Would you...

[thekneaf]

Ok I see where your coming from and the fact that we do need a striker does change things a bit.

But let me make myself very clear...if all our CBs were out and we were playing Lennon and Modric at the back I still wouldn't take that turncoat back...never.

In that situation Mr Campbell would be a better option than Berbatov. I also suggest that this heart over head attitude may stifle any abition you have or managing at the highest level.

 

[Mr Pink]

In that situation Mr Campbell would be a better option than Berbatov. I also suggest that this heart over head attitude may stifle any abition you have or managing at the highest level.

Says who? :wink:

 

[JKSpurs]

he's have contract issues as Man u won't pay him the money he wants. Would he get that at Spurs... Not F-ing Likely !

 

[Matt C]

Even though he is a **** I would have him back in a heartbeat, yes he is 30 but he is a player that will still be sharp at 35/36.

He won't come back though and if his wage demands are too much for Utd they would be way out of our reach

 

[jonnyrotten]

No. He dropped us like a stone, refused to play for us, didn't even try to play for the team, and left us in the relegation zone.

Now I don't care if players like him are in short supply, we need players who are going to fight when the chips are down, not shrug their shoulders and hand in a transfer request. Allowing someone who did this much damage to the club to return smacks of desperation and low morale standards, it goes against the fabric of the club.

 

[StartingPrice]

Can't believe there's 23 people who wouldn't see him as a massive upgrade on what we have.

But I vorted 'no' and not because I don't see him as a superior strtiker to thosse presently at WHL - perhaps if you had read the answers rather than looking at the graph:shrug:

 

[adiepf]

yes

simply the most talented striker i have seen in football.....the best striker in the world whilst here..

 

[StartingPrice]

yes

simply the most talented striker i have seen in football.....the best striker in the world whilst here..

So, aside from the fact that he might not be 'best-fit' in this team and style of play, for all his talent (I believe that, don't agree, fine), wouldn't you have massive, (and I mean massive) qualms that he might putfrify our clearly very good team spirit? Or just start conspiring to get a move, again, straight away, or just plain shaft us AGAIN when we need him most:shrug:

 

[Azrael]

What is the point of this thread anyhow?

He's not coming back. End of.

 

[hughy]

Might as well lock this now Azrael has said that.