What's new

Jose Mourinho

How do you feel about Mourinho appointment

  • Excited - silverware here we come baby

    Votes: 666 46.7%
  • Meh - will give him a chance and hope he is successful

    Votes: 468 32.8%
  • Horrified - praying for the day he'll fuck off

    Votes: 292 20.5%

  • Total voters
    1,426

spurs mental

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2007
25,576
50,480
The players and Mourinho share responsibility for the dismal level of performance we have descended into.

However this narrative about these being the same players that got Pochettino the sack just isn't accurate.

By my calculation we have signed at least 5 first teamers since Mourinho joined: Reguilón, Doherty, Højbjerg, Bergwijn and Bale as well as a back up striker and a highly rated young centre back. Mourinho has also had much longer to work with Ndombele and Lo Celso who were still relatively new to the country and the club when Pochettino left. Maybe these players aren't good enough but you can hardly say they're the ones who got Pochettino the sack as most of them weren't even here then.

Lloris
Aurier
Toby
Dier
Reggie*
PEH*
Sissoko
Ndombele**
Son
Kane
Bergiwjn*

*Signed under Jose
**Signed under Poch but more Time with Jose.

That is, what most would agree has been our best starting XI so far this season. He's signed 3 starters for our first XI.

Bench:

Hart*
Davies
Doherty*
Lucas
Lamela
Vinnie*
Bale*
Winks
Sanchez
Rodon*

5 bench players. Dispute over whether he even wanted Bale.

13 out of the 21 were here under Poch. So yes, the majority were here under Poch.
 
May 17, 2018
11,872
47,993
Levy got Pochettino sacked.

He failed to invest in the team over several seasons with quality players either leaving or declining. Then he began to look for a new Manager cutting Poch out of the recruitment process (Coach instead of Manager) thus undermining him and causing him to become disillusioned.

I'm not saying Poch is perfect. But everyone has short ********* memories on here.

There's always the shiny new Manager at Tottenham to fix everything but it won't.

Interesting thing to say, considering your version of events is heavily edited, if not completely fictional.
 

Rosco1984

Well-Known Member
Aug 31, 2012
1,743
7,056
I’m not excusing how bad we were last night, but in some respects we were unlucky, they didn’t really pepper our goal did they, we limited them to one flea chance where Hugo made a great save. Were it not for the penalty we’d have got a draw, or if Vinicius had buried his chance. Chelsea are no great shakes at the moment, and they were pretty poor last night, we were worse, but we could have easily got a draw out of that game.

Glad we are striving to just not lose to a team that was in crisis themselves a week ago. We had two attempts they had 18 we were at home we weren't unlucky we were scared.
 

nico97531

Well-Known Member
Dec 5, 2006
593
947
The players and Mourinho share responsibility for the dismal level of performance we have descended into.

However this narrative about these being the same players that got Pochettino the sack just isn't accurate.

By my calculation we have signed at least 5 first teamers since Mourinho joined: Reguilón, Doherty, Højbjerg, Bergwijn and Bale as well as a back up striker and a highly rated young centre back. Mourinho has also had much longer to work with Ndombele and Lo Celso who were still relatively new to the country and the club when Pochettino left. Maybe these players aren't good enough but you can hardly say they're the ones who got Pochettino the sack as most of them weren't even here then.
It’s one way of looking at it but on the other hand these players you mentioned are mostly performing at a better level and the ones seemingly having problems are the same ones from the poch era which makes the point that it’s the same players that cost the job of poch correct!
 

Shadydan

Well-Known Member
Jul 7, 2012
38,247
104,143
Levy got Pochettino sacked.

He failed to invest in the team over several seasons with quality players either leaving or declining. Then he began to look for a new Manager cutting Poch out of the recruitment process (Coach instead of Manager) thus undermining him and causing him to become disillusioned.

I'm not saying Poch is perfect. But everyone has short ********* memories on here.

There's always the shiny new Manager at Tottenham to fix everything but it won't.

You need to let Poch go, literally every post you mention this guy - time to move on fella.
 

