- Aug 22, 2014
- 13,603
- 58,005
So let's sack Paratici and all our scouts to save money then because they're utterly pointless in that case.
The analogy doesn't work because Conte is not an expert scout, nor does he even spend the majority of his time trying to scout.
Klopp had Salah as his 4th choice. He wanted Brandt, Draxler and Pulisic over him. Poch was gagging for Ndombele and Lo Celso. Managers are not recruitment experts and letting them have sole control of your recruitment policy is a shit idea.
The point is to have a conversation, The scouting team are not there to tell Conte what to do, they are there to support his needs and to give him more detailed information on Zaniolo and on other targets. This gives the manager more choice and allows for contingency, the point of Paratici is to then make whatever decision Conte decides happen. That's why when it fails, the responsibility is on the manager, hence why they get sacked quite quickly. This deal is not an example of a structured decision when the guy was 1 pdf from being registered for Everton.
You picking 1 example of where it worked out does not change that in Salah. Your example of Poch falls flat because for the 8 millionth time, Lo Celso was injured for 3 months and Poch had no time at all to integrate the players properly. The club then decided to hire a manager who doesn't believe midfielders are a real thing and was another shining example of a club that consistently hires resources such as managers, players, directors of football and other staff that don't fit together because it has no idea what it wants.