What's new

Europa League, another competition devalued

SouthbourneSpurs

New Member
Dec 12, 2009
22
0
We've seen the Big Four devalue the League Cup and FA Cup in recent years - and now it seems the also-rans are happy to devalue the new Europa League at the first opportunity. Like everything that's gone before, it's all down to the strength of the Premier League. (the prize money, Champions League carrot, etc), but it's ruining the English game in my opinion.

I know the Europa League will always be a poor man's Champions League, but shouldn't English clubs at least give it their best shot or what's the point? (other than another source of revenue). Retaining Premier League status or pushing for a top four finish is now deemed more important than actually winning silverware.

Are we really going to be 'over the moon' when/if Spurs claim fourth spot? I know Champions League football will increase revenue, secure a bigger foreign fan base, etc, but fourth spot doesn't win you any silverware! I for one won't be singing 'Glory, Glory' or celebrating if Spurs finish FOURTH!

I spoke to well-known Spurs fan Morris Keston yesterday (to update his page on Twitter). He revealed that Mike Kelly, Roy Hodgson's assistant at Fulham, was at the Lane on Wednesday to see Spurs play City. From what Morris says, and he knows Hodgson and Kelly very well, the Europa League is proving an unwanted distraction for Fulham. In fact, Hodgson deemed it more important for Kelly to run the rule over Spurs (we've got them Boxing Day and again later in Jan) than travel with him to Basle where Fulham were playing in the Europa League on the same night. Fulham rested Dempsey, Duff and Hangeland for that must-win match. Of course you can understand Hodgson's thinking, with Premier League survival deemed the number one priority by the men who pay his wages. It's also what made Mick McCarthy field his second string against Man Utd during the week. (Why lessen Wolves' chances of beating Burnley by playing his first choice players against United)

I don't know about you, but I think it's a shame that as fans we've got to watch as our clubs and managers follow the Premier League gravy train. Terry Venables really was ahead of his time when he released THE MANAGER board game in 1992. (The winner of the game was the player with the most money at the end, not the player who had won the FA Cup)

Today, we've got a national game which sees managers resting their best players in the quarter-final of a League Cup (Harry at Old Trafford) or in the latter stages of the Europa League (Harry against Shaktar last season) This isn't a pop at our leader, but it's about getting the right balance between actually winning something and being as competitive as possible in the Premier League.

Will you be happy in the next decade if Spurs qualify for the Champions League three times, but win nothing, OR win the League Cup, FA Cup and Europa League once? It's winning silverware and experiencing great days out like at Wembley against Chelsea that fuels the passion in me as a supporter - not qualifying for the Champions League and then going out after the group stage.

Of course, qualifying for the Champions League IS an achievement, although look a few miles down the road and ask the other lot. Wenger's now under immense pressure for not having won anything for the last five years, yet he's achieved top four consistently.

At Spurs we've got a great Cup tradition and it's why my Dad and his Dad loved Tottenham. (We reached the semi-final of the FA Cup four times between 1948 and 1959, before we won the Double. The Glory, Glory Nights, the first club to win the League Cup twice, first British club to win a European trophy). Tottenham Hotspur has built its name on being a great Cup team and these days everyone bar, Chelsea, Man U and Arsenal is a Cup side! Let's face it, everyone else has got bugger all chance of winning the Premier League. Let's hope Spurs don't go down the route of devaluing Europe or the FA Cup. I'd like to see us put out a very good side against Peterborough, the sell-out crowd deserves it - and hopefully again in the forthcoming rounds. I'd certainly take a day out at Wembley over a place in the Top Four. We've got the makings of a good side at Spurs, one capable of breaking into the Champions League, but let's hope Harry sees that winning silverware is still what the game's really all about. (unless you're playing El Tel's 'The Manager' board game that is.) :wink:
 
Dec 17, 2009
35
1
I wholeheartedly concur, so much so that there is nothing left for me to contribute other than to say thank you for an excellent post. Compliments of the season to you, sir.
 

cwy21

Well-Known Member
May 11, 2009
9,876
8,609
Hey UEFA. You want to get teams to give the Europa League a reason to win it? Give them a champions league spot for the winner, and change the rules where a country can get more than four teams in this case.
 

