What's new

Lloyd Kelly

THFCSPURS19

The Speaker of the Transfer Rumours Forum
Jan 6, 2013
37,898
130,561
Clearly it's not happening this way, but are Tosin or Kelly really that much better than Tanganga? Tanganga is home grown, a decent 1 on 1 defender. Would I'm sure be happy as a squad option, not cost £20m, etc.

This season particularly, clearly Cuti and VDV are gonna play most games, and the issues come with injuries/suspensions, but tlikelihood is that whoever is back up will play with one of Cuti or VDV, and I'm sure will look fine. Am I crazy?
Ultimately I think Tanganga deserves to go somewhere he plays regularly.
 

Flobadob

Well-Known Member
Jul 22, 2014
3,637
12,369
Clearly it's not happening this way, but are Tosin or Kelly really that much better than Tanganga? Tanganga is home grown, a decent 1 on 1 defender. Would I'm sure be happy as a squad option, not cost £20m, etc.

This season particularly, clearly Cuti and VDV are gonna play most games, and the issues come with injuries/suspensions, but tlikelihood is that whoever is back up will play with one of Cuti or VDV, and I'm sure will look fine. Am I crazy?
Tosin is way better than Tanganga
 

sidford

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2003
11,431
30,161
Clearly it's not happening this way, but are Tosin or Kelly really that much better than Tanganga? Tanganga is home grown, a decent 1 on 1 defender. Would I'm sure be happy as a squad option, not cost £20m, etc.

This season particularly, clearly Cuti and VDV are gonna play most games, and the issues come with injuries/suspensions, but tlikelihood is that whoever is back up will play with one of Cuti or VDV, and I'm sure will look fine. Am I crazy?
Could be injury related as well. Tanganga has a terrible injury record so very hard to rely on him as a 3rd choice.
 

nicdic

Official SC Padre
Admin
May 8, 2005
41,857
25,920
Tosin is way better than Tanganga

Could be injury related as well. Tanganga has a terrible injury record so very hard to rely on him as a 3rd choice.

Tosin may well be much better, not saying he or Kelly aren't better, I just don't know enough about them, and I believe you drop Tanganga in alongside Cuti or VDV with the rest of the first XI and he'd be more than fine. Tanganga, as well as any of our CBs under Jose/Conte will look loads better in this first XI.
 

sidford

Well-Known Member
Oct 20, 2003
11,431
30,161
Tosin may well be much better, not saying he or Kelly aren't better, I just don't know enough about them, and I believe you drop Tanganga in alongside Cuti or VDV with the rest of the first XI and he'd be more than fine. Tanganga, as well as any of our CBs under Jose/Conte will look loads better in this first XI.
Like all our reserves you can only judge them when you play them with better players and not 8 other bloody subs (yea I'm still bitter)
But for me he can't be relied upon to be 3rd choice given his injury record
 

LukaKranjcar

Well-Known Member
May 8, 2010
915
5,431
Why wait until the last day?

Unless we're expecting Bournemouth to take Dier(and him accepting the move ofc) it gives them no time at all to replace.

We wouldn't sell in the same position.
 

tubbygold

Well-Known Member
Jan 12, 2021
936
2,552
Why wait until the last day?

Unless we're expecting Bournemouth to take Dier(and him accepting the move ofc) it gives them no time at all to replace.

We wouldn't sell in the same position.
If this was the plan, it's a very poor plan.
 

amathews3416

Well-Known Member
Mar 3, 2008
1,703
6,150
Why wait until the last day?

Unless we're expecting Bournemouth to take Dier(and him accepting the move ofc) it gives them no time at all to replace.

We wouldn't sell in the same position.
Because like ITK has been saying we have to sell to buy on these positions. I doubt we wanted to wait until end but reality is the market for our players hasn’t been there until today when dominoes start to fall across Europe.
 

kent brockman

Beware of the Daviesaurus
Sep 1, 2012
1,268
2,638
Why wait until the last day?

Unless we're expecting Bournemouth to take Dier(and him accepting the move ofc) it gives them no time at all to replace.

We wouldn't sell in the same position.

Hopefully not these days. We did sell Berba in exchange for Frazier Campbell though back in the day…
 

Flobadob

Well-Known Member
Jul 22, 2014
3,637
12,369
Tosin may well be much better, not saying he or Kelly aren't better, I just don't know enough about them, and I believe you drop Tanganga in alongside Cuti or VDV with the rest of the first XI and he'd be more than fine. Tanganga, as well as any of our CBs under Jose/Conte will look loads better in this first XI.
I’m not sure he would though. He wouldn’t at RB and he wouldn’t as RCB as he’s not better than Sanchez and we’ve seen him struggle only the other night even next to the excellent Van De Ven and Emerson. I think our entire defensive options would struggle playing into the midfield that played that match though, so it’s hard to really say. I definitely think it’s about upgrading the squad where we can though and the likes of Tosin and Kelly are both better players than Tanganga quite comfortably and it makes perfect sense targeting them to replace Japhet to me
 
Top