Your sarcasm is wasted on me. I acknowledge it but don't react. The Pav. argument I present is eminently based on reasoned logic, mathematical logic even, but if you can't be bothered that's fine. It's neither good nor bad of me to admit when I am wrong. Shall I start an 'Is Parker any better than Livermore' thread? The two games prior to his injury were Norwich and Swansea. He was very average against Swansea and decent against Norwich. He may have been carrying an injury by then.