What's new

Jose Mourinho

How do you feel about Mourinho appointment

  • Excited - silverware here we come baby

    Votes: 666 46.7%
  • Meh - will give him a chance and hope he is successful

    Votes: 468 32.8%
  • Horrified - praying for the day he'll fuck off

    Votes: 292 20.5%

  • Total voters
    1,426

DanielJohnCosta

Well-Known Member
Jul 10, 2015
1,650
5,838
Are you saying that these players don't pass forward at all? Or are we just talking about Kane? That wasn't your original point.

no the original post was making excuses for the manager for setting up some truly horrible football, i'm simply stating as UCL finalists we can pass it forward if our manager wanted to
 

hellava_tough

Well-Known Member
Apr 21, 2005
9,429
12,383
Tim Sherwood was a better Spurs manager than Mourinho, and I gave up my season ticket because of the way we were playing under him. Anyone who thinks the fight between Lloris and Son shows passion is wrong. It shows the beginning of the end of us challenging for things, you can tell the squad is unhappy. We are going to have an even more fractured squad. This tension has been heightened by Mourinho.

Or a DCM comes in, we become very difficult to beat, win a few games in a row and the players start believing in themselves again.
 
D

Deleted member 27995

no the original post was making excuses for the manager for setting up some truly horrible football, i'm simply stating as UCL finalists we can pass it forward if our manager wanted to
Which we have done. You're using a broad stroke statement to run the current manager down, while the football last night was poor, if we weren't passing the ball forward we wouldn't have scored the goal.

It was rubbish as a game of football, but we all know that.
 

Dougal

Staff
Jun 4, 2004
60,369
130,269
To see some 'fans' of our club apparently unwilling to celebrate a win against a team in good form is very disappointing. Get over yourselves.
Celebration takes place in many forms. I’d say this was the lower end of the scale. At that end, enthusiasm is hard to muster. Yes, it’s a positive. But the energy isn’t there to dance around the room. That doesn’t necessarily warrant fans becoming ‘fans’. We’re all on the same side. But the spectrum is rather large and, at the moment, widespread.
 

DiVaio

Well-Known Member
May 27, 2020
4,178
17,421
Sessegnon has nothing to do with Poch. We wanted him on the advice of Levy’s special advisor David Pleat. The fact is Poch almost walked last summer because Levy’s antics in the transfer window. We were never signing Dybala and we spent forever negotiating for his prime target Lo Celso. The other player Poch wanted on the advise of Bisela was Calvin Phillips, but that was a no go because Levy was more concerned about Jack Clarke who was also on the advise of his special advisor.

Levy fast and loose antics in the transfer windows have left us with an unbalanced squad. The fact he listens to David Pleat as a special advisor is baffling.
Lo Celso was our priority target and Bruno was backup. How we were never signing Dybala?
Also didnt Pleat find Dele from League Two? So weird that Levy listens to good scout
 

DiVaio

Well-Known Member
May 27, 2020
4,178
17,421
Tim Sherwood was a better Spurs manager than Mourinho, and I gave up my season ticket because of the way we were playing under him. Anyone who thinks the fight between Lloris and Son shows passion is wrong. It shows the beginning of the end of us challenging for things, you can tell the squad is unhappy. We are going to have an even more fractured squad. This tension has been heightened by Mourinho.
 

Metalhead

But that's a debate for another thread.....
Nov 24, 2013
25,411
38,427
I just find it baffling that people are complaining about the style of play, they aren’t remembering that for the entirety of last season and this season under Poch we played similarly ‘dull’ and ‘arduous’ football. The last season we played ‘nice’ football was 17/18. Surely the only thing thats important is seeing gradual improvements in areas of our game, and I can say that defensively (Sheffield individual errors aside) we look systematically more solid since the restart. I think Jose would admit that offensively we aren’t as free following as he’d like us to be but just give him time ffs.
I think that it’s in no small measure down to the fact that many didn’t want Mourinho and are determined to be proven right so every situation, every game, every word said by Mourinho will be contrived in such a way to paint him in as negative light as possible and where possible to ‘prove’ that he’s the wrong choice and that he will be on his way very soon.
 

Chirpystheman

Well-Known Member
Jan 22, 2019
501
1,610
Hang on... you've assumed that because Mourinho was the wrong choice, the right choice must have been to keep Poch. Or that I think Poch was perfect (he isnt). My argument in that post was that Mou is the wrong coach for us.