3Dnata

Well-Known Member
Oct 5, 2008
5,879
1,345
It's designed by the man to keep us down.
It's pure evil;there's no point in not taking part and I'm sure Eufa would go for a massive sanction (worse than they did for us in the Inter Toto cup in the 90's) if we regularly put out youth teams.
It's better for you to play in it but look at Everton & Fulham this season and I'm sure it assisted the problems we faced in recent years.
 

duffster

Active Member
Dec 11, 2004
446
226
Its not just us. At least English teams still get decent gates for European games. Italian and Spanish clubs desperately try to get themselves knocked out early because noone comes to watch the games and it ends up costing them money to be in it!
 

class of 62

Well-Known Member
Apr 29, 2009
1,408
1,197
fantastic post from southbournespurs... i'm still of the opinion that any european football is better than none.. fotunatley i was around for most of the" glory glory" european nights from the early 70's onwards, personelly theres still that something about european nights at the lane.. even last year the best atmosphere at the lane was when 26.000 die hards turned up 3 days before the cc final and backed a team of reserves & youth players to the hilt v shaktar!!..we very nearly pulled it off,.... the gutting thing for me was shaktar then went on to win the trophy!!.
i understand how people see how uefa have devalued the competition/s but i also feel that if you give a years hard work qualifying for a competition your working just as hard from the opposite end to devalue the competition by playing what was virtually a third string side.
couldn't give a toss about finishing fourth & then being able to enter a competition called the champions league........... says it all!!!!!!!!!
 

sunnydelight786

Chief Rocka
Jan 7, 2007
6,075
4,243
Great post Sir. Truth is we devalued the comp last year ourselves with the teams we played in both legs against Shaktar last season.....
 

Legacy

SC Supporter
Mar 29, 2007
2,886
6,309
One thing I've always hated about the UEFA Cup, which devalues it for me, is that teams that fail to qualify from the group stages of the Champion's League get to automatically enter the UEFA Cup/Europa League and have a second chance of success ahead of teams that have already been competing in that cup.

If you qualify for a Champion's League spot, you should be given the choice of which competition to enter. Then, if you get knocked out of the Champion's League, that should be it. You should be done with Europe for the season, not drop down into the "lesser" cup that you'll have a better shot of winning.
 

leffe186

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2004
5,363
1,827
It's designed by the man to keep us down.
It's pure evil;there's no point in not taking part and I'm sure Eufa would go for a massive sanction (worse than they did for us in the Inter Toto cup in the 90's) if we regularly put out youth teams.
It's better for you to play in it but look at Everton & Fulham this season and I'm sure it assisted the problems we faced in recent years.

In its current format, absolutely.

Returning it to a straight (albeit two-legged) knockout without the pathetic sop to the Champions League would completely revitalize it.
 

DC_Boy

New Member
May 20, 2005
17,608
5
the key is money - as i've said many a time if UEFA believe their own egalitarian propaganda they should dramatically up the EL money taking it from the CL money
 

BringBack_leGin

Well-Known Member
Jul 28, 2004
27,719
54,929
Completely agree, but the only way to give cups the respect they deserve (domestically and continentally) involves pissing off all the major powers in football and risking a break away European Super League.

First step: Bring back the cup winners cup. The team that wins its national cup, and only that team, gets to play in this competition.

Second step: Only the champions in each country qualifies for the Champions League. Not the runners up, not the 3rd, not the 4th. CHAMPIONS ONLY! And teams who fail to get out of the group stage in the Champions League don't get to play in the Uefa cup, their European season ends there and then.

Third Step: Those teams that finish 2nd, 3rd and 4th in their domestic league (or in Englands case, 2nd and 3rd, with the league cup getting the last spot as, unlike other countries, we have 2 cup competitions) qualify for the Uefa cup.

All of a sudden, if only 1 team can get into the Champions league (making that competition more prestigious immediately), then the importance of getting into the uefa (europa, whatever) cup increases as well, because all of a sudden, even if still the poor relation, it is still an elite competition where you are likely to play Milan, Madrid, Munich, etc. Both competitions become more prestigious all of a sudden, the former because you really are just playing Champions, and the latter because you are playing against better teams than whoever krept into 6th spot in their league. Also, each countries domestic cup (and Englands favoured domestic cup) all become important again because winning them brings entry into a competition as exclusive as, and nearly as hard to win as the Champions league.

Is this turning the clock back 20 years? Yes. Is it the right thing to do? Completely. It wasn't broke, yet the meddled and meddled and meddled until we ended up with both domestic and continental cup competitions being a burden for the clubs, a turn off for the players and a waste of money for the fans.
 

Krafty

Well-Known Member
May 26, 2004
4,799
2,145
I would rename it the uefa Cup, and make it a straight knock out competition. No teams dropping in from the Champions League, no seedings, just like a proper cup competition.

And then, this is where it gets interesting, because there is another club cup competition that nobody cares about (outside supporters of the clubs involved, and even then only the teams from Europe and South America) the World Club Cup.

Lets go big with this compeititon. Two teams from Europe, two from South America, one or two from the others, dependant on how their teams do in previous competitions. Whack the prize money up to 20 mill. Now clubs and fans are interested. Now winning the Uefa cup leads to something big, now teams want to win it etc etc etc
 

SouthbourneSpurs

New Member
Dec 12, 2009
22
0
Completely agree, but the only way to give cups the respect they deserve (domestically and continentally) involves pissing off all the major powers in football and risking a break away European Super League.

