What's new

Benteke / Quality young forward or Paulinho

rio bryan

Well-Known Member
Dec 30, 2006
547
350
As good as Paulinho seems to be i'd much rather be using the 17m towards a quality young forward who's going going to score us 20 goals a season, it could be the case that we have Ade, Defoe and Villa for next season so with Villa perhaps struggling with the pace of the premier league or getting injured it will be the same as last season.If we are going to sign a quality young forward as well as Paulinho then happy days !
 

beats1

Well-Known Member
Feb 22, 2010
30,031
29,612
I think Villa would ask £30million for Benteke, look at Carroll after one good season and Benteke has had the best debut season ever iirc
 

FITZ

Well-Known Member
May 17, 2004
2,020
1,527
Paulinho improves our first team from what it was. Quality, proven international who will walk into the team. These are transfers we need regardless of position.

When a player like this comes available you have to get him - the skill for me is being able to move the players now not needed on for the most money possible.
 

Legacy

SC Supporter
Mar 29, 2007
2,883
6,296
I think Villa would ask £30million for Benteke, look at Carroll after one good season and Benteke has had the best debut season ever iirc
Carroll is English, English players always have their values overly inflated. Liverpool had just come into £50m from the Torres sale and were desperate for Carroll, so Newcastle were able to take them to the cleaners with the transfer fee.

That one transfer isn't the benchmark for all impressive debut seasons.
 

Shadydan

Well-Known Member
Jul 7, 2012
38,247
104,143
Carroll is English, English players always have their values overly inflated. Liverpool had just come into £50m from the Torres sale and were desperate for Carroll, so Newcastle were able to take them to the cleaners with the transfer fee.

That one transfer isn't the benchmark for all impressive debut seasons.


Not really anything to do with nationality seeing as you mentioned Torres wasn't he overpriced as well?

More to do with the fact that the Premiership historically has been the most lucrative league in the world and teams throughout the league always readily had a lot of money to spend compared to teams in other leagues, granted that English players don't really compare skill wise to foreigners but that doesn't mean that they're exclusively overpriced.

But to answer the question then obviously a striker is what we need the most but it's a moot point anyway seeing as we're still using the money we have to strengthen other areas.
 

Yid-ol

Just-outside Edinburgh
Jan 16, 2006
31,164
19,416
As good as Paulinho seems to be i'd much rather be using the 17m towards a quality young forward who's going going to score us 20 goals a season, it could be the case that we have Ade, Defoe and Villa for next season so with Villa perhaps struggling with the pace of the premier league or getting injured it will be the same as last season.If we are going to sign a quality young forward as well as Paulinho then happy days !

Ok lets twist your own logic here.

You don't want Villa as he may struggle with pace or get injured, if we just buy a youth, what will happen if he gets injured and leaves us with just Defoe and Ade?

To me we need better creativity in midfield, we need this more than a new striker IMO, we could get a striker and not get many chances, so as others have said, Villa and Paulinho will do, or others as long as its both.
 

beats1

Well-Known Member
Feb 22, 2010
30,031
29,612
Carroll is English, English players always have their values overly inflated. Liverpool had just come into £50m from the Torres sale and were desperate for Carroll, so Newcastle were able to take them to the cleaners with the transfer fee.

That one transfer isn't the benchmark for all impressive debut seasons.
I agree but his worth to villa he is higher than what he is worth to us, he is potentially the difference between a good season and a bad season
 

camaj

Posting too much
Aug 10, 2004
8,195
883
Both would be the right answer. I think a good striker would have more of an impact that Paulinho since we've got a strong midfield

Paulinho would (will?) make our current strikers better.

I think only steroids could help those two
 
Top