thought so, too. dont get the poor ratings this week. he wasnt a stand out but he was solid. Anything less than a 6 is harsh IMO.Is it just me or did Doherty have a fairly solid game ? Barely put a foot wrong and made a nice interception and a few tackles in the second half
Majority of the scores so far are way to high.
Well it’s not just you as you have 3 agrees as I write but I thought he was awful again. He was a turnstile in defence, offered nothing going forward and gave the ball away a bunch. They got in behind on his wing over and over againIs it just me or did Doherty have a fairly solid game ? Barely put a foot wrong and made a nice interception and a few tackles in the second half
Momentum shift back in our favour once Lamela came on. Not sure what game you was watching. The guy is a hunter and basically did what he does best. Got control of the midfield again.No he didn’t. And he wasn’t an 8. Unless it’s a sliding scale that everyone starts On 10 and goes down. Point for every 10 minutes they do something wrong. Pathetic. Yeah he done alright. But he was a 6. He created no chances. Had no shots on target. And made no key passes. So what did he get an 8 for. Running abaaat a bit??
Lamelas performance actually typifies what he brings to the team.Lamela MOTM, he closed out the match for us today.
What would you suggest the team do to deal with an overlapping fullback that is unmarked?Well it’s not just you as you have 3 agrees as I write but I thought he was awful again. He was a turnstile in defence, offered nothing going forward and gave the ball away a bunch. They got in behind on his wing over and over again
I think its both, but doherty’s problems cannot all be blamed on cover. Look at the chance at the end of the first half. First he is beaten comically easily despite being right next to the touch line (meaning there was only one way the attacker could go) then he just idles back instead of busting his balls to get back and make up for his own mistake. If he’d put the efforts in he would have been cutting out the cross. If you are playing like shit you can at least maximise effortWhat would you suggest the team do to deal with an overlapping fullback that is unmarked?
is that the fault of the right back or the right winger?
You’ve avoided answering the question there.I think its both, but doherty’s problems cannot all be blamed on cover. Look at the chance at the end of the first half. First he is beaten comically easily despite being right next to the touch line (meaning there was only one way the attacker could go) then he just idles back instead of busting his balls to get back and make up for his own mistake. If he’d put the efforts in he would have been cutting out the cross. If you are playing like shit you can at least maximise effort
No he didn’t. And he wasn’t an 8. Unless it’s a sliding scale that everyone starts On 10 and goes down. Point for every 10 minutes they do something wrong. Pathetic. Yeah he done alright. But he was a 6. He created no chances. Had no shots on target. And made no key passes. So what did he get an 8 for. Running abaaat a bit??
I don’t get people giving subs an 8. Really boils my piss lamela. Did barely fuck all and gets an 8’ come on.
No he didn’t. And he wasn’t an 8. Unless it’s a sliding scale that everyone starts On 10 and goes down. Point for every 10 minutes they do something wrong. Pathetic. Yeah he done alright. But he was a 6. He created no chances. Had no shots on target. And made no key passes. So what did he get an 8 for. Running abaaat a bit??
He was on for 10 minutes. Check the ratings. Totally skewed. Sorry. No matter how some of the other players played. Most of them gave 70-90 minutes. And you give Lamela and 8.
Subjective is judging it over a set period of time. I didn’t rate Lamela an 8 because he didn’t deserve an 8. Fairly subjective.
I haven’t avoided answering the question. I said it’s both - he didn’t get sufficient protection, but even allowing for that he was still crap, and I gave a good example of his crapness that couldn’t be blamed on the RWYou’ve avoided answering the question there.
The issue was in the second half only, so bringing up something from the first half isn’t really relevant either.
But let’s explore the issue in the second half further.
Basics:
Rb marks lw-
Rw marks lb-
Lb pushed forward to overload the rb- what should any rw do in that scenario?
Last night Andersen plays numerous cross field balls to Robinson who is wide open.
Are we saying that Doherty is at fault because he doesn’t leave his man (lookman) to close this space? Or should it have been bale/ Lucas who was meant to drop and cover?
I know that there are plenty on here still feeding on dohertys carcass. Maybe when they’ve had their fill when can look at why he was left 2v1 in the second half
Is it just me or did Doherty have a fairly solid game ? Barely put a foot wrong and made a nice interception and a few tackles in the second half