Holtby or Sigurdsson?

[MkYid]

I was saying to my friends who were writing Holtby off last season to wait this season and he will be immense. His presence on and off the ball is top notch and imo he has a footballing brain like teddy teddy Sheringham or modric. I think is the closest like for like modric type player in the squad and the boy is tenacious.

Sigs has got qualities butalways looks like he'll get tackled when trying to take on players.

Sigs is a good squad player but holtby can be much more.. Unfortunately I think his progress will be stunted with signing Eriksen.. top team problems eh!

 

[Wardy]

The thing is, as good as Holtby was last night, that wasn't a patch on his usual Schalke form.

Seriously? He can play much better than last night?

Questions why we are going for Erikson if that's the case!

 

[$hoguN]

Seriously? He can play much better than last night?

Questions why we are going for Erikson if that's the case!

Seriously and because Eriksen will give us options as a creative midfielder, a LWF and CAM.

 

[Mullers]

Seriously? He can play much better than last night?

Questions why we are going for Erikson if that's the case!

Because he is cheap and Liverpool won't get him?

 

[Wardy]

Seriously and because Eriksen will give us options as a creative midfielder, a LWF and CAM.

I think this has got to spell the end of Siggy then

 

[$hoguN]

I think this has got to spell the end of Siggy then

It almost certainly will imo

 

[Wardy]

It's a shame that he's not been able to produce like he did at Swansea

 

[OmarsComing]

EPL>Championship>League 1> Dynamo Tbilisi>League 2

 

[Lufti]

EPL>Championship>League 1> Dynamo Tbilisi>League 2

True but still, he showed he was the best player on the pitch yesterday, which still includes 10 of our players

 

[OmarsComing]

True but still, he showed he was the best player on the pitch yesterday, which still includes 10 of our players

Read the match ratings thread.

 

[Lufti]

Read the match ratings thread.

Okay, Holtby won MOTM by a mile on both threads - your point?

 

[Harry Barber]

I think this has got to spell the end of Siggy then

His body language last night certainly seemed as though this will be the case imo.

 

[FinnYid]

Holtby mainly for central midfield 2 or three, could be used as no. 10 too, but can't see that happening much. Eriksen as part of central midfield three or no. 10 could be used even on central midfield 2 or lm. Siggy, no.10 or lm mainly for us, could be used on either side though. Holtby all-arounder with creativity, Eriksen creator who can score and Siggy goalscoring attacking midfielder with bit of creativity on him. Wouldn't mind keeping them all with Chadli as option for LM and Lamela / Lennon as option on the right. No Andros for me.

 

[Wardy]

His body language last night certainly seemed as though this will be the case imo.

Yeh I saw that as well. I think after that shot he had cannoned back out, he almost said "can't get a break" and I can imagine that AVB probably spoke to him before the game saying he needs to improve