Good Week/Bad Week

Discussion in 'Columns' started by Krafty, Nov 7, 2012.

  • by Krafty, Nov 7, 2012 at 8:50 AM
  • Krafty

    Krafty Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    4,493
    Ratings Received:
    +1,710 / 21 / -5
    Good Week

    Yago Falque

    An impressive turn against Norwich, the young Spaniard is growing in stature and nudging further into the first team picture.

    Steven Caulker

    It will be interesting to see if he keeps his place when Benny returns and Jan moves into the middle, even more so when Kaboul is fit.

    Bad Week

    AVB

    A very bad week for the Portuguese manager. Obviously two defeats are poor, but two defeats that showed up all our failings under his tenure was worse.

    Against Norwich we dominated the game, only got one goal, then crumbled when the pressure came. Not the first time, not the last, but it has happened too often for this to be a mere coincidence. Then on Saturday we performed woefully, outplayed by a Wigan side that on their day can be very good but should not dominate a game at our home like that.

    There are some many issues it is alarming that AVB has not addressed them yet. He is playing a system that doesn’t suit the players at his disposal. It requires a midfield that can play short, snappy passing which, with the exception of Dembele, they cannot do (if we had signed Joao Moutinho it might have been different but we didn’t so it isn’t). The lone striker is too isolated, we do not get enough men in the box, with Defoe upfront there is little point in crossing the ball (add the aforementioned lack of numbers in the box) therefore wasting the skills of Bale and Lennon. For someone who is meant to be a tactical genius these failings are appalling.

    Simply put he needs to put out a more offensive team against weaker sides. That line-up will do very well in away games against the top teams, where space and opportunity for the counter will occur. However when you need to take the game to the opposition it is blunt, as we have seen against Norwich (twice), Maribor, Panathinaikos, Wigan, the first halves against Villa and QPR.

    We do not have the players or the league for this style and setup to prevail against middle to lower table sides.

    AVB said we have only played two upfront against QPR in the second half, a game we turned round a 1-0 deficit into a 2-1 win, and while I can understand we have not had the chance to practice it in training, what with Ade’s ‘issues’ and no third striker, it is the easiest formation to adjust to since positioning is decided by zones on the pitch, and the players have played it for the last three seasons under Redknapp.

    One of the most startling sights for me on Saturday was just how far we were off the Wigan players at any given time. We always seemed to be ten yards off a man, then when we were pressed him a simple pass took our player out of the game. Then someone else would have to run ten yards to press, then they would be taken out of the game. We are not and cannot press from the front at the moment, and it is no surprise that we were struggling to get the ball. It is also no surprise that we are tiring at the end of games. As a pressing game plan, you either all do it from front to back, or you retreat and sit deep; you cannot do both.

    With some big games coming thick and fast, AVB needs to find some answers quickly. Ironically his default setting might do well at City, Arsenal and Lazio, but he needs a plan B if he is going to succeed.

    Tottenham’s goalkeepers

    Okay, it has to stop. Pick a number one (Lloris), stick with him, then get rid of a couple of keepers by the summer.

    Every mistake, no matter how big or small, has now become a talking point. If Friedel makes an error, like he did against Wigan, Lloris should be in goal. If Lloris makes an error, like some say he did for Norwich’s winner in midweek, Friedel should be first choice. You cannot do that to a goalkeeper, it will ruin their confidence and crank up the pressure to ridiculous levels.

    Goalkeepers need to be in credit. They need to have performed well enough and saved enough points so that any mistakes still leave him with points in the bag. At the moment, even if we are 7-0 up, a slight handling error will cause big questions to be asked, rather than simply dismissing it as one of those things, he’s saved us plenty of times, if you’re going to make a mistake make it when we have already won the game etc.

    Goalkeeper is the one position where you want the pecking order to be clear.

    Clint Dempsey

    A last minute missed penalty in midweek, another anonymous performance on Saturday. Clint’s a good player but he is not a star player. He was a big fish in a small pond at Fulham and we won’t forget his winning goal at Old Trafford, but he is getting caught in limbo at the moment – a bit like Gylfi Sigurdsson.

