What's new

Croatia Vs Brazil: QF

ralvy

AVB my love
Jun 26, 2012
2,512
4,630
Top 1 mate. Xavi and Iniesta have no argument left. They were eating Nusr-Et salt bae steak in Qatar at this age. Modric pulling 120 minute MOTM performances against Brazil.

Levels.

Zidane and Matthaus have arguments I suppose. But Modric best midfielder of this era hands down.

Nah, those two won a world cup and a couple of Euros. I respect Luka inmensely, but Xavi and Iniesta have the edge over him.
 

nailsy

SC Supporter
Jul 24, 2005
30,536
46,630
Imagine if Yugoslavia never broke up. They'd be able to field a ridiculously good team.

Imagine if there was a combined English and Scottish squad....

It would be the same as the current England squad wouldn't it?
 

Trix

Well-Known Member
Jul 29, 2004
19,656
331,874
Imagine if there was a combined English and Scottish squad....

It would be the same as the current England squad wouldn't it?
You don't think Andy Robertson would play over Luke Shaw?
 

rossdapep

Well-Known Member
Aug 25, 2011
22,360
80,567
With that goal he scored, it's fair that everything should be about him.

I never thought I would say this, but today it was the Brazilian team (and coach) letting Neymar down, and not the other way around. With just five minutes to go in overtime, and already having the advantage, how the hell Croatia was able to find just three Brazilian defenders?
It was ridiculous and amateurish for that to happen. That's on the leadership of the team.
 

isaac94

Well-Known Member
Jan 5, 2017
2,950
9,806
Nah, those two won a world cup and a couple of Euros. I respect Luka inmensely, but Xavi and Iniesta have the edge over him.
xavi and iniesta had a array of amazing players around them at the international level, luka does not. Croatia getting to 2 semis is as impressive as spain winning a world cup considering the size of the nations.
The fact that at the age of 34 Iniesta was playing in the Japanese league and Modric at 37 is still a elite player who just won a CL and is the star man for his nation reaching a WC semi settles it, longevity counts for a lot in this sport
 

ralvy

AVB my love
Jun 26, 2012
2,512
4,630
xavi and iniesta had a array of amazing players around them at the international level, luka does not. Croatia getting to 2 semis is as impressive as spain winning a world cup considering the size of the nations.
The fact that at the age of 34 Iniesta was playing in the Japanese league and Modric at 37 is still a elite player who just won a CL and is the star man for his nation reaching a WC semi settles it, longevity counts for a lot in this sport

Yeah but why? Why should longevity be the deciding factor that settles this discussion? Perhaps it's worth considering what stress does to one's body, and Xavi and Iniesta reaching three main finals back to back certainly must have experienced their fair share of it.

And Spain didn't just won a world cup, they won it by sandwiching it between two Euro cup tittles as well. Show me any other 45 million> nations who have been able to achieve such a feat. Also, you can't go around trying to pin Xavi and Iniesta's success mainly on the strength of the squad they were playing with, and then try to give Modric any credit for Madrid's at CL..
 

isaac94

Well-Known Member
Jan 5, 2017
2,950
9,806
Yeah but why? Why should longevity be the deciding factor that settles this discussion? Perhaps it's worth considering what stress does to one's body, and Xavi and Iniesta reaching three main finals back to back certainly must have experienced their fair share of it.

And Spain didn't just won a world cup, they won it by sandwiching it between two Euro cup tittles as well. Show me any other 45 million> nations who have been able to achieve such a feat. Also, you can't go around trying to pin Xavi and Iniesta's success mainly on the strength of the squad they were playing with, and then try to give Modric any credit for Madrid's at CL..
all amazing players who should be heralded as the greatest, personally like modric more, because you can see how Modric pushes his team on sometimes single handled at international level, quite inspiration, whilst xavi and iniesta had a golden generation around them villa, torres, pique, puyol, ramos, alba, alonso, fabregas, , so wasn't afforded the same opportunity to do so, still amazing players mind
 
Top