What's new

New manager search twist as Frank De Boer says he's happy to stay at Ajax

Donki

Has a "Massive Member" Member
May 14, 2007
14,455
18,975
I suppose I see your rationale in terms of Carlo and his CV, etc. You have a good point there, m8. I am still rather gravitating towards FDB or Poch though. It's interesting how many Yids just want one or the other.

Time will tell, most of all what I want from our next appointment is progress, I'm not demanding top 4, I want to see a team who look like they know what they are doing. A team that plays as one and looks hungry and can entertain. I don't want a team that hopes for the best or a team that doesn't want the worst, I want a team that wants to outplay their opposition. Role on August!
 

doom

Well-Known Member
Dec 13, 2003
2,368
1,338
Ancelotti may well want to manage us if he is sacked and is by far a better more experienced manager than the other candidates mentioned, it's like comparing Bale and Townsend. The players would love to play under him and doubt we'd get players wanting to leave with him at the helm.
 

sebo_sek

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2005
6,023
5,168
Not so sure about that, m8. I suspect I am going to get dumped on for this, but Ancelotti is overrated IMHO. Don't get me wrong, he is a good manager, but not remotely close to being worthy of the insane amount of £ his salary would command. In fact, I don't even like Benitez at all, and I believe Carlo is just slightly better tactically than the Spanish Wanker.

Let's consider the following:
Ancelotti was at the two (or even three or four) of the most powerful and filthy rich clubs in the whole wide world, with virtually no restrictions on the budget. With any and all resources at his disposal, and largely no opposition when it comes to transfer targets of his own preference.....and he still only managed a relatively underwhelming level of accomplishment.
He got what, a double with the Chavs before getting sacked. Then he got that title with PSG, and Copa Del Rey this year with Madyid (well, he's still in the race for CL victory, but we'll see).
In almost a decade at those clubs, thats not nearly as good as he's made out to look by some folks.

Just sayin. ;)

Much rather FDB or Poch...Much more fitting candidates for us, IMHO.

Cheers!
Oh I haven't read such bollocks on here for ages. Just to sum up his mediocre achievements:

Intertoto cup - 1999
Italian title: 2004
Italian cup: 2003
Italian Super cup: 2004
CL: 2003 and 2007
European Super Cup: 2007
Club world cup: 2007
English double: 2010
Community shield: 2009
French title: 2013
Copa del Rey: 2014
Champions league final after beating last year's champions: 2014

You said the last decade and barring the intertoto cup there it is.
so that's 11, possibly 12 major achievements in the last decade. Pathetic.
 

onemorespursfan

Active Member
Jun 3, 2004
366
55
Oh I haven't read such bollocks on here for ages. Just to sum up his mediocre achievements:

Intertoto cup - 1999
Italian title: 2004
Italian cup: 2003
Italian Super cup: 2004
CL: 2003 and 2007
European Super Cup: 2007
Club world cup: 2007
English double: 2010
Community shield: 2009
French title: 2013
Copa del Rey: 2014
Champions league final after beating last year's champions: 2014

You said the last decade and barring the intertoto cup there it is.
so that's 11, possibly 12 major achievements in the last decade. Pathetic.

But other than that, what has he actually achieved?
 

Barry Mead

Well-Known Member
Jan 31, 2013
3,083
4,078
Much ado about nothing, what else is he going to say? These journo's like to sensationalise a pretty obvious comment.
 

slartibartfast

Grunge baby forever
Oct 21, 2012
18,320
33,955
Oh I haven't read such bollocks on here for ages. Just to sum up his mediocre achievements:

Intertoto cup - 1999
Italian title: 2004
Italian cup: 2003
Italian Super cup: 2004
CL: 2003 and 2007
European Super Cup: 2007
Club world cup: 2007
English double: 2010
Community shield: 2009
French title: 2013
Copa del Rey: 2014
Champions league final after beating last year's champions: 2014