    Going back to the AVB section, Dempsey is an example of a player who doesn’t quite fit the system as it should be. He is a direct player, physical, likes running into or onto the ball. He is not a Van der Vaart technical advanced playmaker, he is not going to play incisive through balls or little touches round the corner, and it is therefore no surprise his link up play with Defoe is non-existant.

    If he is a striker, like AVB says he is/can be, then push him right up there. Give the other striker a hand pressing the opposition, give us more options, and force the midfield to step up fifteen yards.

    Everyone else

    Let’s face it, no one put in a high enough level of performance over the two games. Bale shone at Norwich, Falque looked good, but everyone let themselves down against Wigan including the fans. Not a good week for Tottenham Hotspur Football Club.


    Subs Table

    Falque helped us come from behind to pick up a draw against Maribor (at the expense of Townsend), Livermore lost a point at Norwich when he replaced Huddlestone at HT, and Vertonghen lost three points (and Carroll gained three) when he came on with us winning in the Cup. Sandro picked up a point (Sigurdsson -1) even if the team didn’t with his early sub on Saturday.


    Defoe + 4
    Caulker + 3
    Carroll +3
    Lennon +2
    Dempsey +2
    Falque +1
    Sandro +1

    Kane 0
    Adebayor 0
    Mason 0
    Huddlestone 0

    Livermore - 2
    Jenas -2
    Townsend -3
    Vertonghen - 3
    Sigurdsson - 6
     
    • Like Like x 1
    • Agree Agree x 1
    • Informative Informative x 1
  • Categories: Uncategorized

Comments

Discussion in 'Columns' started by Krafty, Nov 7, 2012.

  1. tomo
    I enjoy these Good week/Bad week articles although I have absolutely no idea what is going on with the 'Subs table' bit. :)
    • Agree Agree x 4
  2. tomo
    And I agree with your bit about the goalkeepers. I appreciate that AVB has had to be careful not to upset the applecart by replacing Friedel with Lloris but I think the time is right now.
    He should play Lloris against Maribor and as long as he doesn't have a mare, which is highly unlikely, then start him against City and from then onwards.
    Friedel is a model pro - he will grin and bear it and be ready if we need him in the future.
    • Agree Agree x 1
  3. rupert miller
    You mention playing a different system, and you mention Dempsey isnt up to it, but you dont mention the system you would play, and who you would play instead of Dempsey. Please let us know
  4. HotspurFC1950
    I think Verts is "more better" than Benny at left back than he is over Caulks and Bill at centre back.
    • Agree Agree x 1
  5. JimmyG2
    Just because Falque has thrust himself into contention, and I agree that he has,
    does not mean we should forget Townsend after one poor half.
    He has looked good on at least three occasions.
    If we were going to drop players after a poor showing
    then we would be playing the under 21/ 18 squads for the rest of the season
    who incidently had a very good week.
  6. heythisisjay
    Can someone involved with the club PLEEEEASE print a copy of this and give it to AVB or one of his backroom staff. Otherwise the next month could be an absolute shocker.

    As in some seasons past, I'm sort of already expecting it with a depressing familiarity...

    Spurs fan depressed at the oncoming inevitability after all the promise. Maybe jumping the gun. Probably not.
  7. Sweetsman
    Last season we played a short passing game, but we had VdV and Modrić. Just because this important cogs have gone does not mean that the team is falling apart. The positive spin is that we have not had a settled side out there and have particularly missed Adebayor, yet have shown great play in glimpses. I'll leave the negative outlook to you.
    • Agree Agree x 1
  8. oskathegobshite
    Dembele is the key in my opinion. When we start to see a line up of Lloris Walker Kaboul Vertonghen Ekotto Sandro Dembele Bale Lennon Dempsey Adebayor or something similar we will click.

    If you look at our best players last year we have been without Parker Modric Adebayor and Kaboul thus far and we are still sat in 4th. I didn't think the players we needed to strengthen we're available to us at prices we could have paid in the summer but I do still believe we bought well and don't look weaker with everyone fit even after losing a world class player like Modric.

    I would still take our squad over Arsenals and I believe if we adopt a siege mentality behind a coach that the press don't seem to want to allow to have a job in English football then we will secure champions league this season.
    • Optimistic Optimistic x 1

Share This Page