- Aug 22, 2014
- 13,603
- 58,005
I didn't particularly think the loss today was his fault (though he has to take responsibility as manager admittedly) I thought today was the first time in ages we tried to play decent football, we created plenty of chances. We should have put it to bed.
If you look at their 2 goals and you see Dier and Davies being pulled in and pulled apart on both and I think what can Jose do in that situation? Would Alderweireld and Vertonghen have fared any better? Based on what I've seen this season I'd say no. His tactic of having Tanganga as LCB on a 3 so we could double on Traore was working but as soon as he moved centrally to face Dier 1on1 they had the advantage. I don't see what Jose is meant to do in this situation, the players he got are the players he inherited, who else is going to be playing LB exactly? What other CB do we have that is going to steady the ship, there's a reason we had our youth CB being turned inside out for the 3rd goal because we don't have much other choice which is providing more solidity. Then you look at in my opinion having Gazzaniga instead of Lloris in goal costing us again I don't see what Jose is meant to do there. Our midfield duo worked well and we created plenty of chances considering there was no discernible outlet.
The only thing I'd say as a criticism would be the subs, perhaps left too late, especially Parrott, Gedson didn't help in anyway and we lost our shape. but you're all complaining but I haven't seen anybody discernibly make an argument for what Jose could have done differently because from where I'm sitting he set us up in a way to score goals and the players he had available conspired to leave us with a loss here.
If you look at their 2 goals and you see Dier and Davies being pulled in and pulled apart on both and I think what can Jose do in that situation? Would Alderweireld and Vertonghen have fared any better? Based on what I've seen this season I'd say no. His tactic of having Tanganga as LCB on a 3 so we could double on Traore was working but as soon as he moved centrally to face Dier 1on1 they had the advantage. I don't see what Jose is meant to do in this situation, the players he got are the players he inherited, who else is going to be playing LB exactly? What other CB do we have that is going to steady the ship, there's a reason we had our youth CB being turned inside out for the 3rd goal because we don't have much other choice which is providing more solidity. Then you look at in my opinion having Gazzaniga instead of Lloris in goal costing us again I don't see what Jose is meant to do there. Our midfield duo worked well and we created plenty of chances considering there was no discernible outlet.
The only thing I'd say as a criticism would be the subs, perhaps left too late, especially Parrott, Gedson didn't help in anyway and we lost our shape. but you're all complaining but I haven't seen anybody discernibly make an argument for what Jose could have done differently because from where I'm sitting he set us up in a way to score goals and the players he had available conspired to leave us with a loss here.