What's new

Did we need Modric?

Rackybear

You Must Respect Ma Authowita!
Aug 10, 2008
4,613
19
I dont understand why you are all giving this guy such a hard time, even when i read the article title, i thought "here we go", but having read it, he raises a really good point.

If we had left Jenas to play the modric (attacking, playmaking / goalscoring midfielder role), and had spent the money we used on modric instead on someone like Veloso, Carrick, or that kind of calibre player perhaps our midfield would have more balance.

Whilst modric is a great player and a great signing, him AND jenas in the midfield isnt really what we need. I think this point has been raised before, but rightly so, both of them prefer to be attacking midfielders, neither of them have a preference for defending. Look at the top clubs:-

Chelsea - Essien/Mikel Hold and clean things up with not much intention to support attacks whilst Lamps, Ballack and now Deco can play further up the pitch.

Man Utd - Carrick/Hargreaves sit back, Scholes pushes on.

Liverpool - Mascherano/Alonso hold, gerrard pushes.

Arsenal - Fabregas box to box with a holding player in flamini, who will do it now, who knows.

But spurs need to find a similar balance, Jenas and Modric cant do that simply because its neither of their natural game. Sure ramos can ask Jenas to sit, but we are wasting his abilities by doing that, and also have a player who isnt that great at it either. Let him express himself on the game, push forward, make runs into the box and give us a goal threat, what i just said for Jenas applies for modric too, we need to let him loose in the "hole" and playmake and impact the attacking play from their, not from just in front of our defence!
 

spurs4europe

misses the snow!
Oct 11, 2004
1,105
201
wow. just wow.

no, no i'll be serious now. you're clearly right, after 1 GAME in the PL he's actually the big pretender and is our worst midfielder by far.

perhaps when we get the defensive midfielder we so desperately crave it'll be pushed who will be pushed up a bit further. did you not think of that?

joker.
 

PLTuck

Eternal Optimist
Aug 22, 2006
15,981
33,238
All I will say is that I am very confident that Modric will become a VERY important player for us.

But it will take time. Before he can start to impose himself on our midfield, he has to adjust to the pace of the Prem, which can easily take a full season, even with big strong lads like Drogba. May I remind people how many were saying Berbs wouldn't cut it after his first game and his "It's so quick!" comment when asked about the PL after his first league game for us.

Modric is the type of player we can build a team around. That team isn't quite in place yet but have patience and I firmly believe he will become as important for us as Carrick was. From what little I've seen, he is very Carrick-esque, although he prefers playing further upfield.
 

Krafty

Well-Known Member
May 26, 2004
4,785
2,126
I am delighted with Modric's signing, exactly the type of player we need. We need other players to step up. I think Modric will slip under the radar, we will start winning and while Bentley or Gio get the praise it will be because of Modric.

I expect to see the very best of him in Europe where it will be a bit slower pace - might take him a month or so to get used to the pace of the Prem, but he is still very young and has massive potential.
 

southlondonyiddo

My eyes have seen some of the glory..
Nov 8, 2004
12,652
15,206
Did we need to buy a World Class footballer??

errrrrrrrrr........... nah who needs them!! Better off with the likes of Howells, Sedgely and Pratt
 

charlatan.uk

Banned
Aug 11, 2008
166
0
who slated him? not me.

I suggested we may have spent the money more wisely. It seems to me most of our signings havent really been following an agenda, if its available buy it.


Quite impressed he is a sacred cow already despite doing nothing good or bad yet. One must never question the Modric obviously.
 

Dougal

Staff
Jun 4, 2004
60,372
130,304
We got in early with the Modric signing and after an impressive Euro 2008 it's probably good that we did. We have more money to spend and until the window closes I'm not going to make judgements on how well we've done in the transfer market this summer.
 

polski sklep

█ ██ █ █ ██ ████
Aug 18, 2008
354
0
who slated him? not me.

I suggested we may have spent the money more wisely. It seems to me most of our signings havent really been following an agenda, if its available buy it.


Quite impressed he is a sacred cow already despite doing nothing good or bad yet. One must never question the Modric obviously.

You're looking for trouble.
 

catesy2018

Member
Oct 5, 2004
272
1
To answer the thread's question:

Yes.

He has bags of talent, he just needs time to settle, and even if he doesn't do it for Spurs in sure that big reputation will mean he fetch a big price on his way out.
 

Dwallace

Active Member
May 12, 2008
295
60
The simple answer is yes we have needed a player like Modric for a while.Now we have to get someone decent to play like Veloso to pla alongside him.
 
Top