Barry or Carrick

[Teemu]

Neither, bring Steffen Freund out of retirement.

 

[There's always next year]

Carrick is far superior. Barry makes Huddlestone look like a greyhound. The fact he gets picked for England is no benchmark for class and ability.

 

[double0]

Barry

 

[bubble07]

carrick because that is his natural position. For Villa Barry is not a holding midfield player. If we cant get carrick back in the summer we should try and get alonso

 

[Limee]

Carrick everytime.

 

[striebs]

Scrap the holding DM role because it is less conducive to attractive football than two box to boxers .

 

[Cicada]

pointless debate, so i voted the goat option..

we'll never get either of them..

give me the crazyness of didier zokora anyday

 

[P-Dogg]

I'd prefer Barrick.

 

[eViL]

It's a tough one.

I'm a big Carrick fan, but he can only play in one position.

Barry can play anywhere on the left or down the centre, so in terms of value for money and value to the team, I'd go for Barry even though he's the least talented of the two.

 

[Kendall]

I'd prefer Barrick.

I'm a Carry man myself.

 

[The Apprentice]

Gareth Barry is the most immobile player I've ever seen. He's one dimensional and passes sideways and backwards. Massively over rated.

Carrick is twice the player Barry is. Of that I am sure.

 

[don1]

carrick for me would love to get him back but i dont think that will happen

 

[Yid-ol]

Carrick, we have seen what he can do in our team already, and i dont think Barry would be as good

 

[jimtheyid]

Carrick every single day of every week of every year

 

[st@rbug]

Barry, just cos i dont like Carrick, bah

 

[parklane_n17]

carrick everytime he would never come back while levy and commoli here though

 

[PantherX]

The thought of Goat in a Spurs shirt makes me w....erm....excited.

To be honest though our midfield hasn't been the same since Carrick buggered off and we would probably have a better chance of getting him than Barry who starts evrey game for AV.

If we could only get Goat though..............

 

[PantherX]

The thought of Goat in a Spurs shirt makes me w....erm....excited.

To be honest though our midfield hasn't been the same since Carrick buggered off and we would probably have a better chance of getting him than Barry who starts evrey game for AV.

If we could only get Goat though..............

 

[sundancer]

Has to be Carrick, I really believe we have never replaced him and if we had not sold we would be a better team.

 

[hodspurs]

carrick everytime he would never come back while levy and commoli here though

?? why?? they wanted the lad to stay,i cant see why he would have a problem with them.maybe levy might not have him back because he wanted out.