Spurs Community MOTM Awards
- Thread starter chrissivad
- Start date
THFCSPURS19
The Speaker of the Transfer Rumours Forum
- Jan 6, 2013
- 37,899
- 130,564
Well yes, there are a few inaccuracies. I cannot see how JV (and arguably even Lloris) is higher than Dier, Alli, Rose and Lamela. Toby or Dembele should also be the highest.
Looking at it more, the 'performance score' seems to be an accumulation of different scores such as the 'Attacking score', 'Defensive score' and 'Possession score'. When I compare players and post it on here, I leave out these scores as they are incredibly vague, and also depend on how many appearances a player has made.
Also, I've just had a look, and according to these scores, Aston Villa defenders (the team with a disastrous defensive record) Joleon Lescott and Micah Richards supposedly performed better than Lamela. They were also better than Wimmer apparently.
mark87
Well-Known Member
- Nov 29, 2004
- 36,269
- 115,411
Sorry but that's utter horse shit.
How times did our performances drop when he got subbed at 60/65 minutes? Countless times. And why? Because he keeps the tempo high with his tireless running and harassing and our style of play requires a high tempo in order to be played effectively.
Granted he may not have got as many league goals as we all hoped and he is by no means perfect but his performances went up ten fold this past season and deserves more credit from some.
TriXed
Well-Known Member
- Aug 19, 2011
- 489
- 637
You kinda just proved my point there... soo great this season and we are all relieved it's happened and glad we finally got a player...was a more of a tongue in cheek line.
mark87
Well-Known Member
- Nov 29, 2004
- 36,269
- 115,411
Didn't prove your point at all, I'm basing it on this season and nothing else.
TriXed
Well-Known Member
- Aug 19, 2011
- 489
- 637
And I'm not ignoring previous seasons into why people may vote for him over others who were equally as good in matches..
Either way, we are both arguing that we thought Lamela was excellent this season... was just trying to give my view on why he got more votes.
chrissivad
Staff
- May 20, 2005
- 51,646
- 58,072
- Thread starter
- Staff
- #28
Top 5 (So top 5 from each poll)
Top = 5 points / 2nd = 4 points / 3rd = 3 points / 4th = 2 points / 5th = 1 point
99 - Lamela
77 - Dembele
74 - Eriksen
69 - Toby
58 - Alli
55 - Rose
51- Lloris
42 - Dier
38 -Kane
30- Mason
25 - Walker
24 - Carroll
23 - Son
19 - Vertonghen
17 - Trippier
14 - Chadli
13 - Davies
13 - Wimmer
10 - Onomah
2 - Clinton
2- Townsend
1 - Bentaleb
Top = 5 points / 2nd = 4 points / 3rd = 3 points / 4th = 2 points / 5th = 1 point
99 - Lamela
77 - Dembele
74 - Eriksen
69 - Toby
58 - Alli
55 - Rose
51- Lloris
42 - Dier
38 -Kane
30- Mason
25 - Walker
24 - Carroll
23 - Son
19 - Vertonghen
17 - Trippier
14 - Chadli
13 - Davies
13 - Wimmer
10 - Onomah
2 - Clinton
2- Townsend
1 - Bentaleb
Lufti
Well-Known Member
- Jan 3, 2013
- 7,994
- 16,635
So you think 2788 votes are down to agendas? Riiiiiight
Blake Griffin
Well-Known Member
- Oct 3, 2011
- 14,171
- 38,507
7 of the 10 games he got motm in we didn't win. i think when the rest of the team is below par, lamela often becomes the default pick because of his energy and work rate.
THFCSPURS19
The Speaker of the Transfer Rumours Forum
- Jan 6, 2013
- 37,899
- 130,564
He also won it vs. United, but @chrissivad hasn't added that for some reason.
Blake Griffin
Well-Known Member
- Oct 3, 2011
- 14,171
- 38,507
yeah mine says he won 13 so there's two other games to account for too, i didn't keep a record of which particular games they were in though.
chrissivad
Staff
- May 20, 2005
- 51,646
- 58,072
- Thread starter
- Staff
- #33
he has 13, i have managed to take a few lines out, will be updated in a min
chrissivad
Staff
- May 20, 2005
- 51,646
- 58,072
- Thread starter
- Staff
- #34
Chelsea, Man U and Norwich were missed
Blake Griffin
Well-Known Member
- Oct 3, 2011
- 14,171
- 38,507
by the way, i also have toby on 5, dembele on 7, eriksen, alli and kane all on 4, hugo on 2 and chadli on 1(you gave him alli's motm vs palace).
sorry
UpTownSpur
Says it like it is
- Dec 31, 2014
- 2,266
- 4,362
The SC MOTM Cumulative Points Tally Award is nothing to be sniffed at and Erik should feel pleased to have won it. I would be happy to contribute to buying him a trophy, this one perhaps:
http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Football-...372502?hash=item2eefd77d16:g:g0YAAOSwGotWkjMi
However, I was just pointing out that, outside of SC, there is no objective evidence to suggest his performances were superior to several other players in the vast amount of games be was voted MOTM in these forums. And there are in fact multiple pieces of evidence that players like Kane, Dembele, Toby and Eriksen consistently out performed him, and Squawka is just one of those, where Lamela won 2 "best" awards and 17 "worst" - a total no one else came near. The cause of this discrepancy is open to speculation. Sympathy? A willingness for him to succeed? But as I said, congratulations to him.
- Feb 1, 2005
- 55,694
- 205,833
- Admin
- #38
If the voting is agenda driven then the whole thing becomes a massively pointless exercise and whilst there may well be an element of that its not to the extent that it determines the whole affair because if its true of the winner then its also true of whoever comes second or third etc etc, so the whole suggestion of agendas is pretty ridiculous.
But then again........this is SC
But then again........this is SC
Ionman34
SC Supporter
- Jun 1, 2011
- 7,182
- 16,793
Which is a fair reason for voting him MOTM.
King of Otters
Well-Known Member
- Jun 11, 2012
- 10,751
- 36,094
SC loves a trier.
