Bellamy yes or no and why?

lukespurs7

Well-Known Member

Feb 21, 2006

4,833

4,259

• May 24, 2010

• #1

Lots of speculation regarding the possible transfer of the erratic Welshman but would you lot want him in a Spurs shirt and and why/why not?

• Personally I would say yes. Okay he is 30 but still has pace to burn and is a real threat to defenders. He is versetile and we do lack another pacy option he would in essence replace Robbie Keane,and if Redknapp can control Bellamy which I believe he most certaintly can I think he could really do a job for us. I don't think he is quite good enough to be first choice especially as he is getting on a bit now and he is by no means a world-beater but he has fight desire,as I said before pace in abundance and would provide a good different option.

Strikers next season:
Dzeko + Defoe(1st choice) Crouch+Bellamy(2nd choice) thats the dream anyway.

 

MattyP

Advises to have a beer & sleep with prostitutes

May 14, 2007

14,041

2,980

• May 24, 2010

• #2

No, because he is a ****

 

Huddlestone22

Tom Huddlestone

Mar 1, 2007

2,042

2,463

• May 24, 2010

• #3

No if we keep Gudjohnsen and buy Dzeko, however if we sell Keane, Pav and don't retain Gudjohnsen then he'd be a different option to Defoe with pace to burn and can be used on the wings if needed.

 

michaelden

Knight of the Fat Fanny

Aug 13, 2004

26,474

21,855

• May 24, 2010

• #4

No. I can't stand him. Think he'd be a huge disruption to the team

 

lukespurs7

Well-Known Member

Feb 21, 2006

4,833

4,259

• May 24, 2010

• Thread starter
• #5

michaelden said:

No. I can't stand him. Think he'd be a huge disruption to the team

Click to expand...

I think Harry would make sure that wouldn't be the case and that what he brings on the pitch would far make up for it.

 

P

punky

Gone

Sep 23, 2008

7,485

5,403

• May 24, 2010

• #6

Yes he has a bit of pace when his knees work and yes he gives 100% when he wants to but its a no from me.

Trouble follows him around he has left under a cloud at almost every club he's been to. Its only a matter of time before he causes fights with Hary or another player and unsettles the dressing room. He has only been at City 1 season now and caused at least 2 fights to my knowlege. He's a liability that doesn't add anything we don't already have or can't get elsewhere.

 

$hoguN

Well-Known Member

Jul 25, 2005

26,686

34,862

• May 24, 2010

• #7

Yes, because he talent on the pitch far out weighs the fact he is a **** off it

 

Hoowl

Dr wHo(owl)

Staff

Aug 18, 2005

6,527

267

• May 24, 2010

• #8

Tricky one. We really could do with a striker who could play the lone forward role and Bellamy isn't it. This means if we signed Bellamy, we'd could do with another striker too but where does that leave our current four (and Eidur)?

I expect Keane and Pavlyuchenko to leave and then either 2 or 1 and Gudjohnsen to come in. I'd be happy if one of them was Bellamy. He is a good player and has the kind of desire we need.

 

aws_young

Well-Known Member

Oct 24, 2005

2,273

156

• May 24, 2010

• #9

No because if we are going to buy another striker, and we only need one more, let's make it a really high quality one and not someone on the same level that we already have.

 

P

philbcn

Member

Feb 12, 2006

544

1

• May 24, 2010

• #10

MattyP said:

No, because he is a ****

Click to expand...

This. No. On top of being not that good. Not bad but not exceptional.

 

StartingPrice

Chief Sardonicus Hyperlip

Feb 13, 2004

32,568

10,280

• May 24, 2010

• #11

I want a "Yes AND No" option!

Yes - for all of the reasons everyone elsse has given.

No - for THE one reason everyone else has given - he really is a prize CARLTON who has disrupted the dressing room in just about every club he has been in.

 

E

Eric_s

Well-Known Member

Aug 30, 2004

1,561

1,924

• May 24, 2010

• #12

Yes. An upgrade to keane. To me a very good player is a very good player. His pace and finishing will help sustain our challenge on all front.

 

ChrisW81

Active Member

Feb 16, 2006

441

110

• May 24, 2010

• #13

No!
Injury prone.
Too much of a pain in the ar5e

 

yozza

It's Totti, not Shitty.......get it right!

Feb 23, 2004

1,228

457

• May 24, 2010

• #14

Yes.........only if Harry can stop him being a complete ****before and after the 90mins. He's a fiesty bastard, and with the amount of games we will have next season, having someone like that may be a big positive.

 

blanchflower007

Well-Known Member

Jun 20, 2008

901

442

• May 24, 2010

• #15

No - not good enough for the problems that he would bring with him.

 

Kendall

Well-Known Member

Feb 8, 2007

38,502

11,933

• May 24, 2010

• #16

I think he's a great player and has been in the form of his life at City, but he's been playing left side and is not an upgrade on anything we have in that position, so it's a no for me.

 

Locotoro

Prince of Zamunda

Sep 2, 2004

9,465

14,268

• May 24, 2010

• #17

I think he's a very good player but I think he would also create a bit of disruption in the team.

He has been relatively quiet at Man City despite his fallouts with the management, but I attribute that to the extortionate salary he is collected, one which spurs wouldnt match.

I also think at his age he isnt going to get any faster or better. There are better options elsewhere

 

DJS

A hoonter must hoont

Dec 9, 2006

31,279

21,788

• May 24, 2010

• #18

No, because:

- He's injury prone.
- He won't be happy being backup, he will cause problems.
- He's a ****.
- He's overated. Massively.

 

G

gibbs131

Banned

May 20, 2005

8,870

11

• May 24, 2010

• #19

Yes (but only if Keano and Pav are out)

We have enough short arse strikers, but we need more needle/bastards.

 

bubble07

Well-Known Member

Dec 27, 2004

23,295

30,491

• May 24, 2010

• #20

Yes. Last season he really showed what a class player he is and what a genuine threat he his. Bags of premier league experience. If the price is right then I say we should get him. Can operate wide left, wide right and I would assume wide right. Very versatile player who has also played in the champions league