I seriously think that if he was to stay my pick would be Berbatov, maybe try him out, it could go very well or very very bad.
Give it to Berbatov if that would make him stay.
thats a great example to the rest. If your any good just threaten to leave and we will make you club captain
I really don't get people saying Jenas when he is not even guaranteed a starting place. The only players who are more or less guaranteed a starting place when fit are Gomes, Hutton, Woodgate, King, Modric, Keane and Berbatov
Of course if Keane stays he will be vice captain. If not that only leaves Woodgate as a real candidate