You said the last decade and barring the intertoto cup there it is.
so that's 11, possibly 12 major achievements in the last decade. Pathetic.
Pull your neck in. Youve totally missed the point of what he was saying.
He was saying to win things with those massive power house clubs is not that much of an achievement.
I mean Avram Grant was a knats cock away from doing a treble with Chelsea and DiMatteo won CL so maybe we should get one of them in?
Working with clubs like us and working with Inter Milan, Barcelona, Real Madrid etc is a bit different.
I'm not saying he's a shit manager. Just you didnt need to post a list of what he's won because the post your replying to never said he hadnt won anything.
And can we stop mentioning him anyway. Ffs theres not a f-in chance in hell he'll come to spurs unless we get taken over by a Billionaire so why are we even discussing it???
 
Last edited:

2bearis2do

Well-Known Member
Apr 22, 2006
3,820
2,317
Can someone explain to me how and why Pochettino is an upgrade on either AVB or Dim Tim? I just don't get it…he's done well with Southampton - Whoppeee.
Feels like we're just going to make the same mistake again…an unproven, young manager at the realms of one of the top clubs in Europe?
What am I missing?!
 

Yid

Well Endowed Member
Jul 5, 2013
1,254
1,366
Oh I haven't read such bollocks on here for ages. Just to sum up his mediocre achievements:
.......................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................
You said the last decade and barring the intertoto cup there it is.
so that's 11, possibly 12 major achievements in the last decade. Pathetic.

Hahahaha....o_O You're calling me "Pathetic"? Brilliant!
This is so fitting, coming from a person who obviously lacks fundamental reading comprehension, along with basic arithmetic skills.

I probably shouldn't bother, but since you chose to open this can of worms and get personal, here you are, luv -->>

Last I checked, this was May of 2014, which makes your count of Ancelotti's accolades completely off the tangent.

Let's see here ((you may wanna get out your calculator, btw)):

#1) Intertoto cup - 1999 -->> really?? 1999?...2014 minus 1999, that comes to 15...that's 15 years, just FYI....let me double-check and verify my calculator...uh huh...yup, that's 15 years...Way off there, kiddo.

#2) Italian title: 2004 -->> Technically, this one doesn't count either, since that was in early May (4th IIRC), and today is the 17th (almost 2 weeks over a decade), so you lose this one too, sweet cheeks...but I'll go ahead and give it you, since I am nice like that. Oh and BTW, thanks for confirming my argument ((I was trying to limit my points to the last 3 filthy rich mega-clubs Carlo worked @, but you threw AC Milan in there as well, where he incidentally had one of the top 5 squads in the world...and Juventus was fighting corruption scandals..So Carlo managed to steal that title with a roster of world-class footballers topped by the most prolific goalscorer that year, amidst a total cluster-f*ck in serie A))

#3) Italian cup: 2003 -->> Yeah, I don't think so, sweet cheeks. 11 years is definitely pushing the envelope. Refer to #1, and scratch that one.

#4) Italian Super cup: 2004 -->> Ok, ok, you can have this one.

#5) CL: 2003 (See #1 and #3, but NICE TRY)...and 2007 (fair and square, on this one...See, I can be reasonable ;)

#6) European Super Cup: 2007

#7) Club world cup: 2007

#8) English double: 2010 (Abramovich throwing millions upon millions at him, this was a bare minimum expected with the Chavs. And I'm being generous here)

#9) Community shield: 2009 (clinging on to a thin thread, ey)?

#10) French title: 2013 (Barely...Considering he inherited a near-billion £ club, but still managed to draw 0-0 vs Ajaccio, 0-0 vs Bordeaux, 1-1 vs Valenciennes, 2-2 vs Lorient, and then lose to Rennes, and St. Etienne....quite underwhelming in a league largely dominated by the very same giant Ancelotti chose to lead.

