Was I Illegal, or Simply Immoral?

Bill_Oddie

Everything in Moderation
Staff
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Messages
19,120
Thread starter #27

chrissivad

Staff
Staff
Joined
May 20, 2005
Messages
40,562
#28
Its one of the unwritten rules, like you would kick the ball out of play if a player was down, well untill they changed it. That was never a writen rule under the FA but always happened, just like shouting mine.
 

SpurSince57

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2006
Messages
45,214
#29
Did the opposition complain? If not, you're in the clear.

This does not, however, excuse Arsenal players shouting, 'A moi, Didi!' to Zokora. This fiendish practice has to stop.
 

Chris12345

LADdam Hussein
Joined
Jan 15, 2005
Messages
11,908
#30
I think its illegal...

we were always told to put a name on it... infact we had a player sent off in a school match after he got a yellow for twice shouting "mine!"
 

Bill_Oddie

Everything in Moderation
Staff
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Messages
19,120
Thread starter #33
As I say: Yes to immorality, No to illegality.

All in all one of my better days.
 

Phantom

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
5,249
#34
I must say having played for several clubs as a youngster and both my schools. I have never even heard of this.

But I would also like to join in making Bill feel bad so ........CHEAT CHEAT
 

dirtydave

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2004
Messages
1,260
#35
hang on we are discussing legit rules yet you play 3 sets of 30mins? surely a rule is already being broken!

i still vote GOAL btw.
 

Flatters

Racist Troll
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
27,001
#36
I've never heard of a rule stating that you can't shout "mine" or anything of such nature...

I'll try it next time I play at Powerleague and see if anything happens.
 

DFF

Some Men Just Want To Watch The World Burn
Joined
May 17, 2005
Messages
13,070
#38
What the hell? Free kicks and cards for shouting "mine"? Jesus wept. I've never even heard of that before. Then again, i didn't play with amateurs who shouted "mine". And if you got put off by what an opposing player said, you'd be out on your arse.

I was always taught to shout your name because "mine" didn't make it clear to a teammate who was claiming the ball.

What kind of Home Counties woofter league gives out free kicks and cards people for shouting "mine"? For chanting "who's the bastard in the black", i can understand.

I don't think Bill's a cheat. Just one of those noncey, amateurish players who shout "mine". :wink:
 
Joined
Nov 10, 2006
Messages
6,365
#39
I was told that shouting 'mine' was illegal by a teacher in primary school, but have never seen it in a professional match, so I'd go for the unwritten rule explaination.

Having said that, if anyone is stupid enough to be put off my someone shouting mine in such key areas of the pitch, they deserve to have the ball go in off their arse. Claim the goal my friend, claim it
 

Bill_Oddie

Everything in Moderation
Staff
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Messages
19,120
Thread starter #40
Just to clarify, I never touched the ball. It went over the defenders (ducked) head and missed my foot, before going in off the keeper's ankle. I haven't claimed it as I think thats even worse than calling 'Mine'.

But yep, I'd agree fully with the last few posts that you shouldn't shout 'mine', but the fault lies with the defender who - had it been me - needed to clear his lines regardless of what anyone around him said, unless it was "Keeper's Ball" in the exact voice of his number 1.


*Goes off to practice his ventriloquism for this Saturdays return fixture.