The one strand you seemed to have picked up on (out of five) is that Mourinho isnt developing young players with talent. Foyth is not the best example because he has had a lot of injuries under both coaches. He was getting more and more game time under Poch when fit though. He had some very rash games but he also had some great outings in the CL and against Man City where he looked composed on the ball and shackled world class players (notably Sterling). Lets see what happens under Mourinho. My suspicion is (and you can quote me on this later) that because he is not yet reliable, he will not be given an opportunity to fulfill his potential and we will not see the best from someone who was an Argentine international at 21.

Your points on Sess and Ndombele are irrelevant. Even if Poch was doing a terrible job, all that means is that we can criticise Poch for the same thing as Mou. My argument is that Mou was a bad fit because we will not be buying fully formed players for big money - something Mou himself has said repeatedly whilst hes been here - but instead relying on buying potential to develop. This is the kind of Dortmund-esque strategy so many have pined for and seemed to be kick started last summer. Mou aint gonna maximise that.

I would disagree with some of that. To say he doesn't play young players or develop them. He has been credited by Rashford and McTominay for helping to develop them. McTominay is now a regular for united and got his Debut under him. Also we have a young player that even though he played really well in preseason didnt get a kick until Jose come in and would have probably left for nothing in Tanganga. He might juat stay now. So lets not say he doesnt or will never play kids. He has started Skipp and is always praising him for his efforts in training and has done the same with White and Cirkin. So its a myth. He also won the prem as someone pointed out with the youngest squad in prem history. He also kick started the career of Varane at real madrid. So lets all be honest here. We can point to players hes moved on but KDB and Salah werent ready when he moved them on. They wanted game time and he couldnt give them it. He was also winning trophies at this same time. So not a complete disaster.

As for the sort of players we would buy. We bought those type of players under Harry. Id say our position is more critical now than under harry purely because we are around the CL places now and financially we need to stay there. Levy cares about the net spend. So if we can get that to a place hes comfortable he will spend money

He probably wasnt 1st choice for many of us. The reality is hes here and should be backed by the fans and Levy. The agenda some have against him is bordering on ridiculous. We have 3 games in a week and controlled a side who have been getting plaudits under Carlo Ancelotti to just 6 touches in our box. Once we get midfielders in who are happy to carry the ball forward and commit players as well as getting the ball forward quickly then we will be on to something. Sissoko and winks cannot do this to the kevel we require. Maybe ndombele will be up to the challenge Jose has set out before him. Lo celso was as jose made him convince him he should be in the side now hes probably the 2nd name in the XI.

For as long as ive been a spurs fan weve been weak mentally and no real winners in the side. The ones who appeared to be winners quickly left. Berba bale sheringham even Judas. All got out. If we hadnt been on cuspast couple of seasons Kane would have been gone as well. Players too nice to call each other out. When your teammates demand little from you wherenis the motivation. Do you think Ndombele would have got away with what he has at Chelsea with some of the characters they had in the dressing room.

Mourinho is a winner its about time the players believed it too. Believing you are a winner and walking out in to any aspect of life believing you belong there makes a big difference. Saying to your team and to anyone who would listen that it was a miracle we had got to a cup final shows your level of expectation and what you are demanding from your players. Thought we were meant to aim high as a club not aim for the middle of the road
 

Shadydan

Well-Known Member
Jul 7, 2012
38,247
104,143
no the original post was making excuses for the manager for setting up some truly horrible football, i'm simply stating as UCL finalists we can pass it forward if our manager wanted to

Of course we can pass it forward but when we pass it forward and play expansive football bad things happen.

Like this
 

Ledley's Right Foot

Well-Known Member
Jun 18, 2012
338
743
Tim Sherwood was a better Spurs manager than Mourinho, and I gave up my season ticket because of the way we were playing under him. Anyone who thinks the fight between Lloris and Son shows passion is wrong. It shows the beginning of the end of us challenging for things, you can tell the squad is unhappy. We are going to have an even more fractured squad. This tension has been heightened by Mourinho.

We were bad under Sherwood because we didn't have the right players (with the right mentality) - which Poch proved when he began his clear out (and Sherwood was not the right man to take us forward). It's not quite the same now but I think yesterday showed just how much we miss Eriksen and Dembele. They were at the fulcrum of all our creativity.

We need an outstanding playmaker or two to make his team function as an attacking unit. In the meantime, what we did yesterday will get us more good results than not.

