2008/09 Players Hit or Miss

[Bemuser]

Simply vote who was a hit for you this season, and don't vote for those who you thought were a miss this season.

 

[markiespurs]

Where's Corluka?

 

[Bemuser]

Never before have the words "Oh, bugger" been more appropriate. Well, I think we all know he's been a hit but I wish I could change it.

 

[Leachie]

So basically the only thing I have learnt from this poll is that "Crow" is either completely mental or a WUM.

 

[freeeki]

21 people so far think Gunter has been poor? Idiots.

 

[louisg]

Who voted Alnwick, hes rubbish even his internet video was crap too.

 

[dimiSpur]

lol jenas stands at 50% at this moment in time.... Really does prove how he's turning into a marmite player

 

[LeeJay]

come on, who voted for alnwick.
you crazy prankster

no seriously, he's shit.

 

[Dr Know]

21 people so far think Gunter has been poor? Idiots.

I don't think we saw enough of him to make any judgement. Actually there are quite a few that could fall into that category

 

[freeeki]

I don't think we saw enough of him to make any judgement. Actually there are quite a few that could fall into that category

When we lost 2-1 to Man Utd, the boy was great. He got a yes vote from me. :clap:

 

[scat1620]

I don't think we saw enough of him to make any judgement. Actually there are quite a few that could fall into that category

That's how I feel. Don't think Gunter has been a 'Miss' this season, and I do like him as a player (I'd certainly see him rather than Chimbonda lining up in defence for us, for example). But he hasn't played enough games for me to feel like I can call him a 'Hit' either, much as I like the lad. So I'm one of the people who didn't vote for him, but that's no reflection on his skills or character because I think he will go on to be a decent player for Spurs. But I only voted for people who I thought have been bona fide 'Hits' for us this season, and Gunter didn't quite fall into that category.

 

[Dannyspur]

hit or miss doesn't really say enough. there are loads of players who have been 'ok' some like hudd who have been great and crap at the same time and some like gunter who haven't played enough.

 

[milkman]

Fail @ the poll

 

[Maske2g]

Speaks volumes, goalie and defensive players, and Modric and lennon are hits. Attackers are sh1ts!!

 

[MarkTHFC9]

Fail @ the poll

Coming from the failure himself.

 

[hughy]

Coming from the failure himself.

My thoughts...

 

[Chaplain]

So Corluka gets 100% as he's not possible to vote for? Grats to him , he's had a great season.

 

[Darrkespur]

I chose the obvious candidates at first but decided Dos Santos and Taraabt did enough at the level appropriate for them (loan in the Championship) that, for my expectations of them, they probably also deserved to be hits. Following their good buzz on loan, I expect them to challenge for 'hit' status in the first team, if they don't depart.

 

[DJS]

So basically the only thing I have learnt from this poll is that "Crow" is either completely mental or a WUM.

He probably just loves and supports all our players regardless of whether they have performed cackly this season or not! :lol:

Coming from the failure himself.

You seem to quite love Milky. ;-)

 

[VancouverSpurs]

Poll needs a bit more explanation. I defined 'hits' for myself as players who met or exceeded my expectations. A player like Bale was not a hit for me because we all know what he can do, he showed that potential in his first season and since then he's been disappointing. Certainly he shouldn't be sold, but still not a hit.