First step: Bring back the cup winners cup. The team that wins its national cup, and only that team, gets to play in this competition.

Second step: Only the champions in each country qualifies for the Champions League. Not the runners up, not the 3rd, not the 4th. CHAMPIONS ONLY! And teams who fail to get out of the group stage in the Champions League don't get to play in the Uefa cup, their European season ends there and then.

Third Step: Those teams that finish 2nd, 3rd and 4th in their domestic league (or in Englands case, 2nd and 3rd, with the league cup getting the last spot as, unlike other countries, we have 2 cup competitions) qualify for the Uefa cup.

All of a sudden, if only 1 team can get into the Champions league (making that competition more prestigious immediately), then the importance of getting into the uefa (europa, whatever) cup increases as well, because all of a sudden, even if still the poor relation, it is still an elite competition where you are likely to play Milan, Madrid, Munich, etc. Both competitions become more prestigious all of a sudden, the former because you really are just playing Champions, and the latter because you are playing against better teams than whoever krept into 6th spot in their league. Also, each countries domestic cup (and Englands favoured domestic cup) all become important again because winning them brings entry into a competition as exclusive as, and nearly as hard to win as the Champions league.

Is this turning the clock back 20 years? Yes. Is it the right thing to do? Completely. It wasn't broke, yet the meddled and meddled and meddled until we ended up with both domestic and continental cup competitions being a burden for the clubs, a turn off for the players and a waste of money for the fans.
Couldn't agree more. I interviewed Paul Miller for the Hotspur magazine and he made a good point about the UEFA Cup. When Spurs won it 1984, they beat some really great teams along the way. In fact, about a dozen clubs in the competition that year went on to win their respective domestic leagues (including Real Madrid, Celtic). Spurs turned over Bayern Munich, Feyenoord, Austria Vienna and Hadjuk Split before beating Anderlecht in the final. It was probably a harder trophy to win than the European Cup in 1984.
 

kaz Hirai

Well-Known Member
Nov 5, 2008
17,692
25,340
the reason why the champions league would be such a big thing for us is because the hope is that if we qualify then we sign higher class players there by creating a snowball effect that could see spurs one day soon challenging for the title
 

Adam456

Well-Known Member
Jul 1, 2005
4,464
3,144
Completely agree, but the only way to give cups the respect they deserve (domestically and continentally) involves pissing off all the major powers in football and risking a break away European Super League.

First step: Bring back the cup winners cup. The team that wins its national cup, and only that team, gets to play in this competition.

Second step: Only the champions in each country qualifies for the Champions League. Not the runners up, not the 3rd, not the 4th. CHAMPIONS ONLY! And teams who fail to get out of the group stage in the Champions League don't get to play in the Uefa cup, their European season ends there and then.

Third Step: Those teams that finish 2nd, 3rd and 4th in their domestic league (or in Englands case, 2nd and 3rd, with the league cup getting the last spot as, unlike other countries, we have 2 cup competitions) qualify for the Uefa cup.

All of a sudden, if only 1 team can get into the Champions league (making that competition more prestigious immediately), then the importance of getting into the uefa (europa, whatever) cup increases as well, because all of a sudden, even if still the poor relation, it is still an elite competition where you are likely to play Milan, Madrid, Munich, etc. Both competitions become more prestigious all of a sudden, the former because you really are just playing Champions, and the latter because you are playing against better teams than whoever krept into 6th spot in their league. Also, each countries domestic cup (and Englands favoured domestic cup) all become important again because winning them brings entry into a competition as exclusive as, and nearly as hard to win as the Champions league.

Is this turning the clock back 20 years? Yes. Is it the right thing to do? Completely. It wasn't broke, yet the meddled and meddled and meddled until we ended up with both domestic and continental cup competitions being a burden for the clubs, a turn off for the players and a waste of money for the fans.

Spot on. :clap:

Stable door has opened and will be very difficult to shut it. If we can't get countries to reduce emissions to save the world I doubt we'll get the CL clubs to voluntarily reduce their revenue
 

Adam456

Well-Known Member
Jul 1, 2005
4,464
3,144
Completely agree, but the only way to give cups the respect they deserve (domestically and continentally) involves pissing off all the major powers in football and risking a break away European Super League.

First step: Bring back the cup winners cup. The team that wins its national cup, and only that team, gets to play in this competition.

Second step: Only the champions in each country qualifies for the Champions League. Not the runners up, not the 3rd, not the 4th. CHAMPIONS ONLY! And teams who fail to get out of the group stage in the Champions League don't get to play in the Uefa cup, their European season ends there and then.