#11) Copa del Rey: 2014

So basically, in the last 10 years he managed to get a sum of 10 titles and/or trophies at best (2 of which are right outside the bubble & barely considered...while 2 others are nothing to brag about, and any half decent manager with an IQ level of a chimpanzee would be expected to accomplish them at a bare minimum.

As far as reaching the CL final this year, RM were lucky to squeeze by Dortmund to the Semis, and Carlo admitted as much himself.
I guess we'll revisit his accomplishments at a later date, but the bottom line remains -- while he's a good manager, given the astronomical resources and elite players (whom most regular managers such as Poch and FDB would salivate over)...Ancelotti is pretty overrated. And if you can't see that, then you need to take off your rose-tinted goggles, and take another look, because the facts are staring you right in the face.

And for future reference, please refrain from issuing personal insults, because it's quite discourteous.

Cheers. :love:
 

Lilbaz

Just call me Baz
Apr 1, 2005
41,363
74,893
Can someone explain to me how and why Pochettino is an upgrade on either AVB or Dim Tim? I just don't get it…he's done well with Southampton - Whoppeee.
Feels like we're just going to make the same mistake again…an unproven, young manager at the realms of one of the top clubs in Europe?
What am I missing?!

Probably the fact that we can't get a seasoned proven manager? Van Gaal would have been great but i don't see anyone else knocking down our door.
 

Norse

Member
Sep 13, 2009
279
182
Probably the fact that we can't get a seasoned proven manager? Van Gaal would have been great but i don't see anyone else knocking down our door.

I am not sure there are that many to choose from, who are seasoned and proven. Looking at the Premier League, for instance, the elite ones are already at the other top 7 clubs. And we are looking to get the one who came in just behind, at no 8.
 

sebo_sek

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2005
6,023
5,168
Hahahaha....o_O You're calling me "Pathetic"? Brilliant!
This is so fitting, coming from a person who obviously lacks fundamental reading comprehension, along with basic arithmetic skills.

I probably shouldn't bother, but since you chose to open this can of worms and get personal, here you are, luv -->>

Last I checked, this was May of 2014, which makes your count of Ancelotti's accolades completely off the tangent.

Let's see here ((you may wanna get out your calculator, btw)):



So basically, in the last 10 years he managed to get a sum of 10 titles and/or trophies at best (2 of which are right outside the bubble & barely considered...while 2 others are nothing to brag about, and any half decent manager with an IQ level of a chimpanzee would be expected to accomplish them at a bare minimum.

As far as reaching the CL final this year, RM were lucky to squeeze by Dortmund to the Semis, and Carlo admitted as much himself.
I guess we'll revisit his accomplishments at a later date, but the bottom line remains -- while he's a good manager, given the astronomical resources and elite players (whom most regular managers such as Poch and FDB would salivate over)...Ancelotti is pretty overrated. And if you can't see that, then you need to take off your rose-tinted goggles, and take another look, because the facts are staring you right in the face.

And for future reference, please refrain from issuing personal insults, because it's quite discourteous.

Cheers. :love:
First, I didn't call you pathetic but those accomplishments. Second, I see you exclude any accomplishment that was funded with any player purchases (we spent 100 million last year BTW and have been among the top spenders in England for years - yet failed to deliver so it's not the formality you would like to think), so:
Guardiola is shit, so is Mourinho, so is Ferguson, so is... actually you could say that about anybody who's ever won anything.
Now, please give me the name of the manager who achieved success - CL, domestic title - apparently other cups don't count - on a shoestring budget. Or that achieved any success on a bare minimum. I'm dying to know, cos we should definitly go for them.
I'm sorry but rejecting success cos it came from high profile player purchases just reeks of plain jealousy, and that meaningless moral high ground, that the more dillusioned fans on here represent. They love to shout - it's unfair, they have money and we don't. WHO CARES, THAT'S LIFE!
 

Sweetsman

Well-Known Member
Jan 30, 2011
6,673
6,588
"Now, please give me the name of the manager who achieved success - CL, domestic title - apparently other cups don't count - on a shoestring budget."

