Name your GOAT in each position thread

[Spurs 1961]

Good thread but hard one to contribute to. I keep disagreeing with myself but here goes:

Goal: Jennings
Defence: Cafu - Beckenbauer - Baresi - Maldini

Midfield(ish): Garrincha - Mackay - Cruyff - Best

Forwards: Pele - Messi

Sadly no room for Greavsie or Maradona

 

[RuskyM]

Only going to go with what I've seen and could appreciate.

Cech; Zanetti, Maldini, van Dijk, Roberto Carlos; Iniesta, Modric, Makelele; Henry, R9, Messi.

van Dijk might seem odd but I find him incredible; there's just no weaknesses to him. He's like making a defender in a lab.

 

[spurs mental]

Not necessarily GOATS but some of my favourites mixed with who I think are the best who I've watched

I'm going 3-4-3

Schmeichel

Ramos
King
Nesta

Modric
Makelele
Zidane
Dembele

Messi
R9
Ronaldo


Bench: Lloris, Ramos, Marcelo, Walker, Carrick, Vertonghen, Kane, Bale, KDB, Xavi, Iniesta

 

[ralphs bald spot]

Poor bloke got so much grief/abuse when I watched him playing for Everton at Home Park, against Plymouth Argyle in the FA Cup. I'm gonna guess it was round about 87/88.

Played an absolute blinder, but had nothing but "fat greasy bastard" and Pasty crusts hurled at him for 90 minutes.

Was a brilliant 'keeper, though.

always remember his save from Falco in the game when we lost the League to them it was a stunner unbelievable

 

[gavspur]

Love this. I’m going for this. Although it was hard to leave Matthäus, Valderrama, Gazza, Ince, Roberto Carlos, King, Klinsmann, Higuita, Messi, Nesta, Batistuta, VdV etc etc etc out - it makes for a very good bench and squad tho!

 

[fishhhandaricecake]

These might not be GOAT in these positions, but these players are my favourite

Gianluigi Buffon ??

Lilian Thuram ?? ----- Franz Bekenbauer ?? --- Ledley King ???????----- Roberto Carlos ??

Diego Maradona ?? -- Mousse Dembele ?? --- Zinadane Zidane ?? --- Zico ??

Ronaldinho ??

Harry Kane ???????​

Love this team! ? ? and happy bday btw mate ? ?

 

[fishhhandaricecake]

GOAT ? TEAM:

Buffon ??

Lahm ??
King ??????? / Cannavaro ??
Maldini ??
A.Cole ???????

Zidane ??
Pirlo ??
Van Der Vaart ?? / Iniesta ??

Messi ??
C.Ronaldo ??
Cruyff ??

 

[Spursmatty87]

Cech
Cafu cannavaro King R Carlos
Modric Zidane Gazza
Messi Kane Ronaldo

obviously totally unbiased.

 

[brasil_spur]

Going with a strong attacking formation. Every game guarantees at least 3 goals at either end

Claudio Taffarel ??

Cafu ?? -------------- Aldair ?? ----- Roberto Carlos ??

Dunga ??
Socrates ?? ----------- Ronaldinho ??
Garrincha ?? ------------------------------------------------ Zico ??
Ronaldo ?? ------- Pele ??​

 

[fishhhandaricecake]

Going with a strong attacking formation. Every game guarantees at least 3 goals at either end

Claudio Taffarel ??

Cafu ?? -------------- Aldair ?? ----- Roberto Carlos ??

Dunga ??
Socrates ?? ----------- Ronaldinho ??
Garrincha ?? ------------------------------------------------ Zico ??
Ronaldo ?? ------- Pele ??​

Lucas Moura misses out?

 

[punkisback]

Neuer

Dani Alves Cannavaro Nesta Maldini

Zidane Xavi

Messi Ronaldinho C.Ronaldo

R9

Stupidly attacking team but hey ho.


Batistuta if we are allowed a supersub

This is it for me as well.

 

[N170ap]

................................Buffon......................

Cannavaro.......King........Maldini

.................................Pirlo.........................

...Zidane...Gascoinge...Iniesta...

...Messi.............................Ronaldinho.

...................Ronaldo (R9)....................

 

[Flobadob]

................................Buffon......................

Cannavaro.......King........Maldini

.................................Pirlo.........................

...Zidane...Gascoinge...Iniesta...

...Messi.............................Ronaldinho.

...................Ronaldo (R9)...................

Love that midfield