What's new

Player Watch: Gareth Bale - Retires

E17yid

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2013
17,224
31,317
I’m not buying into this “lift” argument either. I get it and I don’t even really dispute it but is a lift really what we need?
 

THFC_is_my_life

Well-Known Member
Jan 29, 2011
253
1,358
Bale suits our counter attacking style perfectly, and if there is a deal there to be done I hope we can do it.

My worry though is that, even with a front 3 of Son, Kane, Bale (imagine that!), our inability to get the ball forward from midfield/ play in tight spaces/ create anything of note will affect the level of impact he is able to have - hopefully GLC can provide this spark once fit.
 

SpartanSpur

Well-Known Member
Jan 27, 2011
12,561
43,105
Press building on Bale to Utd. Dortmund talking up keeping Sancho. All a game of poker between the two or will genuinely get Bale and wait a year for Sancho?

Concerns me that following Trix's ITK Levy might have walked away from this deal. Feels like the deal the whole club needs for sure, a bit more ambition shown by the chairman might get a buzz around the place that seems to be sorely lacking.
 
D

Deleted member 27995

I’m not buying into this “lift” argument either. I get it and I don’t even really dispute it but is a lift really what we need?
Yeah, Bas Dost is the one we want, can you imagine the shirt sales? Those photo ops? Fuck yeah!

bucket
 

wadewill

Well-Known Member
Aug 31, 2005
3,169
10,503
It obviously wouldn’t be a surprise if United did sign him.

but I think it’s way more likely that if they do it’ll be towards the end of the window when Sancho has absolutely 0% chance

at the moment I would guess this is all a game from United to get Dortmund to hurry things up. It’s what they do
 

Donki

Has a "Massive Member" Member
May 14, 2007
14,460
18,981
United wont sign Bale, he doesn't fit in with their transfer strategy at all, if anything its a smokescreen to make BD panic with the Sancho deal
 

spursfan77

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2005
46,707
105,015
Has anyone had a look on the man u forums to see if they think they will sign him or if it is a load of nonsense?
 

E17yid

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2013
17,224
31,317
It's as sure as shit a bigger lift than signing any one of the names we're being linked with :D

I know you’re joking but the whole thing about a lift is that, in part at least, it’s just superficial.

I’m more concerned with signing players that will improve us as a team. I’m not saying Bale wouldn’t but I also don’t think he’d automatically come in and solve the shit show that is the squad at the moment, lift or no lift.

And that’s before you even consider the fact he’s likely to spend half the time in the physio room, what a lift that would be for the fans.

We’re kinda in Danny Rose google territory. I wonder if the same people who still make the jokes about Danny are the same ones who are just clamouring for a big name. The general view against Danny was that it’s about getting the right profile of player rather than a big name. I dunno.
 

Finchyid

Well-Known Member
Jun 27, 2017
3,829
12,038
Press building on Bale to Utd. Dortmund talking up keeping Sancho. All a game of poker between the two or will genuinely get Bale and wait a year for Sancho?

Concerns me that following Trix's ITK Levy might have walked away from this deal. Feels like the deal the whole club needs for sure, a bit more ambition shown by the chairman might get a buzz around the place that seems to be sorely lacking.

When did Trix say that ?
 

rossdapep

Well-Known Member
Aug 25, 2011
22,448
80,888
Press building on Bale to Utd. Dortmund talking up keeping Sancho. All a game of poker between the two or will genuinely get Bale and wait a year for Sancho?

Concerns me that following Trix's ITK Levy might have walked away from this deal. Feels like the deal the whole club needs for sure, a bit more ambition shown by the chairman might get a buzz around the place that seems to be sorely lacking.
If United think they can play poker with Dortmund they've got another thing coming.

Dortmund don't want or need to sell and won't be panicked into selling at what United are trying to pay.

Thats why I think United are genuinely pushing to loan Bale.
 

WalkerboyUK

Well-Known Member
Jun 8, 2009
21,658
23,476
United wont sign Bale, he doesn't fit in with their transfer strategy at all, if anything its a smokescreen to make BD panic with the Sancho deal

Dortmund have no need/reason to sell Sancho. They're proving it by playing him in the cup match last night.
 

Danny1

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2006
5,700
17,619
Have to say that if Utd go out & sign Bale after we have been told that there was a deal to us that was just for us, then I will lose my shit. This club needs to be backed, we were in the Champions League final last year for fuck sake, and we are pissing around with our signings as per usual. I'm usually quite level headed with Levy but to see Bale rock up at Utd would tip me over the edge.
 

0-Tibsy-0

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2012
11,441
44,506
I know you’re joking but the whole thing about a lift is that, in part at least, it’s just superficial.

I’m more concerned with signing players that will improve us as a team. I’m not saying Bale wouldn’t but I also don’t think he’d automatically come in and solve the shit show that is the squad at the moment, lift or no lift.

And that’s before you even consider the fact he’s likely to spend half the time in the physio room, what a lift that would be for the fans.

We’re kinda in Danny Rose google territory. I wonder if the same people who still make the jokes about Danny are the same ones who are just clamouring for a big name. The general view against Danny was that it’s about getting the right profile of player rather than a big name. I dunno.

I get what you're staying and I know we're miles away from that team in regards quality etc, but I remember watching the Sky Broadcast when we were signing a slightly past it Edgar Davids (in 05?) - they had a camera at the training ground and before it was confirmed his car turned up - it showed professional Spurs players running round the corner to get a glimpse of him including Keane and Mido, who were their Nations superstar players. The excitement and lift seemed obvious.
 

E17yid

Well-Known Member
Jan 21, 2013
17,224
31,317
I get what you're staying and I know we're miles away from that team in regards quality etc, but I remember watching the Sky Broadcast when we were signing a slightly past it Edgar Davids (in 05?) - they had a camera at the training ground and before it was confirmed his car turned up - it showed professional Spurs players running round the corner to get a glimpse of him including Keane and Mido, who were their Nations superstar players. The excitement and lift seemed obvious.

Yeah that’s totally fair enough and I don’t dispute it. There would definitely be a buzz about the place before we get knocked out of the Europa league qualifying rounds and Bale gets injured.
 

ernie78

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2012
7,373
15,509
Have to say that if Utd go out & sign Bale after we have been told that there was a deal to us that was just for us, then I will lose my shit. This club needs to be backed, we were in the Champions League final last year for fuck sake, and we are pissing around with our signings as per usual. I'm usually quite level headed with Levy but to see Bale rock up at Utd would tip me over the edge.
I feel the same. I think after everything that has happened over the last 2 years, euphoria to utter dismay to just get strung along Only for the same shit to happen will be the final straw.
it was ok in the 90’s/early 00’s when were shit and didn’t have any delusions of grandeur but now to have got so close, have world class facilities to not get class players just makes you think what is the fucking point?? It will look like a sham and I feel undo years of good work raising our profile as we slip further toward midtable
 

Donki

Has a "Massive Member" Member
May 14, 2007
14,460
18,981
Has anyone had a look on the man u forums to see if they think they will sign him or if it is a load of nonsense?

Most don't want him and think he will be Sanchez MKII, they don't really have an ITK section and mostly go on "trusted" Journalists.
 

deanostheyido

Well-Known Member
Aug 5, 2011
597
5,949
For people doubting the impact a 31 year old Bale would have here, just a small reminder that mourinho signed a 35 year old Ibrahimovic for united, helping them to 2 trophies and the community shield (glorified friendly) in his 1st season. Cant underestimate the difference a renown star coming in can have on a team.
 
Top