Whilst I agree about learning with players in training, it's match time (competitive) that'll sort the good from the not so good.
Ideally a loan to a lower prem team, but Championship is also good. So it seems it's more of the players in between ressies/first team that do the loans, rather than the development piece itself.
Only way to know if someone is ready, is by getting matches, rather than in training where intensity is never as high.
Totally agree Shanks. There a stat when we were linked to McCarthy saying he has over 200 games under his belt, for the little age difference between him and Carrol, that's a hell of a lot of senior football in anyone's book.
It must be extremely difficult when full internationals have to move on due to not getting enough playing time. And we fans demand the results, or even scorelines, and if we dont get it the boos ring out.
Would anyone else put a novice in that position?