- Dec 12, 2004
- 3,923
- 166
Yeah, he was crapola. First of all, there's not that many talented QB's that are NFL-worthy. It's such a hard position to play. Not even every team's starter is that great. Nevermind the backup. You'll get a ton of QB's who excel in college but don't make the grade in the NFL for whatever reason. So many Heisman trophy (awarded to the 'best' college player that year) winners have not made it over the years it's untrue. Case in point, Troy Smith won the Heisman last year, he was drafted in the 5th round by the Ravens and is slumming it as their 3rd string QB. Why? Because he was deemed to short. The tiniest thing that scouts can nitpick will be scrutinised. You literally have to be perfection personified to even get your shot.
QB depth in the NFL is worse than any other position, not only because there's so few quality QB's avalaible and so those that are available will likely get a starting gig somewhere else (see Jeff Garcia). But, also because a starting QB plays the whole game (99% of the time), every game. Backups don't get a look in unless there's an injury or the starter sucks(in which case if you're the backup you suck even worse anyway). On teams that are considered to have good QB depth, you'll either find an old, experienced QB who's seeing out his career (see Brad Johnson on the Cowboys, Kurt Warner on the Cards, Trent Dilfer on the 49'ers) or a young, relatively new QB who's being groomed and/or a reliable but unspectacular 'move the chains' backup (see Kolb and Feeley on the Eagles). The fact that in those two examples Brad Johnson and Feeley have got it done in the NFL before is why those two teams are generally considered to have the best QB depth in the NFL.
And before Leinart's and Smith's injuries, you could also say the same about the Cards and 49'ers.
So yeah, QB depth is generally not good. But backup QB's generally don't see the light of day anyway.
As for the Jags, well, they're a running team, so they should be running all the time no matter who their QB is. That's how they beat the Colts last year. They pounded the ball and ran for something ridiculous like 375 yards. This year, they change it up and look what happens. Then in the 4th quarter they revert back to their 'O-line dominatrix run all over your face' game and go straight down and score a TD. That game was a prime example of a coach trying to get too cute. Obviously having Bob Sanders helped the Colts this time around, but still, run the damn ball. Something i wish the Eagles would do more.
:up:
Great run-down.
Cheers mate.