What's new

Manager Watch: Ange Postecoglou

rossdapep

Well-Known Member
Aug 25, 2011
22,185
79,777
The difference is the best teams continue to move the opposition around just in tighter areas.
We don't have enough dynamic technicians that can play quickly with thier heads up in tight areas.

Because a lot of our players have no pictures of the play in mind or have the awareness to play a little give and go in tight areas a lot of times our best option is to go back/sideways first time to open a different passing lane. But this only gets you so far, and when the movement stops or slows it becomes all very predictable and much like under Conte, Jose and even Poch becomes reliant on individual brilliance.
Our forwards are all pretty limited against a low block too, the only one I would consider a good link up player is Kulu and he's limited in other ways

Still think Udogie and Porro make a big difference today if they play.
Yeah.

Son = A brilliant finisher who can
I think so much of this narrative is what social media has done to the game. The radical swings, etc. and seeing such things as “let’s stick with it” as if it’s really becoming difficult. As others have mentioned, some need to really get a grip. I get asking questions, seeking some adjustments, etc, but it’s been like 7 months, playing a completely brand new style of football, and we are still in position to be playing Champions League football if we can just get some stability in terms of injuries.

We lost to a team that was well drilled, playing football they are used to, while missing (arguably but not really) our two most vital players and having to go with 2 guys that simply don’t offer the same styles at all, really.

I’d rather ask questions of the fans ready to dismount the Ange train this quickly than anything else. For me, those folks can get lost, because they won’t change and will always be quick to start shouting for change at the first moment things go sideways. We are in a rebuild and punching above our weight so far does not change anything. We still are inconsistent, and that was always going to be the case (see: Ange constantly saying there would be “ups and downs”). Quite frankly I find it annoying this is even part of the conversation right now.
My dad was complaining about Conte and that playing 3 at the back and 2 in midfield was ineffective.

In the summer he was wanting Poch or a coach to get us playing the "Tottenham way" again.

Last 2 weeks he has been moaning that we can't be so gung ho.

In January he was saying he could see us being a top team for years to come with all the young players.

One extreme to another. Want one thing but when it goes too much the other way he wants some of the other thing he was complaining about

🤣🤣
 

only1waddle

Well-Known Member
Jun 18, 2012
8,211
12,417
I partly agree, but what Allardyce and Mourinho achieved twenty years ago is not necessarily relevant to what they later became.

I do know what you mean though, in that words are just words. And there’s no clean demarcation between a so called project manager and any other. But at the same time I think there’s a difference for example when a club like Brighton employs an Allardyce or Hodgson in 2024 versus appointing a Potter or DeZerbi. I think project at least indicates something.

I think it's more accurate to describe what we're going through with Ange as a reset, as it's been a club wide change in recruitment, academy, structure and ideology, we already have a decent stature of regular 6th to 4th for it to be a project.
 

only1waddle

Well-Known Member
Jun 18, 2012
8,211
12,417
Yeah.

Son = A brilliant finisher who can

My dad was complaining about Conte and that playing 3 at the back and 2 in midfield was ineffective.

In the summer he was wanting Poch or a coach to get us playing the "Tottenham way" again.

Last 2 weeks he has been moaning that we can't be so gung ho.

In January he was saying he could see us being a top team for years to come with all the young players.

One extreme to another. Want one thing but when it goes too much the other way he wants some of the other thing he was complaining about

🤣🤣


I reckon quite a number of our fanbase are probably having the same thoughts as your dad, my mate messaged as he was leaving the game saying Ange will never work out how to break a low block down.
Years of "nearly but not quite" has taken it's toll.
 

mil1lion

This is the place to be
May 7, 2004
42,520
78,124
One tweak I hope Ange makes is keeping 3 players back even when we attack.

The nature of the way we play, we’re going to lose possession in the middle of the park, problem with this is we’re leaving Romero and VdV exposed every time.

I’d like to see more of a fluid shape defensively so if both full backs are progressing up then the DM slots back into the centre of the CBs and splits them out. Would mean their starting positions would then be closer to the traditional full back positions.

