Rate The Ref

[Yid121]

Please rate Chris Foy's refereeing performance against Bolton using the poll above.

I am submitting a poll after each of our domestic league/cup matches and keeping track of the results, so we can keep track of referees that ref well for us :wink: / just do a good job.

0/10 option is not going to be added as if we were to change the rating system previous results would be invalid!

Results
Andre Marriner - Man City (H) - Av. Rating 6.06 (89 votes cast)
Chris Foy - Stoke (A) - Av. Rating 6.34 (99 votes cast)
Phil Dowd - Wigan (H) - Av. Rating 4.69 (43 votes cast)
Howard Webb - West Brom (A) - Av. Rating 4.16 (62 votes cast)
Mike Jones - Wolves (H) - Av. Rating 5.62 (53 votes cast)
Lee Probert - Arsenal (H) - Av. Rating 2.27 (64 votes cast)
Martin Atkinson - West Ham (A) - Av. Rating 6.47 (30 votes cast)
Mark Clattenburg - Aston Villa (H) - Av. Rating 4.30 (73 votes cast)
Mike Dean - Fulham (A) - Av. Rating 7.87 (68 votes cast)
Mike Jones - Everton (H) - Av. Rating 2.52 (153 votes cast)
Mark Clattenburg - Man Utd (A) - Av. Rating 1.42 (115 votes cast)
​

_

 

[Yid121]

Was a bit iffy but not herrendous, gave a 3 as he let Bolton get away with some reckless tackles and ridiculous time wasting at the end.

 

[Winchy85]

Gave a 4 for not showing any real bottle in booking players for reckless tackles. Steinsson should have seen yellow after 4 minutes and Davies should have seen yellow for one of two incidents, Bale and Hutton tackles. Huddlestone should have also seen yellow (maybe red?) for his stamp on Elmander.

 

[tommyt]

5 - wasn't horrendous, wasn't stupendous.

 

[Alfieconnman]

I gave a 4. First goal was offside. Allowed some heavy challenges (on both sides) go unpunished. Otherwise not too bad.

 

[paddy30]

Gave him a 7 1st goal was offside but thats up to the linesman to see,He should of booked Davies for tackle on Bale but apart from that he was excellent,He gave frees when he had to and let the play go one of the best we have had....

 

[CaptainCat]

I gave a 4. First goal was offside. Allowed some heavy challenges (on both sides) go unpunished. Otherwise not too bad.

The referee's fault?

He missed a few things. Huddlestone should have been booked or sent off, a couple of Bolton's players should have been booked, but he got the penalty decision right. 5/10.

 

[mano-obe]

Some people complained about hard challenges but its a mans game. We got away with a few yesterday too.

Apart from the offside (linos fault) he let the game flow. In someways it might have benefited Spurs if he was a power tripper as Bolton were in full flow a lot of the times.

His biggest mistake was not spotting Thudd's stamp. It would have been nice if he booked him, as he's looking at a suspension now

 

[garyhopkins]

Was a bit iffy but not herrendous, gave a 3 as he let Bolton get away with some reckless tackles and ridiculous time wasting at the end.

Have to agree. Steinsson and Davies should have been booked. Had he made the bookings then Bolton wouldn't have had it quite so easy in ruffling the feathers of our easily ruffled darlings! And I know everyone will waste time given the chance but refs should do something about it.

 

[saintlyspur]

compared to the refs in our last two league games i thought he was ok

 

[StartingPrice]

Gave him a 7 1st goal was offside but thats up to the linesman to see,He should of booked Davies for tackle on Bale but apart from that he was excellent,He gave frees when he had to and let the play go one of the best we have had....

This.

What value is there in giving Clatty 1, and looking for a Zero option, if every ref gets a similar grade.

Yeah, the first goal WAS offside, but that's the lino's job, and mistakes are inevitable...it is wen the mistakes are absurd, followed by a refusal to back-down, and accompanied by blatant favouritism and cowardice that I get miffed!