Spurs Community MOTM Awards

chrissivad · Sep 26, 2015


Vs Man United	Vs Stoke	Vs Leicester	Vs Everton	Vs Palace
Vs Anderlecht	Vs Sunderland	Vs Liverpool	.	Vs Leicester
Vs Chelsea	.	Vs Aston Villa	.	Vs Crystal Palace
Vs Borussia Dortmund	.	Vs Southampton	.	.
Vs Borussia Dortmund	.	Vs Sunderland	.	.
.	.	Vs West Brom	.	.

Vs Arsenal	Vs Man City	Vs Swansea	Vs Bournemouth	Vs West Brom
Vs Man City	Vs Monaco	Vs Swansea	Vs Aston Villa	Liverpool
.	Vs Arsenal	Vs West Ham	Vs Norwich	.
.	Vs Monaco	Vs Stoke	Vs Bournemouth	.
.	Vs Newcastle	.	.	.
.	Vs Watford	.	.	.
.	Vs Leicester		.	.
.	Vs Arsenal	.	.	.
.	Vs Southampton	.	.	.
.	Vs Newcastle	.	.	.
.	Vs Chelsea	.	.	.
.	Vs ManU	.	.	.
.	Vs Norwich	.	.	.
				.
Vs Everton	Vs Leicester	Vs Crystal Palace	Vs Watford	.
Vs Fiorentina	.	.	.	.
Vs Fiorentina	.	.	.	.
Vs Crystal Palace	.	.	.	.

]

Kane	Rose	Dier	Lloris	Son

2788	1551	1427	1303	1079
1026	957	939	712	586
Mason	Trippier	Walker	Chadli	Vertonghen
528	527	480	286	246
Carroll	Davies	Wimmer	Onomah	Townsend
240	172	155	60	29
Bentaleb	Clinton	Vorm	Fazio
24	9	8	8

Most Votes Made In A Game: Vs Man City (Away) 758

chrissivad · Sep 26, 2015

lukespurs7 · Sep 26, 2015

great thread.

whitelanefever · Sep 26, 2015

chrissivad said:
@Rob any idea why the bb code if putting huge gaps at the top of each table?

If you put on your show/hide button on word it will show what it is.. probably a page break.. just delete it

chrissivad · Sep 26, 2015

whitelanefever said:
If you put on your show/hide button on word it will show what it is.. probably a page break.. just delete it

Cheers

Its the formatting, BBCode has to be on one line.
Makes it messy and harder to edit, but cant do much about that...

whitelanefever · Sep 26, 2015

chrissivad said:
Cheers

Its the formatting, BBCode has to be on one line.
Makes it messy and harder to edit, but cant do much about that...

try shortening your text & line spacing, if you add a section brake you can turn off formatting on the first part of your document

chrissivad · Nov 8, 2015

updated to the home game vs Anderlecht

thinktank · Nov 8, 2015

Can't believe I wasn't aware of this thread - epic.

THFCSPURS19 · Nov 8, 2015

There are two Dembeles @chrissivad

Larryjanta · Nov 8, 2015

This just shows the Lamela skew - I'm a big fan and he's been excellent this season but, by the above, he's apparently been head and shoulders above everyone else. Kind of devalues the whole thing when certain sections on here would give him their vote even if he scored 4 own goals, shagged Kane to the point of breaking and twatted Poch.

Not a dig at Lamela as he's been very good but, come on guys, stop being so ridiculous.

chrissivad · Nov 8, 2015

thinktank said:
Can't believe I wasn't aware of this thread - epic.

Have left it quet as the start of the season wont show much. Should be better as the season goes

THFCSPURS19 said:
There are two Dembeles @chrissivad

cheers, have combined his 2

Larryjanta said:
This just shows the Lamela skew - I'm a big fan and he's been excellent this season but, by the above, he's apparently been head and shoulders above everyone else. Kind of devalues the whole thing when certain sections on here would give him their vote even if he scored 4 own goals, shagged Kane to the point of breaking and twatted Poch.

Not a dig at Lamela as he's been very good but, come on guys, stop being so ridiculous.

I don't think thats happening.
Have each of the votes in a spread sheet, and while there are some strange voting, its only a small number. The problem is number of posters voting each time. We had over 700 voted in the City game (most to Lamela)and other ones have just over 250 votes in total.

Alderweireld is the same where he has picked up most of his votes in 1 match.
Dier have been the most consistent, but not as many votes in the last few games, and Mason the most impressive considering the games he has missed with injury.

