- Aug 23, 2006
- 8,386
- 3,122
I certainly won't argue that Rooney is the best, most complete player in the Prem. I think SC has, on the whole been quite fair here, of course a Spurs tinted bias is inevitable, but not as partial as I expected.
Great thread IOMLS, I hope it is repeated, perhaps in May.I'm not sure. I'd probably say he should be below Van Persie, but I can see the argument for Van Persie being lower because his injuries keep him out a lot. At the level David Silva is playing now he'd be up there too, but last season he wasn't even close to how he is playing now. Is that because of the protection he has playing in a better team? Not sure.
Rooney is probably the most complete player of all of those even if he isn't bang at the top of his form like Silva and Van Persie. I don't think any of them would get close to the top of an all time Premiership list though.
Great work IOMLS, now to the real mcoy - which team has the best players!
Good analysis.
Surprised that Manu is so low while i dont think everton should be top 10