- Mar 2, 2006
- 428
- 67
I think the fact that BC is one of the most articulate posters on here and generally writes a very informative ratings review means that his opinion on players carries more weight on this board than most other peoples. Regardless of whether they are true or not.
The criticism Walker and Dawson get on this board is way over the top. There is no way we would have the second best defence in the league and concede our first goal in the Europa in our 7th game if these two were as bad as people make out.
Walker is by some distance the best right back we have, and one of the top right backs in the league. Yes his pace is the main attribute and gets him out of trouble, but that shouldn't be seen as a negative.
Dawson has been a great servant to this club and is still an asset. With Kaboul not fit yet he should still be in our 1st choice 11. Yes he has had some bad games but he has had many very strong performances this season as well, particularly against Lukaku.
The criticism Walker and Dawson get on this board is way over the top. There is no way we would have the second best defence in the league and concede our first goal in the Europa in our 7th game if these two were as bad as people make out.
Walker is by some distance the best right back we have, and one of the top right backs in the league. Yes his pace is the main attribute and gets him out of trouble, but that shouldn't be seen as a negative.
Dawson has been a great servant to this club and is still an asset. With Kaboul not fit yet he should still be in our 1st choice 11. Yes he has had some bad games but he has had many very strong performances this season as well, particularly against Lukaku.