Hakkz

Svensk hetsporre
Jul 6, 2012
8,196
17,270
We are progressively outplayed by teams with much less at their disposal than us so that argument doesn't hold up- Brighton made us look like footballing dinosaurs last week.

I hate watching this football it bores me to tears. And only an idiot who witnessed the end of Mourinho's era at Man United would think it was ever going to be different here.

The meltdown and fallout isn't far away believe me.

Good. Sometimes that is needed for a group to be hardened and united. Hopefully we can also ship out the deadwood in this squad and get people with energy and drive.
 

Spartanspurs

Well-Known Member
Jul 2, 2013
427
1,862
Lloris
Aurier
Toby
Dier
Reggie*
PEH*
Sissoko
Ndombele**
Son
Kane
Bergiwjn*

*Signed under Jose
**Signed under Poch but more Time with Jose.

That is, what most would agree has been our best starting XI so far this season. He's signed 3 starters for our first XI.

Bench:

Hart*
Davies
Doherty*
Lucas
Lamela
Vinnie*
Bale*
Winks
Sanchez
Rodon*

5 bench players. Dispute over whether he even wanted Bale.

13 out of the 21 were here under Poch. So yes, the majority were here under Poch.
8 out of 21 is almost a complete squad overhaul. I doubt there's many other teams in Europe let alone the league that have changed so much of their squad in that time.
 

H-SF

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2020
2,198
10,484
The videos of our pressing in the second half are the most embarrassing thing. Looks like a bunch of school kids chasing the ball. He just hasn’t coached them how to press at all.
 

swarvsta

Well-Known Member
Jul 25, 2008
773
4,061
Most managers talk about playing "attacking" football but only a few are really genuinely good at it. I think there are some managers who do spend a lot of time on tactical training and trying to play really complex systems, but generally speaking I think the role of the manager is to create an environment that allows players to flourish - mentally and physically as much as anything else. If the result is a group of players that feel scared, nervous, demotivated and unfit, then that is a major red flag.

Liverpool have been on a poor run of form of late, but they always create plenty of chances to score every game. Their players make off the ball runs, they find space, they move the ball around quickly, they hassle and pressure the opposition when not in possession - teams feel like they have to play well to beat them. I am seeing none of that from us at the moment.

Talk all you want about how certain players are not good enough - the fact is that most of our squad are international footballers with Champions League experience. We're not West Brom or Burnley but we sure are playing like it at the moment. One or two meaningful attempts on goal per game, most of the game out of possession, no creativity, no flair. This is just nowhere near good enough.

It doesn't necessarily mean that Mourinho is a bad manager, but the manager is about being in the right time and place. In his past jobs he's had more money and resources than anyone else in the league and has done well to get big teams exert their dominance over their rivals - but he's never succeeded in taking an underdog up the table. At the time I felt it was time for Pochettino to go but Mourinho was a questionable fit to replace him and sadly I think that this appointment hasn't worked out.

People talk about whether winning the League Cup is worth this. I don't. Winning the title or doing something I've never seen us do before would be, but just getting a single domestic trophy, no. And quite frankly, the way things are going we are going to get murdered by Man City in the final anyway.

If I'm Levy then I'm on the phone to Kane and Son this morning asking what they're thinking. If either say they want Mourinho gone then I'd sack him today.

I agree with some of your points, but you clearly haven’t watched Liverpool recently if you think they have been creating lots of chances, pressing high and moving the ball around quickly. They haven’t been doing any of these things, which is why their results have been poor. Klopp has even come out and said this.

Crucially he didn’t blame the players, but more so fatigue.

The key point I agree with is that a manager should set up an environment for people to feel comfortable and motivated to work. This goes for any profession.

I think our players cannot handle the Jose style and are terrified of making mistakes and being called out in front of the group - probably whilst watching a video analysis.

Jose’s greatest teams had some of the toughest of players mentally. Dare I say it, but ‘old school’ proper MEN. They were hard as nails mentally and thrived under Jose’s style.

Football doesn’t seem to have these characters any more. Many of this generation probably don’t appreciate his constant swearing! This generation are offended by everything, so I just don’t think his style fits the modern game.

