Very well put. Martin Keown won three league titles, three FA cups and a European Cup-winners cup, yet he never seems to be watching the same sport as everyone else.Is there an agreed level that people should have played football to, for them to know what they're talking about?
I really hate this view of "well, you've never played the sport so you don't know what you're talking about", it's ignorant and arrogant bollocks.
I like boxing, mma and cricket too but I've never "played" any of them - Does that mean that I don't know what I'm talking about with regards to those sports?
I have played American Football though and I still don't understand anything about that sport.
You really don't need to have played a sport to be able to study and understand it and comments such as yours just come across as piffle to shut other people down that don't agree with you.