An average ratings would be fantastic, but just a lot of work to go through each post in the thread. Would give the best indicator of how their season has been

THFCSPURS19 · Nov 8, 2015

chrissivad said:
Have left it quet as the start of the season wont show much. Should be better as the season goes

cheers, have combined his 2

I don't think thats happening.
Have each of the votes in a spread sheet, and while there are some strange voting, its only a small number. The problem is number of posters voting each time. We had over 700 voted in the City game (most to Lamela)and other ones have just over 250 votes in total.

Alderweireld is the same where he has picked up most of his votes in 1 match.
Dier have been the most consistent, but not as many votes in the last few games, and Mason the most impressive considering the games he has missed with injury.

An average ratings would be fantastic, but just a lot of work to go through each post in the thread. Would give the best indicator of how their season has been

The Qarabag MOTM also isn't up there

Blake Griffin · Nov 8, 2015

if i'd known about this thread I wouldn't have bothered to keep a record myself. anyway, here's mine up to the anderlecht game

assigning 1st place 3 points, 2nd place 2 points and 3rd place 1 point.

dembele 13
dier 13
lamela 9
alderweireld 8
mason 8
rose 7
eriksen 6
alli 5
lloris 4
kane 3
son 3
vertonghen 2
walker 2
carroll 1

and as an average per appearance(sub apps count as .25)

dembele 1.53
mason 1.39
rose 1.17
dier 1.08
lamela 0.92
son 0.86
alderweireld 0.62
eriksen 0.59
alli 0.51
carroll 0.44
lloris 0.33
kane 0.21
walker 0.18
vertonghen 0.15

chrissivad · Nov 8, 2015

THFCSPURS19 said:
The Qarabag MOTM also isn't up there

There wasn't a vote/poll only ratings so that's why

chrissivad · Jun 3, 2016

updated to include the last game

L-man · Jun 3, 2016

THFCSPURS19 · Jun 3, 2016

BREAKING: @UpTownSpur demands investigation into corruption at Spurs Community after Erik Lamela wins most MOTM votes.

UpTownSpur · Jun 3, 2016

Larryjanta said:
This just shows the Lamela skew - I'm a big fan and he's been excellent this season but, by the above, he's apparently been head and shoulders above everyone else. Kind of devalues the whole thing when certain sections on here would give him their vote even if he scored 4 own goals, shagged Kane to the point of breaking and twatted Poch.

Not a dig at Lamela as he's been very good but, come on guys, stop being so ridiculous.

Agree, the Squawka ratings and awards are a much more accurate reflection of a player's influence as there are no agendas or rose tinted spectacles involved. The comparison between Eriksen and Lamela is most interesting, and most at odds with the above ratings.

http://www.squawka.com/teams/totten...eason-2015/2016#165#all-matches#1-38#by-match

If you click on a player it will show you their accumulated rating over the season, and also how many "best" awards they won and how many "worst" ones as well.

THFCSPURS19 · Jun 3, 2016

UpTownSpur said:
Agree, the Squawka ratings and awards are a much more accurate reflection of a player's influence as there are no agendas or rose tinted spectacles involved. The comparison between Eriksen and Lamela is most interesting, and most at odds with the above ratings.

http://www.squawka.com/teams/totten...eason-2015/2016#165#all-matches#1-38#by-match

If you click on a player it will show you their accumulated rating over the season, and also how many "best" awards they won and how many "worst" ones as well.

Oh come on. Lamela may not have deserved to have the most votes, but this says that Lamela was not MOTM once, was the worst player in the match 3 times, and the worst player in our team 6 times.

UpTownSpur · Jun 3, 2016

THFCSPURS19 said:
Oh come on. Lamela may not have deserved to have the most votes, but this says that Lamela was not MOTM once, was the worst player in the match 3 times, and the worst player in our team 6 times.

Take it up with Squawka, not me:

http://www.squawka.com/contact-us

Do the other ratings seem pretty accurate? They do to me. Four players have 1000 + ratings. Kane, Toby, Dembele and Eriksen. Is that not an accurate reflection of who has been our best players? So why would Lamela be the only one who's rating is somehow grossly inaccurate? The numbers don't lie. And I think they also show who on this forum is the most astute judge of players.

Forums

What's new

Matches

Sportsbook

Members

Spurs Community MOTM Awards

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Hmmm...

The Speaker of the Transfer Rumours Forum

Well-Known Member

The Speaker of the Transfer Rumours Forum

Well-Known Member

Misplaced pass from Dier

The Speaker of the Transfer Rumours Forum

Says it like it is

The Speaker of the Transfer Rumours Forum

Says it like it is

Similar threads