Swansea vs Spurs - FA Cup Match Thread

nailsy

SC Supporter

Jul 24, 2005

30,536

46,630

• Mar 17, 2018

• #361

Onside, but not a clear and obvious error so they're correct to give the wrong decision

 

CowInAComa

Well-Known Member

Aug 31, 2012

7,293

18,237

• Mar 17, 2018

• #362

Streetspur77 said:

So they could check?

Click to expand...

Check they got it wrong?

 

EJWTartanSpur

SC Supporter

Jan 29, 2011

4,811

10,103

• Mar 17, 2018

• #363

I have no problem with how VAR was used there. If there was an error then it was from the linesman making a guess over a marginal inconclusive to the naked eye call

 

Nerine

Juicy corned beef

Jan 27, 2011

4,764

17,261

• Mar 17, 2018

• #364

Looked offside to me...

 

LexingtonSpurs

Well-Known Member

Aug 27, 2013

13,456

39,042

• Mar 17, 2018

• #365

It wasn't "clear and obvious" should have quickly stuck with the on-field call and moved on.

 

S

SugarRay

Well-Known Member

Jul 6, 2011

7,984

11,110

• Mar 17, 2018

• #366

We had retreated, set ourselves up and was ready to go then suddenly Swansea think they’ve had a great decision etc, gives them a lift

 

ikky

Well-Known Member

Dec 6, 2006

8,991

21,420

• Mar 17, 2018

• #367

what happened to giving the benefit to the attacking player?

 

nightgoat

Well-Known Member

Sep 12, 2005

24,604

21,898

• Mar 17, 2018

• #368

Hmmm. So the linesman was wrong but VAR was right to let him be wrong. In that situation when it's so tight surely he should just keep his flag down knowing it will be looked at if Son scores regardless.

 

thinktank

Hmmm...

Sep 28, 2004

45,893

68,893

• Mar 17, 2018

• #369

Sonny got no awareness of offsides tbf...runs off all the time - way too early.

 

D

Deleted member 27995

• Mar 17, 2018

• #370

VAR in football doesn't work, goal line tech is fine, everything else should be left to the officials, how many replays, and people are still fucking unsure. Forget it.

 

S

SugarRay

Well-Known Member

Jul 6, 2011

7,984

11,110

• Mar 17, 2018

• #371

Bus-Conductor said:

wonderful ball by Eriksen

Click to expand...

Was a great piece of skill from Son too

 

spursfan77

Well-Known Member

Aug 13, 2005

46,680

104,957

• Mar 17, 2018

• #372

Need that second goal to show how dominant we’ve been.

 

Phomesy

Well-Known Member

Aug 20, 2013

9,188

14,102

• Mar 17, 2018

• #373

Lamela is a pressing machine

 

A

ardiles

Well-Known Member

Nov 24, 2006

13,228

40,308

• Mar 17, 2018

• #374

With or without VAR, Son will get his due goal/s in this game at some stage.

 

Streetspur77

Happy Clapper

Jul 20, 2017

2,792

9,404

• Mar 17, 2018

• #375

CowInAComa said:

Check they got it wrong?

Click to expand...

Well no because they got it right within the framework of how VAR works and got it right in general because sons head and chest were off

People just enjoy having something to moan about

 

W

wishkah

Well-Known Member

Jan 27, 2011

4,808

14,483

• Mar 17, 2018

• #376

would hate to play 5 aside against lamela

 

tiger666

Large Member

Jan 4, 2005

27,978

82,216

• Mar 17, 2018

• #377

Even if they didn't use VAR, it still got called offside anyway.

 

felmani26

SC Supporter

Jan 1, 2008

24,537

43,408

• Mar 17, 2018

• #378

Our movement is giving Swansea no end of problems.

Really interesting how our dynamic changes when Son is up top instead of Kane

 

W

Wsussexspur

Well-Known Member

Oct 2, 2007

8,918

10,176

• Mar 17, 2018

• #379

Did they restart with a kickoff from the VAR disallowed goal?

 

Bus-Conductor

SC Supporter

Oct 19, 2004

39,837

50,713

• Mar 17, 2018

• #380

To be fair, VAR changed nothing, it was just one of those tight calls by the linesman, VAR just decided it was to tight to overturn. No VAR, we still get that goal disallowed.