes the pitch do something odd that can only be to our benefit as we'll be the ones with the most time to get used to it.

Unless they accidentally install land mines in the centre circle or something.
 

thebenjamin

Well-Known Member
Jul 1, 2008
12,261
38,945
If it makes the pitch do something odd that can only be to our benefit as we'll be the ones with the most time to get used to it.

Surely we don't want to go to all this trouble to end up with the single most important part - the bit where the football is played - being substandard?
 

talkshowhost86

Mod-Moose
Staff
Oct 2, 2004
48,185
47,186
Surely we don't want to go to all this trouble to end up with the single most important part - the bit where the football is played - being substandard?

Depends what you mean by 'sub-standard'.

I would suggest that if they accidentally left a hole in each goalmouth then yes that would be an issue.

But if the ball bounces slightly differently then that's something we could take advantage of to a small degree.

Either way I'm fairly certain that how the pitch actually plays will certainly have been considered during the project.
 

LexingtonSpurs

Well-Known Member
Aug 27, 2013
13,456
39,042
I agree with @talkshowhost86 and, based on the video Spurs put out on the turf - they put together a working mock-up of the system at the training grounds - I don't think it will have much effect - the grass field is pretty close to the underlying artificial turf field. And, any idiosyncrasies would be to Spurs benefit, based on familiarity - just as a smaller pitch at WHL was a benefit.


This is the video Spurs put out showing how the system will work, and showing the working mock-up at the training grounds.
 

tottenmal

Well-Known Member
Aug 22, 2013
801
2,082
Depends what you mean by 'sub-standard'.

I would suggest that if they accidentally left a hole in each goalmouth then yes that would be an issue.

But if the ball bounces slightly differently then that's something we could take advantage of to a small degree.

Either way I'm fairly certain that how the pitch actually plays will certainly have been considered during the project.

One of the effects these trays will have is our pitch will be the only flat natural pitch in the league. Most have a camber, (hence you can only see a player from the waist up on the other side of the pitch, if your stood on the touch line) to help with drainage etc. Since these will be on trays that won’t be the case.
 

Croftwoodspurs

Well-Known Member
Aug 15, 2012
359
651
I agree with @talkshowhost86 and, based on the video Spurs put out on the turf - they put together a working mock-up of the system at the training grounds - I don't think it will have much effect - the grass field is pretty close to the underlying artificial turf field. And, any idiosyncrasies would be to Spurs benefit, based on familiarity - just as a smaller pitch at WHL was a benefit.


This is the video Spurs put out showing how the system will work, and showing the working mock-up at the training grounds.


I might be think here, cue for abuse... lol

But I don't get this mock-up they show the pitch being split length ways, and then running up. I can see this happening because the runners would interfere with astro turf pitch, also we don't have the space behind the stadium.

In my mind I always thought it would split across the side, and then it would use the side rollers, and also require less space under the stadium.
 

THFCSPURS19

The Speaker of the Transfer Rumours Forum
Jan 6, 2013
37,890
130,524
I might be think here, cue for abuse... lol

But I don't get this mock-up they show the pitch being split length ways, and then running up. I can see this happening because the runners would interfere with astro turf pitch, also we don't have the space behind the stadium.

In my mind I always thought it would split across the side, and then it would use the side rollers, and also require less space under the stadium.
I mean it is factually happening so there we go.
 

LexingtonSpurs

Well-Known Member
Aug 27, 2013
13,456
39,042
I might be think here, cue for abuse... lol

But I don't get this mock-up they show the pitch being split length ways, and then running up. I can see this happening because the runners would interfere with astro turf pitch, also we don't have the space behind the stadium.

In my mind I always thought it would split across the side, and then it would use the side rollers, and also require less space under the stadium.
The field has to split to fit under the south end of the stadium - there are concrete pillars underneath the stands for support, where the field is stored - so the field will split to go around those pillars.
 
Last edited:

Lilbaz

Just call me Baz
Apr 1, 2005
41,363
74,893
I might be think here, cue for abuse... lol

But I don't get this mock-up they show the pitch being split length ways, and then running up. I can see this happening because the runners would interfere with astro turf pitch, also we don't have the space behind the stadium.

In my mind I always thought it would split across the side, and then it would use the side rollers, and also require less space under the stadium.

We have the public square behind the stand the pitch goes under that.
You can't have it split across the side easily as those stands wouldn't be able to support the weight (of themselves and spectators).
 

Phischy

The Spursy One
Feb 29, 2004
1,000
1,152
I might be think here, cue for abuse... lol

But I don't get this mock-up they show the pitch being split length ways, and then running up. I can see this happening because the runners would interfere with astro turf pitch, also we don't have the space behind the stadium.

In my mind I always thought it would split across the side, and then it would use the side rollers, and also require less space under the stadium.
I don't really understand your point here (particularly what you mean by 'split across the side'), but the video is 100% a representation of what has been designed and is being built.

There is a large cavern (which I the plans seem to show has a secondary purpose as a car park when not storing the pitch) under and behind the South Stand effectively where the old stadium was and the buildings (and public realm) are organised to ensure there's not too much weight over it. There is literally no room under any other stand. All this is public realm and can be found in this thread or the planning application.

In terms of the tracks, such a large mass would need to be supported in a number of areas and would need a complex system to move, so rails would be necessary regardless. There will no doubt be some method, either manual or automated of filling the rail gaps with astroturf pitch after the pitch has been rolled back.

Obviously the large carevn being used to store the pitch has daylight lamps to keep the grass alive but the stand and flooring above it need support, so there are two large pillars and a two rows of smaller pillars behind them for that job. The pitch splits into three parts to accomodate that.

I must say at the outset, I wasn't keen on a system which splits the primary playing surface up and I felt it would lead to injuries if a player slides or gets their studs caught on a seam. But it seems a huge amount of engineering and testing has (as it should) been conducted and having seen some videos of a trial in action the majority of my fears have been allayed.
 

robertgoulet

SC Resident Crooner Extraordinaire
Jul 23, 2013
3,610
12,552
For our Americans I’m surprised we’ve never had any kind of tie up with the Spurs NBA team. Could you play basketball in our stadium or would it get lost. I guess Boxing is ok so maybe ? Do we think x2 top NBA teams would sell out ? Not sure if there is the interest here. But will be interesting to see the make up of the 16 other events.

Basketball is not ideal for a stadium of that size. The NCAA Final 4 is played in football stadiums, it has to be a huge event to make it worthwhile. I can't imagine that few regular season NBA games would sell out the stadium.
 
Top