The name is Louis Van Gaal, but unfortunately he's not coming to us.
 

Japhet

Well-Known Member
Aug 30, 2010
19,271
57,611
Can someone explain to me how and why Pochettino is an upgrade on either AVB or Dim Tim? I just don't get it…he's done well with Southampton - Whoppeee.
Feels like we're just going to make the same mistake again…an unproven, young manager at the realms of one of the top clubs in Europe?
What am I missing?!


He sets his teams up to play a much better style of football than either AVB or TS for starters. He's done a good job instilling a team ethic and workrate wherever he's been and he's done well bringing players through the ranks and maximising the talents within the squad. If he could do similar at Spurs I'd be happy.
 

Yid

Well Endowed Member
Jul 5, 2013
1,254
1,366
First, I didn't call you pathetic but those accomplishments. Second, I see you exclude any accomplishment that was funded with any player purchases (we spent 100 million last year BTW and have been among the top spenders in England for years - yet failed to deliver so it's not the formality you would like to think), so:
Guardiola is shit, so is Mourinho, so is Ferguson, so is... actually you could say that about anybody who's ever won anything.
Now, please give me the name of the manager who achieved success - CL, domestic title - apparently other cups don't count - on a shoestring budget. Or that achieved any success on a bare minimum. I'm dying to know, cos we should definitly go for them.
I'm sorry but rejecting success cos it came from high profile player purchases just reeks of plain jealousy, and that meaningless moral high ground, that the more dillusioned fans on here represent. They love to shout - it's unfair, they have money and we don't. WHO CARES, THAT'S LIFE!

You're missing the whole point. I didn't say Carlo is shit.
Au contraire, I even emphasized that he is indeed a good manager (in my original post).
That however does not change the fact he is slightly overrated given the vast resources at his disposal (among other things).
Are you really going to deny that money makes a huge impact on success in football (or any other professional team sport for that matter)?
 

sebo_sek

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2005
6,023
5,168
You're missing the whole point. I didn't say Carlo is shit.
Au contraire, I even emphasized that he is indeed a good manager (in my original post).
That however does not change the fact he is slightly overrated given the vast resources at his disposal (among other things).
Are you really going to deny that money makes a huge impact on success in football (or any other professional team sport for that matter)?
Of course not, but it can't be the only denominator. There are superb managers that work with limited budgets and achieve great things - Pulis this year to name one. But in order to win you need a combination of money and experience - Pellegrini, who we can agree won the league not because of huge expenditure but because he didn't bottle it at the very end, unlike Rodgers - also huge budget and a star-studded squad.
Moyes is a very good manager, had a title-winning squad and botched it up. On your original logic he should have won the league without batting an eye-lid. But he didn't. Hence, the fact that Carlo has only worked with the super-rich is only one small part of his success, which I will still say has been impressive.
 

ardiles

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2006
13,228
40,308
Oh I haven't read such bollocks on here for ages. Just to sum up his mediocre achievements:

Intertoto cup - 1999
Italian title: 2004
Italian cup: 2003
Italian Super cup: 2004
CL: 2003 and 2007
European Super Cup: 2007
Club world cup: 2007
English double: 2010
Community shield: 2009
French title: 2013
Copa del Rey: 2014
Champions league final after beating last year's champions: 2014

You said the last decade and barring the intertoto cup there it is.
so that's 11, possibly 12 major achievements in the last decade. Pathetic.

But......but.... Does he have the best winning percentage in the Premiership? :whistle:
 

nav007_2000

Well-Known Member
Sep 28, 2006
2,157
2,622
Carlo is definitely NOT overrated. Far from it! From all the managers that we are linked to, he would be my number one if available.
 

CanberraSpur

Well-Known Member
Aug 26, 2012
241
392
If that story is true and we are waiting for Ancelotti instead of getting on with what we need to be doing then f**k me dead we are run by some deluded numpties. What a joke.
 
Top