- Oct 19, 2004
- 39,837
- 50,713
There is only so far coaching goes, some of the mistakes stones was making was nothing to do with instructions given but rather issues with his mentality.
He got a lot of praise in one match for doing a Cruyff turn and the next thing we saw was him doing it every week when it clearly wasnt working anymore. Then he kept on playing himself in to trouble for the rest of the season. Instead of going simple he does unnecessarily go too complicated and then try to do too much. Hence why he did get dropped.
I think you are massively over exaggerating the amount of mistakes he made and personally I'd take the odd mistake as part of his development. Look at Pique or Ferdinand at his age. It's not like most of the CB's in the EPL weren't also making mistakes is it? Smalling, Mangala, Ottamendi, Cahill, Gabriel hell even Alderwiereld cost us a couple of goals at the business end.
What I saw was a young CB trying to get his head up at times and no one giving him options to receive the ball, which drives me fucking mad anywhere on the pitch, especially when it's a young kid. I think Martinez was a fucking coward for dropping him when it was his complete inability to organise and teach a team how to play without the ball that cost Everton (and Wigan before that) dearly, and Stones was scapegoated.