What's new

The Weekend ITK Discussion Thread - 23/24 July 2011

Shep

Well-Known Member
Nov 5, 2005
784
940
What's with the references to sweets in the itk? We any wiser on that?!

Arsenal have had to scrap their youth recruitment policy because Thomas Huddlestone broke into Wenger's office and stole his stash :grin:
 

Rob

The Boss
Admin
Jun 8, 2003
28,024
65,137
A great example of how a cryptic should be handled was Ryan's M&M one the other day. He confirmed who it was when it was guessed, even though he knew it would upset his boss's son. I guess the only issue with it was that it was a bit too easy to work out. However there is a balance to be struck in the level of difficulty.

See this is where we completely disagree.

No disrepect to Ryan at all but that's exactly the kind of cryptic that's pointless. It's guessed within an hour of being posted and served no real purpose.

As Bill, JJ and others have alluded to above, the reason some of The Goat's info is posted cryptically is so that the name doesn't get out and the club don't get wind of who's passing the information on to us. The majority of the names we've posted cryptically are players not linked to in the media and we only cryptic it when it'd be very obvious who the info is coming from.

We've taken on board the comments in here and will see if we can make any improvements to how it's done.
 

frazer

Member
Jan 27, 2011
90
106
We have all been looking for THE Man. Now it seems we've found him. And in German, if you please.

The capitol letters spell THEMA which in german is theme. Maybe theme park.
The man maybe man utd.
So Park from Man Utd.

Rubbish I know but it could be.
 

Spurvert

Huge Member
Jul 10, 2011
2,373
2,824
If we wont be able to solve the cryptics is there any point in posting them?

It's like saying: We're in talks with someone, I cant tell you who, but here's a little clue. Yes, it could be one of fifty players, but none of the ones you've guessed over the past two hours are correct. Evebn if you do guess the right name, I cant tell you. But keep guessing anyways, it's fun, right?

I'm all for cryptics if we're able/allowed to solve them. That seems fair, doesn't it?
 

Azrael

Banned
May 23, 2004
9,377
14
As Bill, JJ and others have alluded to above, the reason some of The Goat's info is posted cryptically is so that the name doesn't get out and the club don't get wind of who's passing the information on to us. The majority of the names we've posted cryptically are players not linked to in the media and we only cryptic it when it'd be very obvious who the info is coming from.
I knew Harry was posting here.

Triffic.
 

rebrab

Harry Cool
Jun 13, 2008
6,418
22,151
Just posted some ITK in the RO, now will be away for the day. Interesting to see how others react to my info, I think POTL has been keeping this one close to his chest personally. We shall see.
 

tez1503

Putting the "ass" in "classy"
Aug 15, 2008
164
357
abel hernandez fits the cryptic as well:grin:

herr = Mr (man) poster failed gcse german?
"and" in Hernandez

what do you think?.....
 

Alfieconnman

Ticket seller for the Dome of Doom
Aug 9, 2008
1,142
151
Just posted some ITK in the RO, now will be away for the day. Interesting to see how others react to my info, I think POTL has been keeping this one close to his chest personally. We shall see.

Thanks for that. I seem to remember some talk about our interest in him earlier last month - obviously we have gone back again. Could this mean that we have missed our prime targets and are moving down the list? His stats are not exactly electrifying.
 

rebrab

Harry Cool
Jun 13, 2008
6,418
22,151
Thanks for that. I seem to remember some talk about our interest in him earlier last month - obviously we have gone back again. Could this mean that we have missed our prime targets and are moving down the list? His stats are not exactly electrifying.

No, I think he is and always has been a major target.

Palermo have offered him a new contract though. Currently he's only there til 2013 so wouldn't be TOO expensive.
 

Klinsmannic

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2011
787
2,430
Would be absolutely chuffed if we managed to get A.Hernandez, especially if the price is fair (under 15m)
 

RJ1882

SC Supporter
Aug 28, 2010
2,122
1,843
Benzema would make sense as a target if the info supplied in January was correct. Why put in all that ground work to then just walk away?
Though you would imagine he would have more attractive options and higher payers than us if he were available.

I believe someone mentioned Abel Hernandez yesterday when guessing the German cryptic, though not sure how they came up with that.

Thanks Rebrab and Brownhead for info
 

Klinsmannic

Well-Known Member
Jun 22, 2011
787
2,430
I don't know much about Abel Hernandez. What type of player is he?

Quick, skillful 6 footer with a powerful left foot. He can link and play on the shoulder. He's still raw which is no bad thing as with some time in the gym he could be moulded into what we need, i.e. a proper number 9
 

lifeof...

Well-Known Member
Mar 18, 2005
2,073
248
Just posted some ITK in the RO, now will be away for the day. Interesting to see how others react to my info, I think POTL has been keeping this one close to his chest personally. We shall see.

thanks for this....

and lastly on the goats cryptic, there are now approx 40 names been guest, some tongue in cheek, some "deemed" good answers", some kind of ignored. and some TBH beyond my comprehension. So what has it really achieved?

here is another plausible one,

We have all been looking for THE Man. Now it seems we've found him. And in German, if you please.

If you take that, the 1st part as looking for something - its lost...translate lost into to German, as the cryptic may suggest and you get Verloren

add the "i think they failed gsce German", the cryptic creator may have thought it was spelt, Ferloran in this you can find Forlan, which is someone later Rob alluded to later on.


I'll take the "clean" info
 
Top