He is really trying to be totally supportive and sympathetic to the players but it isn’t his natural style.

I have ended up liking Jose as a person during his time here, but just don’t think there is any way to turn this around now. The players won’t let him.
 

nico97531

Well-Known Member
Dec 5, 2006
593
947
So Brighton can play possession based football but we cant have a word with yourself. What about Leeds I guess their players are better than ours as well? How many times did we ever have less possession under Poch? Maybe against city and Liverpool but that's it. They are the same players. Poch got us as far as he could and ran out of steam. I really don't think it was as simple as losing the players things just went stale. What was needed was someone to reinvigorate but continue what poch started not a negative confidence sapping disciplinarian to tear it all up and start from scratch destroying everything we built. These players kept the ball for Poch they can still keep the ball now they need confidence and encouragement to play and be brave. Maybe we will still concede but we might actually score a few as well.
[/QUO
There’s no point arguing with these opinions, you think they’re good enough but I believe they are not so we will just have to agree to disagree for the time being. Until you get your wish that is.
 

Styopa

Well-Known Member
Jan 19, 2014
5,400
15,026
13 out of the 21 were here under Poch. So yes, the majority were here under Poch.

Of course the majority of the players in the squad were here under Pochettino, Mourinho has been here less than a year and a half. Nonetheless a significant number of them, 8 by your count, in other words nearly 40%, weren't here when Pochettino left. The fact Mourinho may not be playing this new cohort doesn't change that.

Maybe it's purely a recruitment thing or maybe it's a combination of factors. Whatever the case, it isn't working now like it wasn't working then and this is after bringing 8 new players to the club. And 8 new players doesn't = the same group of players as before. It's just a fact.
 

spurs mental

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2007
25,576
50,480
The videos of our pressing in the second half are the most embarrassing thing. Looks like a bunch of school kids chasing the ball. He just hasn’t coached them how to press at all.
And yet some people last night saying they know how to press because they did it under Poch? But now its Jose's fault because he doesn't coach it? Give me a break. They're professional footballers. They don't forget how to do basic shit like passing or moving or closing down space. They just aren't good enough
 

ardiles&villa

Well-Known Member
Jul 14, 2013
2,001
5,558
It’s either stick or twist and Right now we must stick. If we sack him, there isn’t anyone available till the summer anyway, plus it will give him time to turns it around. We will have dips in form but we also have a manager who is one of the most successful managers in history, I feel like he deserves a chance to do that.
 

buckley

Well-Known Member
Sep 15, 2012
2,595
6,073
When people start saying " this or that club is not doing so well either " as tho that is a reason to let this manager off the hook .
I just dont get it I dont care about other clubs but I do care about spurs but please dont use " this or that club is not playing so well either " as a reason why our club should be let off.
 

cjbyid

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2009
7,416
25,568
Nothing groundbreaking but JJ responded with a thumbs up to someone on twitter asking is Jose under pressure from the board etc.
 

buckley

Well-Known Member
Sep 15, 2012
2,595
6,073
Because of new rules you cannot approach a manager of another club mid season . So that leaves the interim manager as a way forward .
My choice would be Harry Redknapp at least it would not be like watching paint dry .
 

LeParisien

Wrong about everything
Mar 5, 2018
3,212
8,170
In all organisations, corporate, industrial or football clubs, managers are one or many leaders depending whether you have a good team or failing one. Successful teams in all walks of life, have employees that are leaders aswell and do not rely just on a manager to lead for them. Leadership doesn’t just stop at management level.
Yes absolutely. I agree. I also don’t pretend to have all the answers - I have much to learn.

The senior management team will have an impact on the type of leadership structure that exists. Put differently, senior leaders can empower or disempower their workforce.

One simple example. If you reward risk taking and creativity then you will encourage leadership from everyone. There are obvious costs so it has to be managed. On the flip side, if you punish risk taking or creativity then you are likely to encourage subservience.

There are clear applications to a football team but it’s just one example of many we could choose. The way members of a team view themselves and others can be shaped by formal and informal structures as well as communication styles.
 
Top