Dier to captain England against Germany

mawspurs

Staff
Staff
Joined
Jun 29, 2003
Messages
26,722
Thread starter #1
Gareth Southgate has confirmed that Eric Dier will captain England for Friday's game against Germany.

Read the full article at The FA
 

wakefieldyid

SC Supporter
Joined
Jun 13, 2006
Messages
1,086
#8
He is not ahead of Kane for the England captaincy, nor Spurs.
In this context, it's worth reading this article from Wednesday's Daily Telegraph...

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/football...ngland-captain-man-whose-book-helping-gareth/

They make the point that captaincy in any sport isn't about rewarding the best, the loudest, or the longest serving players, but the ones who step up the plate and show leadership by example. Being a proper leader involves far more than being a media favourite.
 

mawspurs

Staff
Staff
Joined
Jun 29, 2003
Messages
26,722
Thread starter #9
In this context, it's worth reading this article from Wednesday's Daily Telegraph...

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/football...ngland-captain-man-whose-book-helping-gareth/

They make the point that captaincy in any sport isn't about rewarding the best, the loudest, or the longest serving players, but the ones who step up the plate and show leadership by example. Being a proper leader involves far more than being a media favourite.
That was an interesting read, thanks for posting. (y)
 

JC-Rule

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 14, 2005
Messages
1,759
#10
I'm not a fan of Strikers or Keepers being captains.

Guessing i'm old fashioned, but i want a central midfielder or Central Defender to captain the team.

So i'd much prefer Dier over Kane for England and Spurs.

But other factors do come into play though.
 

whitesocks

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2014
Messages
2,307
#11
Lloris is our ceremonial captain, and rightly so for all his international experience.
But for some time clearly Kane has been the effective captain, and refs will call him over if they want to make a point.
He listens respectfully and leads by example. Since we are a compact side, he is never that far from the action, so him being a striker is not so much of an issue.

For me, and I am a big fan, Dier hasn't earned the right to be captain either for club or country so I'm not sure why this has happened.
 

Bilko

Active Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2004
Messages
753
#12
Lloris is our ceremonial captain, and rightly so for all his international experience.
But for some time clearly Kane has been the effective captain, and refs will call him over if they want to make a point.
He listens respectfully and leads by example. Since we are a compact side, he is never that far from the action, so him being a striker is not so much of an issue.

For me, and I am a big fan, Dier hasn't earned the right to be captain either for club or country so I'm not sure why this has happened.
Because Southgate is crap
 

newbie

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2004
Messages
3,939
#13
Lloris is our ceremonial captain, and rightly so for all his international experience.
But for some time clearly Kane has been the effective captain, and refs will call him over if they want to make a point.
He listens respectfully and leads by example. Since we are a compact side, he is never that far from the action, so him being a striker is not so much of an issue.

For me, and I am a big fan, Dier hasn't earned the right to be captain either for club or country so I'm not sure why this has happened.
]

To be honest I think we are developing a team of leaders, Toby, Verts, victor, Kane, Dier all have a presents and are leaders during the games.
 

whitesocks

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2014
Messages
2,307
#14
I don't normally watch England games, but we seem to have lost a generation of players aged in their late 20s.
Of those out there, only Walker and Jones have more caps than Dier and he is the better captain material of those. So maybe I was being unfair.

He played well, but he and Livermore are not the most attack minded of players. Winks should walk into this team.
 

gusrowe

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2005
Messages
790
#17
I like Dier as a player, he is solid and dependable. Always puts in a good shift and scores the odd goal. I think the Spurs and England players respect and trust him so I have no problems with him being Captain.
He did well last night as the team Captain, solid, safe,secure in a team of debutantes and led my example. Maybe a little bit slow in passing the ball last night but safety first when your playing the World Champions.
He does not have Kane’s skill and is not flash but he did remind me of Bobby Moore..probably the greatest England Captain...enough said. In addition he always comes over well in interviews and the press currently like him.
I think Dier , although young is improving and will continue to be the England and potentially Spurs Captain.
 

Colonel_Klinck

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 19, 2004
Messages
5,958
#18
Either way, it would be interesting to see him tried out as a regular Spurs captain.
I definitely see him as a future captain of Spurs. Kane may be ahead of him but I actually think Dier would make a better captain. He’s also perfectly positioned on the pitch for a captain.

I thought he had a really good game. Solid performance and leading by example. I’m not a huge fan of the style of football Southgate plays but I do like the trust he places in young players. He’s not afraid to play players that are in form rather than just picking star names either.
 
Last edited:

fridgemagnet

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 18, 2009
Messages
1,474
#19
I thought he was solid and marshalled things quite well, not worried about giving players an earful when needed and i think he sets himself a high standard and it pisses him off when he comes up short and i think he expects the same of those around him, i also think he's very much a team player but not afraid to put a foot in either.

That he's a versatile player makes him a useful captain to have, i think he'll be one of those unsung players a bit like Scott Parker (without the Marvel haircut)
 

whitesocks

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 16, 2014
Messages
2,307
#20
He is a different player to the one that first played midfield 2 seasons back.
Then he'd dive in and make his presence felt. Picked up a few bookings and the smarter players would see him advancing and play it to the space he had left behind him.

Now he zonally marks, cutting the passing angles and waits for the mistake. These are not the natural instincts of a CB, which he has the build for. He is a very strange boy indeed.

All the same, it is a shame he didn't take the opportunity to kick Ozil up in the air
 
Top