Sherwood or Moyes

[Riandor]

Absolutely neither!!!!!

Moyes takes a Championship winning team and drags them to 7th.
Martinez takes Moyes old team and drags them up to 5th, hammering at 4th.

Sorry but whilst i don't think Moyes is a terrible manager, he is NOT what we need. I would also rather not be another springboard for a failed manager.

 

[Rout-Ledge]

I'd take Glenn Hoddle and his demented 5-3-2 over either of them

 

[Rout-Ledge]

Sherwood with Meulensteen and a good defensive coach

We'd end up with a squad consisting of a couple of disillusioned senior players, Adebayor, and 15 promoted youth players if we stick with Sherwood.

 

[Flashspur]

Moyes was found out at Manure. A good mid table manager aspiring to a 6th placing at best. Solid and unspectacular like a Scottish accountant. I agree with some on here that he wont take us any further but he will certainly give us stability. But I think we left the stability bit right behind us after HR whet our appetities for top 4 and the CL.

Personally i think he'll need 12 months away from football after the stress of Manure.

 

[Rout-Ledge]

Moyes was found out at Manure. A good mid table manager aspiring to a 6th placing at best. Solid and unspectacular like a Scottish accountant. I agree with some on here that he wont take us any further but he will certainly give us stability. But I think we left the stability bit right behind us after HR whet our appetities for top 4 and the CL.

Personally i think he'll need 12 months away from football after the stress of Manure.

I'd rather a bit of soul, some excitement and shit defending than a dour defensive Moyes team.

Stability is only worthwhile if you're where you want to be in the first place.

 

[absolute bobbins]

Neither but if I had to choose it'd be Sherwood, his long ball football is better than Moyes 'death by a million crosses' football

 

[nightgoat]

 

[EastLondonYid]

I'm dreaming of Wenger resigning and the scum employing Moyes with Sherwood as his assistant...

 

[Bobbins]

Why isn't there an AIDS option in the poll.

I would choose AIDS.

 

[M.I.B.]

Moyes. One difficult period under a weight of enormous expectation does not make him a bad manager.

No, but several seasons of dour, defensive, un-imaginative football with Everton might.
As someone said above, Martinez took the same bunch of players, plus a couple of loanees, and look at them noe.

 

[parklane1]

Neither of them.

 

[THX2208]

Why isn't there an AIDS option in the poll.

I would choose AIDS.

Full blown AIDS?

 

[ilikeost]

Sherwood. At least he didn't buy Fellaini for £24 million.

 

[Blackrat1299]

Not much of a selection how about neither of them!

 

[Tom Pops]

In all honesty I think I'd rather just stick with Tim in that instance.

 

[avonspurs]

Moyes or Sherwood? Like asking me to choose between saving my boy or girl in a house fire....... except I couldn't chose between my boy or girl because I love them dearly, whereas with Moyes or Sherwood, I'd couldn't choose because I'd want both to burn!

 

[Misfit]

Well Moyes. But...

 

[THX2208]

 

[Rout-Ledge]

Sherwood. At least he didn't buy Fellaini for £24 million.

£27.5m...and people say Soldado was a waste of money.

 

[The Scarecrow]

Sherwood. At least his style is fairly close to The Tottenham Way.