I don't think the squad are unhappy, more they want to win. They played for mourinho yesterday, that was clear. Green shoots. The next three transfer windows are crucial if we want to challenge again.
 

db1

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2004
1,119
697
Lo Celso was our priority target and Bruno was backup. How we were never signing Dybala?
Also didnt Pleat find Dele from League Two? So weird that Levy listens to good scout
No Pleat didn't find Dele. He was being watched by numerous clubs scouts including Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal and Spurs (not Pleat) since he was around 13. I was being told about him from someone whos boy played with him at youth level and was regularly telling me this lad at MK was going to be great and was being watched by those clubs. There were more clubs but it was a while a go and I can't remember the rest.
 

Albertbarich

Well-Known Member
Jul 4, 2020
5,184
19,702
No Pleat didn't find Dele. He was being watched by numerous clubs scouts including Liverpool, Chelsea, Arsenal and Spurs (not Pleat) since he was around 13. I was being told about him from someone whos boy played with him at youth level and was regularly telling me this lad at MK was going to be great and was being watched by those clubs. There were more clubs but it was a while a go and I can't remember the rest.

Dele was an open secret but that doesn't mean pleat wasnt the one pushing us to sign him.

I go to quite a few reserve games ,not just spurs ones either and pleat is always at our ones and I often see him at other games.
 

Shadydan

Well-Known Member
Jul 7, 2012
38,247
104,143
didn't you literally do the same one reply up? :bored:

No you want us to pass forward more and be more expansive - I showed you an extreme example of what happens when we do that, basically we're a bit shit if we open up, but somehow you've taken that as we should only rely on having 2 shots per game.:shifty:
 

Metalhead

But that's a debate for another thread.....
Nov 24, 2013
25,411
38,427
We were bad under Sherwood because we didn't have the right players (with the right mentality) - which Poch proved when he began his clear out (and Sherwood was not the right man to take us forward). It's not quite the same now but I think yesterday showed just how much we miss Eriksen and Dembele. They were at the fulcrum of all our creativity.

We need an outstanding playmaker or two to make his team function as an attacking unit. In the meantime, what we did yesterday will get us more good results than not.

I don't think the squad are unhappy, more they want to win. They played for mourinho yesterday, that was clear. Green shoots. The next three transfer windows are crucial if we want to challenge again.
It’s funny but for a player who had many fans scratching their heads as to what his place was within the team, Dembele went on to be an incredible influence in the team and is really missed.
 

mpickard2087

Patient Zero
Jun 13, 2008
21,889
32,562
We were bad under Sherwood because we didn't have the right players (with the right mentality) - which Poch proved when he began his clear out (and Sherwood was not the right man to take us forward). It's not quite the same now but I think yesterday showed just how much we miss Eriksen and Dembele. They were at the fulcrum of all our creativity.

We need an outstanding playmaker or two to make his team function as an attacking unit. In the meantime, what we did yesterday will get us more good results than not.

I don't think the squad are unhappy, more they want to win. They played for mourinho yesterday, that was clear. Green shoots. The next three transfer windows are crucial if we want to challenge again.

It's going to take much more than just hoping one or two individuals will solve the problem.

Neville was right on commentary last night, about half hour in, when he described it (both teams, but lets focus on Spurs) as just a series of slow one off passes with no idea behind them or with a purpose to do something. No harmony or fluidity to the movement of players or trying to link with others and construct a move in little sub-units. Especially in the final third. That is a whole team problem and requires everyone to improve on and off the ball.

You can say individual players should be able to work it out for themselves, but very often they cant. They need direction and the framework set for them, tons of coaching, to start gaining a better instinct for what you're trying to do.

This was a problem under Poch, it continues to be a problem if not worse under Mourinho. And is the weakest aspect of his coaching career tbh, he's much more comfortable organising, solidifying, and working on fast transitions rather than more patient football. But whilst he can get away with it at the moment, it will have to evolve pretty quickly beyond 'incredibly basic' possession play because he'll find what other managers have found, and the way modern football in general has gone, more and more teams prepared to sit off and defend deep and just ask you to break them down.
 
Last edited:

DanielJohnCosta

Well-Known Member
Jul 10, 2015
1,650
5,838
No you want us to pass forward more and be more expansive - I showed you an extreme example of what happens when we do that, basically we're a bit shit if we open up, but somehow you've taken that as we should only rely on having 2 shots per game.:shifty:

yeh, so they are both extremes on either side of the situation...
 
Top