Spurs - where strikers go to die.
This is an important point. It's a bit like the job of a back up quarterback in the NFL. You're not going to always get a Nick Foles, but you want someone who brings good energy to the group, and gets on with everyone. I suspect last season Janssen's mental struggles made him somewhat awkward to be around on the training pitch, a bit like the elephant in the room. Llorente's seen it all before.It makes me laugh that anyone is surprised that Llorente seems to be performing as poorly as Janssen. It's like no one seems to get that if you buy a striker and only play him sporadically and never to his actual strengths that it will effect his confidence.
To answer the OP I absolutely would rather have Llorente. He has proven throughout his career that he is a top striker and it's only his confidence and rhythm that is affecting his form. Class is permanent though and I would rather a proven player coming on to make the difference in a tight game than Janssen who has never reached the levels Llorente has in his career.
People seem to forget that Janssen looked totally either shit scared or sometimes tried way to hard last season. Llorente just looks very very rusty in front of goal but in general play he links pretty well.
Above all though, it seems Llorente gets on well with the group. Everyone respects him and likes having him around and for a player who hardly gets a kick I would rather that than Janssen who seemed generally unhappy and sulky at not being picked more often.
We need a new defoe.
Ade had 2 good seasons in 3 before he went crazy. And Defoe was consistent after we bought him back.FYP
Harry Kane aside (As he’s homegrown) we’ve had some shocking striker signings over the years. Who was the last consistently good one we bought? Ade for a loan season? Berbatov?
Pretty obvious