What's new

Christian Benteke

Hercules

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2014
5,715
156,719
I am told Palace would consider if they can recoup near what they paid, and Benteke is open to listens to offers. Does not at all mean we are signing him.
 

Metalhead

But that's a debate for another thread.....
Nov 24, 2013
25,425
38,457
So...we want until the last few hours of the window...so that the Benteke apple can fall into our laps

Genius strategy
Yeah, well it minimises the risk of Chelsea nipping in with a last minute bid and dashing our hopes.
 

RicOfPeace

Well-Known Member
May 20, 2015
413
1,044
He's better than Janssen.
I think we can list 100s of players that are better than Janssen has been in a Spurs shirt but the problem with any signing like this is its a like for like replacement for Kane who unless injured won't be starting anyway.
And even when he was injured we started Son ahead of Janssen so no wonder the man has no confidence
 

BringBack_leGin

Well-Known Member
Jul 28, 2004
27,719
54,929
He has proven that he can score goals in the prem. to be fair.
This this 100 times this.

We signed the top scorer, young and willing, from a lesser league which has given us and our league many top players. If it is deemed that he's not up to it, and I say IF, it would be stone madness to repeat the tactic in a climate where all strikers cost insane amounts. This guy offers the physical attributes Pochettino favours in a centre forward, is a proven regular goal scorer in this league and has several good years ahead of him.

He's not anybody's dream signing, including my, but to not realise that he dramatically improves our options is bloody minded and spoilt.
 

daveduvet

Well-Known Member
Oct 6, 2008
5,621
15,262
Always get the impression benteke has fallen out of love with football...
he hasn't peaked again since he left Villa
Don't know whether I'd be for or against him being one of ours tbh
 

paulcumpstone

Well-Known Member
Jul 17, 2008
8,781
10,892
I am told Palace would consider if they can recoup near what they paid, and Benteke is open to listens to offers. Does not at all mean we are signing him.
Im sure they would.its like us saying we would consider letting sissoko leave if we could get our money back.at that age players values drop.says all you need to know when they are happy enough to let him go.contrast that with jonny evans.
 

am_yisrael_chai

Well-Known Member
Feb 18, 2006
6,409
10,931
Very similar to Lukaku
Not that you meant it in that way I'm sure but I think that is a pretty racist comment because the only thing they have in common is their nationality, their skin colour and their build, nothing like each other as footballers.
 

am_yisrael_chai

Well-Known Member
Feb 18, 2006
6,409
10,931
This this 100 times this.

We signed the top scorer, young and willing, from a lesser league which has given us and our league many top players. If it is deemed that he's not up to it, and I say IF, it would be stone madness to repeat the tactic in a climate where all strikers cost insane amounts. This guy offers the physical attributes Pochettino favours in a centre forward, is a proven regular goal scorer in this league and has several good years ahead of him.

He's not anybody's dream signing, including my, but to not realise that he dramatically improves our options is bloody minded and spoilt.
I strongly disagree. He would be as big a disaster for us as Darren Bent for exactly the same reasons. They are both very good playing for poor teams with low possession who play on the break and play in high crosses. Put them in a team that dominated possession and they look really poor and their scoring stats fall away. He would be a good signing for WBA but not for us.
 

Danners9

Available on a Free Transfer
Mar 30, 2004
14,018
20,807
I strongly disagree. He would be as big a disaster for us as Darren Bent for exactly the same reasons. They are both very good playing for poor teams with low possession who play on the break and play in high crosses. Put them in a team that dominated possession and they look really poor and their scoring stats fall away. He would be a good signing for WBA but not for us.
I agree. Palace with Benteke and players like Townsend crossing to him was supposed to work, kinda did under Allardyce but de Boer isn't doing that and it seems Townsend might be sold to Leicester. I guess that would be why Benteke could be available as they try to change styles (although de Boer might not last!). It also means Benteke wouldn't work for us. Is he supposed to play with Kane or instead of? I can see that being a disaster as he's not mobile enough to support in any other way than being the guy to knock down long balls, and is such a downgrade on Harry's overall game that we'd all be cursing his name within weeks.
 
Top