I’m just some fan who loves spurs, so I’m sure Ange would make it more nuanced than my rambling above, but the general premise is the same.
It would suit the shape better to have a defensive midfielder split the center backs the way we did under Poch. It allows the 2 fullbacks to push into central midfield but when VdV and Romero press to halfway there's a central figure between them. I always loved the work Wanyama did to balance all the attacking play we had. If only Bissouma had that desire to win the ball back out of possession. That would be the area I would look too in the summer for midfield.
 

worcestersauce

"I'm no optimist I'm just a prisoner of hope
Jan 23, 2006
26,966
45,254
For all those crying Ange has been found out in the Premier league and anyone would win the Scottish Premier league with Celtic, he ran away with it and Rangers are now top of the league.
 

Goobers

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2011
1,979
3,193
It would suit the shape better to have a defensive midfielder split the center backs the way we did under Poch. It allows the 2 fullbacks to push into central midfield but when VdV and Romero press to halfway there's a central figure between them. I always loved the work Wanyama did to balance all the attacking play we had. If only Bissouma had that desire to win the ball back out of possession. That would be the area I would look too in the summer for midfield.
That's a really interesting point - would a player that plays in that way get in the way of the way that fullbacks come inside ?
 

mil1lion

This is the place to be
May 7, 2004
42,520
78,124
That's a really interesting point - would a player that plays in that way get in the way of the way that fullbacks come inside ?
I shouldn't think so because when the fullbacks come infield they often are more advanced. They should come infield and link with Maddison while a defensive midfielder sits back and Sarr is the link between them. You would just have a more defensively disciplined 6 whose sole purpose is to defend in front of the centre backs and allow VdV to cover counters behind Destiny or Romero to cover Porro. As long as you have an 8 like Sarr to track back and help in front as well I think it would work.
 

Hazelton

Unknown Member
Jul 11, 2011
5,677
19,750
All we need Ange to do is get Champions League football and learn from this season. It's all a learning process.
 

Snarfalicious

Well-Known Member
Jul 15, 2012
15,724
72,078
All we need Ange to do is get Champions League football and learn from this season. It's all a learning process.

I totally agree with your second point. And I’m not trying to “jump” your post. But I think part of what you said is the problem. The expectations. Managing them, being willing to accept that this year, it could be another nothing season like last season. But now we are saying “all we need” is Champions League. But, what if he doesn’t get it? In a season where most of us thought Top 6 would be a great achievement given everything he inherited at the club. But if he doesn’t get Champions League, is his position in question? Even though just being in the equation for Top 4 was an overachievement if you consider what was the general thought going into the season?

We pined for a rebuild, told ourselves we were ready to embrace it and now are being spoiled by it being a lot less painful then we imagined. So, instead of being thankful for that, we change the goalposts and say “yeah, nah, this is no longer a rebuild” just doesn’t work.
 

Misfit

President of The Niles Crane Fanclub
May 7, 2006
21,264
34,956
See, I think that’s a problem. The expectations. Managing them, being willing to accept that this year, it could be another nothing season like last season. But now we are saying “all we need” is Champions League. But, what if he doesn’t get it? In a season where most of us thought Top 6 would be a great achievement given everything he inherited at the club. But if he doesn’t get Champions League, is his position in question? Even though just being in the equation for Top 4 was an overachievement if you consider what was the general thought going into the season?

We pined for a rebuild, told ourselves we were ready to embrace it and now are being spoiled by it being a lot less painful then we imagined. So, instead of being thankful for that, we change the goalposts and say “yeah, nah, this is no longer a rebuild” just doesn’t work.
That's where I am. It would, let's be honest, be a bit disappinting to not get CL at this stage after the season we've had and the position we find ourselves in but bigger picture it's remarkable Ange has had such an effect, not to mention our much much smoother transfer set up now, already.

Too 6 was achievable before the start imo. I'd still be very happy with that after everything shakes out and think we do a bit better than that anyway.
 
Last edited:

Hazelton

Unknown Member
Jul 11, 2011
5,677
19,750
See, I think that’s a problem. The expectations. Managing them, being willing to accept that this year, it could be another nothing season like last season. But now we are saying “all we need” is Champions League. But, what if he doesn’t get it? In a season where most of us thought Top 6 would be a great achievement given everything he inherited at the club. But if he doesn’t get Champions League, is his position in question? Even though just being in the equation for Top 4 was an overachievement if you consider what was the general thought going into the season?

