- Aug 21, 2011
- 14,543
- 31,121
I love AVB but will call him out when he gets it wrong and he got it wrong tonight. He doesn't understand how to get the best out of his players at times. Hudd and Parker need to play in the hole in front of the defence. Play them both and they get in each others way or one is forced to play forward in a role they can't do and pretty much end up in no-man's land, which was Parker ALL night. He was forced to make runs in the channels, run with the ball and try to get our attacks going. He was completely shit at it and just got in the way, he wasn't even tackling or clearing up. It's not his fault because that's not where he should be, it's AVB's fault. Holtby looked good but he's a passing player. He needs movement in front of him and runs coming from the midfielders around him. He only had the isolated Ade in front, a man marked Bale and the static Hudd and Parker behind him. Lennon wasn't looking confident and didn't get involved. That meant that his quick one touch passed were pointless because there was no movement going forward around him. Modric was the same, he looked terrible playing in the hole, you put some decent movement in front of him however and he suddenly turned in to Xavi.
AVB should have played a 4-3-3 with one out of Hudd and Parker. In front of him you'd have Holtby and Siggurdson. That way Parker or Hudd can do what they do best sweeping up just in front of the back four. There's far more movement to pass to out from the back and it will be far less predictable. The full backs can press up because there's a genuine DM who can drop in to the back line and cover. Holtby will have Sig making runs in front of him that allows him to use his passing skills and opening up space for the likes of Bale, Lennon and Ade. It doesn't weaken us defensively because both Sig and Holtby are strong in the tackle and will press better up the pitch than an out of position Parker or Hudd. I genuinely think that the forward position in a midfield 3 is Sig's best position so it's perfect.
Well done to AVB for making the changes and motivating the side for fantastic comeback but we shouldn't have been starting off on the wrong foot. What I don't get it is that AVB favoured the 4-3-3 at his previous clubs yet he refuses to play it here, despite it being the formation most suited to our plays. All in all frustrating
AVB should have played a 4-3-3 with one out of Hudd and Parker. In front of him you'd have Holtby and Siggurdson. That way Parker or Hudd can do what they do best sweeping up just in front of the back four. There's far more movement to pass to out from the back and it will be far less predictable. The full backs can press up because there's a genuine DM who can drop in to the back line and cover. Holtby will have Sig making runs in front of him that allows him to use his passing skills and opening up space for the likes of Bale, Lennon and Ade. It doesn't weaken us defensively because both Sig and Holtby are strong in the tackle and will press better up the pitch than an out of position Parker or Hudd. I genuinely think that the forward position in a midfield 3 is Sig's best position so it's perfect.
Well done to AVB for making the changes and motivating the side for fantastic comeback but we shouldn't have been starting off on the wrong foot. What I don't get it is that AVB favoured the 4-3-3 at his previous clubs yet he refuses to play it here, despite it being the formation most suited to our plays. All in all frustrating