What's new

Jay Rodriguez

kaz Hirai

Well-Known Member
Nov 5, 2008
17,692
25,340
,Massively underwhelmed when this a huge indication the manager is getting the players in he wants. That is so significant IMO.

Sorry, that just boggles my mind.

Mmm.
A manager getting who it wants doesn't equal great things.

Levy tried to get moutinho and Willian but they are much more difficult to do. He got redknapp his choice of gallas, Parker, crouch and adebayor. 4 players not too popular at the time. A spurs manager gettin the players he wants isn't unheard off its just avb came from Porto and his ex players were elite status types.

If tim sherwood was still in charge and got what he wanted, Ferdinand, caulker, the return of livermoore and selling off capoue, holtby, Sandro I feel your mind would boggle so much you may just slip into a coma mr pink
 

Mr Pink

SC Supporter
Aug 25, 2010
55,361
100,852
Mmm.
A manager getting who it wants doesn't equal great things.

Levy tried to get moutinho and Willian but they are much more difficult to do. He got redknapp his choice of gallas, Parker, crouch and adebayor. 4 players not too popular at the time. A spurs manager gettin the players he wants isn't unheard off its just avb came from Porto and his ex players were elite status types.

If tim sherwood was still in charge and got what he wanted, Ferdinand, caulker, the return of livermoore and selling off capoue, holtby, Sandro I feel your mind would boggle so much you may just slip into a coma mr pink

Nope.
 

LiamJM10

Active Member
Aug 24, 2013
389
612
Ignore the price, when you consider we will sell a midfielder to compensate his arrival, he'll only cost us 10-15m in theory. If that.

That's ignoring any possible loanees or makeweights we throw at them. I'd like to see Rose gone, Ceballos and Carroll on loan.
 

Ossie85

Rio de la Plata
Aug 2, 2008
3,934
13,273
BtokzadIUAA3Aon.jpg:large


:D:D
 

ItsBoris

Well-Known Member
Jan 18, 2011
7,979
9,435
Mmm.
A manager getting who it wants doesn't equal great things.

Levy tried to get moutinho and Willian but they are much more difficult to do. He got redknapp his choice of gallas, Parker, crouch and adebayor. 4 players not too popular at the time. A spurs manager gettin the players he wants isn't unheard off its just avb came from Porto and his ex players were elite status types.

If tim sherwood was still in charge and got what he wanted, Ferdinand, caulker, the return of livermoore and selling off capoue, holtby, Sandro I feel your mind would boggle so much you may just slip into a coma mr pink

Are you saying Poch isn't human? :eek:
 

sloth

Well-Known Member
Mar 7, 2005
9,018
6,900
You crack me up! Last sentence contradicts first, second and third sentences are not mutually exclusive and everyone and their mum knows it.

I probably I didn't word it clearly enough for you AB. Anyway, here's what I wrote:

No chairman of a club with an offer for his player is simply going to accept it, unless the offer is as great as any other he can realistically imagine getting. Levy doesn't make those kinds of offers, he makes offers which he thinks will bring his club value for its money. There was no way Levy was going to make an offer Southampton couldn't refuse, and we wouldn't want him to either. Liverpool getting involved is immaterial to the calculation of a value for money offer for Rodriguez.

So if we put the first and second sentences together you get:

No chairman of a club with an offer for his player is simply going to accept it, unless the offer is as great as any other he can realistically imagine getting. Liverpool getting involved is immaterial to the calculation of a value for money offer for Rodriguez.

I think the confusion stems because in general language value can sometimes mean cost, however I was using it in a stricter sense... in this case then 'value' = true worth.

So put more clearly, our calculation of his true worth / value is not dependent on whether Liverpool want him or not. We have an idea that he's worth, for example, £8m, even if Liverpool come into the equation and they put in a bid for £9m, his value doesn't suddenly shoot up to above £8m. As I said his value is independent of the competition for his signature, even if obviously his price is not.

The whole point being that if we've bid £8m and that's what we think he's worth, but Southampton think they can get more than that, then they won't sell him to us, and if Liverpool or whoever bid more than us then they'll get him and we'd be correct to let them.

'
 

Partizan

Well-Known Member
Aug 3, 2005
6,574
3,407
Must admit this made me laugh a bit from J.Rodriguez' whoscored profile page for last season:

Jay Rodriguez's Characteristics

+ Strengths
(Player has no significant strengths)

- Weaknesses
Holding on to the ball Weak
Crossing Weak
Passing Weak
Finishing Weak
Offside awareness Weak

:eek:;)
 

moomin

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2011
1,950
2,899
how good is he really? could someone give me a paragraph or 2 summary of what his game is like?
 

moomin

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2011
1,950
2,899

that has to be the worst goals&skills video song of all time

thanks though. that goal at :56 was extremely beautiful. having him as a threat to do that on the left, and lamela offering the same on the right would be massive.
 

BehindEnemyLines

Twisting a Melon with the Rev. Black Grape
Apr 13, 2006
4,656
13,497
cAN WE ALL POLITELY AGREE NOT TO KEEP CALLING HIM j-rOD? I hATE IT WITH AS MUCH VENGEANCE AS WHEN I FORGET I'VE GOT THE CAPS-LOCK ON HALF WAY THROUGH WRITING A REPLY!
 

Ghost Hardware

Well-Known Member
Aug 31, 2012
18,597
64,342
I am just not buying into the Jay Rod transfer. He's a good player but I would like to see if he can be back to his best before making a move. I also would like to see Chadli given a shot at Pochs rotating AM 3 before moving for Jay. Was never a doubt in my mind we would get him tho, Kono, Depay and AG were nothing but pipe dreams for LWF.
 
Top