We pined for a rebuild, told ourselves we were ready to embrace it and now are being spoiled by it being a lot less painful then we imagined. So, instead of being thankful for that, we change the goalposts and say “yeah, nah, this is no longer a rebuild” just doesn’t work.
I'm not saying his position becomes under threat, as far as I'm concerned he's done more than enough to get a fair crack and our full backing. I also understand that our expectations were low going in to this season, but as the season has unfolded and we can see the lay of the land, realistically we're in a position where we're well placed to finish fourth and it would be disappointing if the wheels fell off. Not a disaster, but disappointing based on how we've performed and the players we have compared to Villa, United's struggles etc.
 

Colonel_Klinck

Well-Known Member
May 19, 2004
12,719
23,322
Do you think players can hear him on the pitch above the crowd noise?

Yeah I get the feeling that a lot of the time managers are just shouting to make themselves feel better as their frustration needs to be vented. If they genuinely want to get a message on they'll call a player over.
 

neogenisis

*Gensy*
Jun 27, 2006
5,932
13,452
Half a season and people are calling for change, mental. The good start we made has clouded peoples minds. Ange gets the time he needs from me thats for sure.
 

Freddie

Well-Known Member
Jan 29, 2004
2,076
4,308
It's quite laughable that so many of you think you've found a tactical loophole that undoes all of our tactics and our manager is too inept/naive to see it and do anything about it. If anyone saw City yesterday you'll know that any ball over the top had them in trouble . It's not because the tactics were naive. They've blown teams away all season playing that way. It's because the the players further up the pitch simply weren't pressing, using the ball well or giving it away carelessly. The same thing that's happening with us.

Perhaps we started too well and Ange is the victim of his own success. It takes over half a season to get everyone to understand what they need to be doing at all times to make the system work. Lets's give him a chance to fix these issues before moaning about his weaknesses every game. This is exactly how pressure needlessly mounts on the manager/team when in fact it's been a breath of fresh air to watch them for most of the season. It's only been a few months since we wnated to pull our eyes out under Conte remember.
 

Reece_Spurs

Well-Known Member
Sep 10, 2011
764
4,887
A big problem we seem to have right now is the players seem short of confidence.

Much of our good football in the first couple of months was from the centre backs and defensive midfielder (usually Biss) playing risky but penetrating passes through the press and midfield then one/two touch football getting us in dangerous positions extremely quick.

Through all the injuries, suspensions, afcon/Asian cup, we've really lacked a settled team and are only just getting back to a fully fit team then lose both starting full backs that are integral to how we play.

The players seem to be playing within themselves, scared of the moans and groans from the home fans if they dare misplace a pass.

The performances lately have been poor because of this but the fans in the stands really need to step back and remember this is a work in progress. Our great start to the season seems to be biting us in the arse in many ways because the expectations are a little bit unfair and all the moans and groans do is cause a negative atmosphere.

Ange needs to get the players playing without fear of making a mistake again.
 

TOLBINY

Well-Known Member
Feb 4, 2019
1,220
2,810
For all those crying Ange has been found out in the Premier league and anyone would win the Scottish Premier league with Celtic, he ran away with it and Rangers are now top of the league.
It's a two team league - what any manager achieves in Scotland is no basis for their suitability to the Prem - just ask Stevie G.
 

rossdapep

Well-Known Member
Aug 25, 2011
22,185
79,777
It's a two team league - what any manager achieves in Scotland is no basis for their suitability to the Prem - just ask Stevie G.
It really isn't as simple as that.

That was Gerrard's first job. Ange has been going and moving on another leap each time.

Secondly. Brendan Rodgers is deemed a good coach yet he is struggling at Celtic.
 

Monkey boy

Well-Known Member
Jun 18, 2011
6,425
17,122
Half a season and people are calling for change, mental. The good start we made has clouded peoples minds. Ange gets the time he needs from me thats for sure.

I’ve not seen a single post calling for change. People are rightly questioning the tactics and if this style will ever lead to anything more than entertainment but unless I’ve missed them not one person has asked to change the manager.
 
Top