Third Step: Those teams that finish 2nd, 3rd and 4th in their domestic league (or in Englands case, 2nd and 3rd, with the league cup getting the last spot as, unlike other countries, we have 2 cup competitions) qualify for the Uefa cup.

All of a sudden, if only 1 team can get into the Champions league (making that competition more prestigious immediately), then the importance of getting into the uefa (europa, whatever) cup increases as well, because all of a sudden, even if still the poor relation, it is still an elite competition where you are likely to play Milan, Madrid, Munich, etc. Both competitions become more prestigious all of a sudden, the former because you really are just playing Champions, and the latter because you are playing against better teams than whoever krept into 6th spot in their league. Also, each countries domestic cup (and Englands favoured domestic cup) all become important again because winning them brings entry into a competition as exclusive as, and nearly as hard to win as the Champions league.

Is this turning the clock back 20 years? Yes. Is it the right thing to do? Completely. It wasn't broke, yet the meddled and meddled and meddled until we ended up with both domestic and continental cup competitions being a burden for the clubs, a turn off for the players and a waste of money for the fans.

Spot on. :clap:

Stable door has opened and will be very difficult to shut it. If we can't get countries to reduce emissions to save the world I doubt we'll get the CL clubs to voluntarily reduce their revenue :shrug:
 

hybridsoldier

Well-Known Member
Aug 2, 2004
5,892
1,185
the Europe League, just like the UEFA Cup is fundamentally flawed.

Its the money-grabbing UEFA who hand out not only places in the knockout stage to teams who ARE NOT GOOD ENOUGH to finish in the top 2 of a CL Group. But they have the audacity to give some of these sides SEEDINGS!!

Im a big Juve fan but I think its a total disgrace Juve were seeded, for a competition they didn't start the season in!

I can't think of any other cup you can are rewarded with a place in another cup for being so bloody shit you couldn't finish in the top 2.

It just UEFA trying to keep the rich rich really....its a disgrace...the UEFA Cup was a important competition for a long time...I am very proud we have won it, but if we were to win it now fans of jack shit sides like Boro or Newcastle would say "oh well its not a real cup anyway....its mickey mouse"

I dont blame the managers, I blame the bigwigs who organise this, the Europa League has not even had 1 run and its already a joke and I pray we are not in it next year!
 

CrazyConrad

Viking Yiddo
Aug 22, 2003
720
632
Completely agree, but the only way to give cups the respect they deserve (domestically and continentally) involves pissing off all the major powers in football and risking a break away European Super League.

First step: Bring back the cup winners cup. The team that wins its national cup, and only that team, gets to play in this competition.

Second step: Only the champions in each country qualifies for the Champions League. Not the runners up, not the 3rd, not the 4th. CHAMPIONS ONLY! And teams who fail to get out of the group stage in the Champions League don't get to play in the Uefa cup, their European season ends there and then.

Third Step: Those teams that finish 2nd, 3rd and 4th in their domestic league (or in Englands case, 2nd and 3rd, with the league cup getting the last spot as, unlike other countries, we have 2 cup competitions) qualify for the Uefa cup.

All of a sudden, if only 1 team can get into the Champions league (making that competition more prestigious immediately), then the importance of getting into the uefa (europa, whatever) cup increases as well, because all of a sudden, even if still the poor relation, it is still an elite competition where you are likely to play Milan, Madrid, Munich, etc. Both competitions become more prestigious all of a sudden, the former because you really are just playing Champions, and the latter because you are playing against better teams than whoever krept into 6th spot in their league. Also, each countries domestic cup (and Englands favoured domestic cup) all become important again because winning them brings entry into a competition as exclusive as, and nearly as hard to win as the Champions league.

Is this turning the clock back 20 years? Yes. Is it the right thing to do? Completely. It wasn't broke, yet the meddled and meddled and meddled until we ended up with both domestic and continental cup competitions being a burden for the clubs, a turn off for the players and a waste of money for the fans.

Totally agree mate!
 

drthfc

Member
Feb 2, 2006
105
1
It should be a straight knock out and forget this crap about not playing teams from your own country or seedings.

The Europa league I think, without looking too much into it, had 3 qualifying games then group games for 48 teams (6 games) then last 32! get to the final and I think you're looking at 14 games?

A knock out....like a proper cup! 512 teams, 9 rounds to the final, less games but more teams involved and play on a Tuesday or Wednesday, not a Thursday! oh and call it a cup again!!
 

DC_Boy

New Member
May 20, 2005
17,608
5
I'd like it to be a cup again - but as i say the key to its prestige is money - ATM it doesn't offer enough vis a vis the aggro involved to make it suitably sought after

double or triple the prize money - suddenly the game is worth the candle
 
Top